9 ms·
I've been working in my little corner of the world to re-frame the conversation. Socializing medicine isn't about restricting your freedom to choose your physic
by arcticbull 8y ago
I've been working in my little corner of the world to re-frame the conversation. Socializing medicine isn't about restricting your freedom to choose your physician, it's the freedom from. Freedom from fear of losing your job, freedom from fear of having to change your doctor if you do, freedom to pick any doctor (they're all in-network), freedom from fear of starting a new business, freedom from fear of death and bankruptcy if anything goes wrong -- and it does, to all of us, eventually. Socialized medicine is freedom, and private medicine just isn't.
- sologoub 8y agoThis. Especially - freedom to pick any doctor as they are all in-network. Family had experience with California PCIP insurance (bridge for pre-existing condition after ACA was voted in, but before it took effect). The PCIP was amazing - PPO-like benefits, using MediCare network (close to 100% doctors take it) and quality services. Of course, unfortunately, the ACA/exchange provided policies are nowhere close to how good PCIP was. If we could get the PCIP-like option, it would truly change lives for the better.
- mises 8y ago> freedom to pick any doctor Any doctor? Doctors can take so many patients. Though it may benefit a large number of people, some may end up worse. Those who have the best doctors currently (because they can pay) may no longer be able to have those doctors.
- beat 8y agoYou realize that's a terrible argument, right?
- mises 8y agoOk, why? I'm more than open to being convinced otherwise; I'd love to think no one would be harmed.
- beat 8y agoFirst, it's unlikely that an influx of new patients due to opening networks and increasing coverage would lead to doctors dropping existing patients. On what grounds would that happen? Second, you're at best arguing that we shouldn't go to a fair system of rationing because it would hurt the beneficiaries of an unfair system of rationing. And to take this sideways... my favorite health care model is the Japanese system. It's actually quite similar to the American system (private employer-provided insurance, private providers), but with one key difference... a government commission fixes the prices for all medical goods and services. No more negotiating between providers and insurers. So no "networks". It leads directly to the situation you described. It also leads to costing half as much as the US, for universal coverage and better outcomes. I'll take that trade, thank you.
- mises 8y ago> it's unlikely that an influx of new patients due to opening networks and increasing coverage would lead to doctors dropping existing patients. It wouldn't, but if I needed to get a doctor, I might no longer be able to get a very good one. Remember that cheaper prices for medical care means the smartest, best people may not become doctors. > you're at best arguing that we shouldn't go to a fair system of rationing because it would hurt the beneficiaries of an unfair system of rationing. I don't believe the current system is "unfair". Why is it? Most Americans like what they have; it is the bottom few percent who are unhappy. Is that "unfair"? At what percentage does that become the case? Must most of society change to accommodate a small, dissatisfied minority? Without government regulation, health care would be much cheaper. Why must I purchase coverage for a hysterectomy or for birth control as part of a plan? I will never need these services. Wasted money. What of experimental treatments? I know a person who is alive thanks to an experimental treatment that was reasonably priced. All it amounted to was an antibiotic regimen far outside the bounds of the CDC-recommended one, out-patient. The problem with single-payer is that I cannot do that, because there is a single payer - the feds. I may not pay for my own procedures (and my friend would not have been able to do so), even though this was quite affordable, because it was not on "the list". Fixing prices is a possibility (albeit not one of which I am as fond), though we would need to allow procedures to be done out side of that (for those which were not approved, or for those who could not get availability and could pay). It is basic economics that price ceilings create shortages; who gets treatment? We are back at square one: I think it should be ordered by those who should pay. I trust dollars to be "fairer" than an opaque system, and would rather the coverage I can get be a known quantity than be at the mercy of the whims of a bureaucrat. My biggest question: why do you want to force those who can pay onto the same plan? That is a part of single-payer that makes no sense. Why not let those who like their existing coverage keep it, as most Americans still do? [0] There was an article that surfaced about an Indian hospital that had industrialized common health-care procedures. A four-year degree is not essential for these; why is it required? If we commoditize common and routine procedures via removal of barriers to entry, we can greatly increase the benefit without forcing those who like what they have to become worse off and without hurting more complicated situations. Lastly, the problem with socialized medicine is that it cannot afford to spend beyond a certain amount per-person on average. End-of-life care is enormously expensive in America, but is better than in other places. [1] Many of us may say it is foolish to spend upwards of a million dollars for a few more years of life, but having spoken to a few dying people, most say something to the effect of that they would give every thing they have for a few more weeks (the exception being those in exceptional pain, those with loss of senses, etc.). EDIT: Downvoters care to comment? [0] https://news.gallup.com/poll/245195/americans-rate-healthcare-quite-positively.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/245195/americans-rate-healthcar... [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/cjarlotta/2016/01/19/end-of-life-care-costs-in-us-comparable-to-europe-and-canada/#350a2305ada3 https://www.forbes.com/sites/cjarlotta/2016/01/19/end-of-lif...
- giggles_giggles 8y agoSocialized medicine is freedom until the government is the only provider of medicine and doesn't want to serve you for some reason, such as a shortage. Medicine is scarce, like food, and we've learned that it's dangerous to have the government be the sole provider of food (see: breadlines and starvation in various Communist nations like Venezuela today). I have a real hard time agreeing with the concept that the government should have a monopoly on any necessary item, because then the government gets an unchecked choice about who gets the good and who doesn't. Since we're talking in this thread about employer-provided healthcare, HMOs, I fail to see how recognizing that adding bureaucracy to healthcare didn't work leads to the line of thinking that the solution is to change the bureaucracy into a government bureaucracy and expect that to work better. To me this sounds like we passed a law that caused a problem (the employer mandate) and now think that more of the same kind of law that created the problem in the first place will resolve it? No, we need a solution that is less encumbered with red tape and public policy, not one that is more tied to politics. Socialized medicine is just HMOs dialed up to 11 and with all choice (what little remains today) removed. I'd like to just see the employer mandate repealed. Anyway, I'm ready for my downvotes for disagreeing with the hive, but I thought I'd try to contribute to the discussion. They're only imaginary internet points.
- einarvollset 8y ago> Socialized medicine is freedom until the government is the only provider of medicine and doesn't want to serve you for some reason, such as a shortage. Medicine is scarce, like food, and we've learned that it's dangerous to have the government be the sole provider of food (see: breadlines and starvation in various Communist nations like Venezuela today). This is obviously total and utter nonsense. Look at every other western country. Nobody is banning you (or your employer) from buying additional private health insurance. It's simply providing a basic level of service in this arena, just like roads, army, police, fire, health and safety, etc, etc, etc. Comparing government provided healthcare to Venezuela is a straw man.
- arcticbull 8y ago> This is obviously total and utter nonsense. Look at every other western country. Nobody is banning you (or your employer) from buying additional private health insurance. It is in fact illegal in Canada under federal law: private clinics are not legally allowed to provide services covered by the Canada Health Act. I'm still for it, though, and the rest of your point stands. It's just like roads, army, fire, etc. > Comparing government provided healthcare to Venezuela is a straw man. It 100% is a straw man.
- turk73 8y agoIf the US goes "single payer" aka "paid through taxes" I'm retiring at whatever age I am when that goes into effect. I would have enough money to retire early except I can't estimate future health care expenses. I tried to downshift in 2017 but ended up having a $1400/mo health ins. payment for my family and me and that was more than my mortgage, which was about $650/mo. At least with the mortgage you know your future costs. I have since paid off the mortgage, so if we stay put, I have only property taxes to worry about. Now, the last question is: What will taxpayers bearing the cost of everyone'se healthcare do to my taxes? The US is $21 Trillion in the hole and counting. I won't be paying much income tax, only taxes on capital gains and dividends. My only other concern is that food prices keep rising like crazy, so do things like car insurance, homeowners' insurance, bills, etc. I don't like private health ins--I work at a major provider and I know full well how billions get wasted. However, I think government taking it over is going to be the worst thing the US has seen since probably the Civil War. I'm certainly not paying for it all, you can go figure it out for yourselves.
- arcticbull 8y ago> If the US goes "single payer" aka "paid through taxes" I'm retiring at whatever age I am when that goes into effect. I would have enough money to retire early except I can't estimate future health care expenses. Do it! We've got more people than jobs necessary anyways, certainly once automation enters full swing. > I tried to downshift in 2017 but ended up having a $1400/mo health ins. payment for my family and me and that was more than my mortgage, which was about $650/mo. At least with the mortgage you know your future costs. This sounds like single payer will provide you with freedom. > Now, the last question is: What will taxpayers bearing the cost of everyone's healthcare do to my taxes? The US is $21 Trillion in the hole and counting. I won't be paying much income tax, only taxes on capital gains and dividends. Even a Koch funded study found that the cost of providing cover is +/- 5%-ish the amount we're spending on medical cover right now, and other studies have shown Medicare does a better job of controlling costs than private insurers. The way the system would be executed is that the amount employers are currently paying private insurers would be redirected to the public purse, either via payroll tax or via personal income tax, or both. No new money needs to suddenly appear from thin air, it's just getting re-allocated. You won't be paying much income tax, others will. Dividends are usually treated as ordinary income, FWIW. > I don't like private health ins--I work at a major provider and I know full well how billions get wasted. However, I think government taking it over is going to be the worst thing the US has seen since probably the Civil War. I'm certainly not paying for it all, you can go figure it out for yourselves. And yet you were planning to go on Medicare right? People in America seem to like Medicare. Why is it socialized medicine only becomes "good" once you hit 65? It's like parents trying to explain alcohol to children: It's really really bad until you turn 21 then suddenly its really really good.