5 ms·
What's the incentive for a shop to provide this info? From their PoV they provide it in the itemizations. You can do with that what you will. It's in the sho
by gumby 8y ago
What's the incentive for a shop to provide this info? From their PoV they provide it in the itemizations. You can do with that what you will.
It's in the shop's interest to use an antipattern that obscures detail so you don't reflect on where your money is going, and possibly choose to spend less.
- iddan 8y agoThe company interest is also to give customers value
- firethief 8y agoValue as judged by the customers, not rational actors. Useful as this is, drawing more focus to costs would drive customers to shop elsewhere. A version of this I could see shops actually implementing would be a graph of the "savings" per-item, a metric which is essentially meaningless but gives people savvy feelings.
- IggleSniggle 8y agoI disagree. I would prefer to shop at a place that showed me this. It would increase my loyalty to that grocer. The downside to the grocer is that I might be less inclined to buy meat, but maybe that still works because I instead gravitate to expensive veg options and look at my percent spend and celebrate my good decision making. The only way this would drive me to use a different grocery is if it did a price comparison vs other grocers and I discovered I was getting screwed...but even then, if it was marginal, I’m not sure I would change grocer. Edit: currently, as a shopper, you are most likely to just look at the bottom line. I think you are right that grocer adoption would be complicated from a business decision perspective, but I think implementation of this would hit “brand names” more than anyone else. It’s in both the grocers and shoppers best interest.
- firethief 8y agoI never said no one would like it, so your counterexample isn't a basis to disagree unless you think most people are as rational as you [think you are] in the checkout line (they aren't). Besides, our own assessments of our preferences are notoriously inaccurate. It would be logical for you to like it, but I'll believe you actually do when you make choices reflecting the preference. Which you'll never have a chance to do unless some store's marketing department thinks this is a good idea.
- IggleSniggle 8y agoYou are right, I am disagreeing on the basis of speculation based on my own experiences and preferences. I assumed you were making an argument from the same place? That said, you are right, we will likely never have the opportunity to test this particular preference. So, from the place of my personal experience: I am sucker like everyone else, and prefer stores that tell me a per-unit price that I can compare like-to-like brands, often to the point of irrationality. I will also grant that I could have a backlash on this if it makes the receipts unduly long, which is a reason for me to prefer RiteAid over CVS. Plenty of reasons not to like this. I just don't personally believe that drawing attention to price would be a reason for me to stop shopping at a place, although it would (hopefully) alter my buying habits within said store.
- firethief 8y ago> You are right, I am disagreeing on the basis of speculation based on my own experiences and preferences. I assumed you were making an argument from the same place? Actually, no. I too think I have logical preferences and would prefer the additional information--but I don't think typical shoppers would respond well to it, possibly including myself (because I don't know if I would act in accordance with my estimation of my hypothetical preferences). So I'm making my argument from psychological principles, and in particular by inferring what supermarkets know about the psychology of typical shoppers (because I'm not an expert, but I assume the people the big supermarkets consult to stay competitive are the best in the field). > So, from the place of my personal experience: I am sucker like everyone else, and prefer stores that tell me a per-unit price that I can compare like-to-like brands, often to the point of irrationality. If that's what people actually want, stores have no idea what they're doing. The supermarket where I usually shop uses different units for the "unit prices" of different brands, so if I want to compare unit prices I have to do the math myself. The information they highlight tends to be the "sales", which serve to: convey a feeling of beating the system (even when they're so common, taking the sale obviously just means not paying the sucker price); and constantly invalidate all previous price comparisons for commodities like coffee where in-depth price comparison would otherwise make sense. > I just don't personally believe that drawing attention to price would be a reason for me to stop shopping at a place, although it would (hopefully) alter my buying habits within said store. I wouldn't expect anyone would think they'd be unhappy to have the additional information, because people consistently assume their behavior is logical. Ha.
- xrd 8y agoI don't know a lot about supermarket economics but I recall seeing articles about how supermarkets put impulse food right by the checkout. I just succumbed to that, and when I'm with my kids, I get chills when I see Paw Patrol or Frozen branded crap. That is intentional by the store and gives me zero value. Also recently heard a story on NPR about the dynamics of shelf space. No one who needs to get that space other than a Canadian company would talk on record. And, if I heard correctly, not only do you pay for placement, but you can pay to position your competitors. https://www.npr.org/2019/04/30/718711109/how-grocery-shelves-get-stacked https://www.npr.org/2019/04/30/718711109/how-grocery-shelves... For these reasons, I really like that online shopping is becoming an option. But, I'm not sure Amazon will use any fewer dark patterns to fill their virtual shelf space.
- gumby 8y agoI like to think so but it rarely feels that way.
- umvi 8y ago> It's in the shop's interest to use an antipattern that obscures detail so you don't reflect on where your money is going, and possibly choose to spend less. On the flip side, any grocery store that does this will automatically get my business, because I like this feature.
- mbrumlow 8y agoSeems like a lot of effort to get one umvi to shop at their store. They will likely have to push this out across an entire chain. I see your point, but I don't think the average user will care about this, and it would be a huge cost to get a handful of like minded people. The cost will be huge because nothing like this would ever be free/cheap.
- lallysingh 8y agoIf you're worried about competition, this is a way to make customers happier without reducing your prices or primary costs -- just a software update on the register.
- mbrumlow 8y agoI think that is easy for much of the HN crowd to say -- where things like updates are a daily occurrence. But I think the world of POS systems is much slower, and requires a lot of testing and read tape to make even a simple change. I think the cost of updating some of these systems would be much more than one might think -- and many of them probably will require hardware changes. The point I am trying to make is -- updating the format of the receipt across a fleet of POS systems is probably very expensive. We have not even factored in the cost of what looks like extra ink, ware and tare adding graphics. It all adds up and is a big cost for something that 90+% of the time finds its self in the garbage.
- Faark 8y agoNot US (so correct me if wrong), but the CVS receipt sees to be its own meme, making me doubt ink and paper are a significant factor. And no one is expecting them to change there usual roll-out process for such a change.
- asveikau 8y ago> What's the incentive for a shop to provide this info? Doing something nice for other humans. Oh wait a minute, I guess you thought we all exist only to make boatloads of money. Yeah, let's stick with mediocre things then! That'll really make 'em pay.
- typon 8y ago> Oh wait a minute, I guess you thought we all exist only to make boatloads of money. We live in a capitalist system after all
- asveikau 8y agoLiving in a capitalist economy and existing for capitalism are distinct things, but I understand why people would miss that.
- gumby 8y agoThat seems to be the recipe of most retail businesses, especially grocery stores: treat the customer as a cow to be milked It's one reason I do as much as I can to buy from owner-operated small businesses.
- tux1968 8y agoIt might be taken up as a feature for POS companies as a competitive advantage. I can hear it now... "The point of sale is your last chance to leave a positive impression with your customers. This feature will keep your store in their minds as they consider their shopping habits back at home. Buy the Acme integrated POS system and make your management, staff, AND customers happy".
- booleandilemma 8y agoWhat about a receipt that shows you how much you would have spent had you shopped at a competitor?
- Symbiote 8y agoSome British supermarkets do (or did?) that. Sainsbury's give a voucher for the difference, if it was more expensive than equivalent shops. https://www.alamy.com/stock-photo-brand-match-receipts-from-sainsburys-supermarket-showing-how-much-48549984.html https://www.alamy.com/stock-photo-brand-match-receipts-from-...
- JohnFen 8y agoSome stores in my neck of the woods did this a couple of decades back. I think everyone stopped because it's pointless. It adds expense for the stores, and it looks like marketing, so few people actually trust the amounts.