4 ms·
The argument discussed was literally Apple trying to argue that you aren't their customer for the purpose of legal liability while you pay them money to install
by michaelmrose 8y ago
The argument discussed was literally Apple trying to argue that you aren't their customer for the purpose of legal liability while you pay them money to install apps from their store on a device they configured to only be able to buy from their store.
This decision makes clear that legal weasels lost.
Understanding next steps requires constructing the argument correctly. One could ask why should Apple be forced to open "their" phone for example. This too would be weasel words because nobody on earth is asking Apple to open the phones in their pockets.
A more reasonable person might ask that Apple allow owners to control THEIR OWN PHONES.
You ask erroneously if BMW should have to stock ford Trucks. This isn't remotely analogous. This is asking if BMW owners ought to have to go to a BMW gas station, seek repairs only at BMW owned service stations. Listen to BWM approved music on BMW approved stereos.
Fundamentally using control of a users device after sale to maximize future revenue is inappropriate and the only remedy is to give users full control.
- Spivak 8y agoLook I want to have full control of my devices but I don't think owning the physical hardware entitles you to any rights other than you may do with the device as-is as you please. If we decide that designing a toaster to only accept $vendor's bread is illegal that's all well and good but the justification for such a law will be that it's monopolistic behavior, not that the end user owns the toaster.
- moron4hire 8y agoIt's really hard to prove that a person who paid money for an object in their hand, without an explicit leasing agreement, is not the "owner" of that object. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Possession_is_nine-tenths_of_the_law https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Possession_is_nine-tenths_of... Without a compelling, court-tested, legal precedent for Apple to claim "you don't own that iPhone in your hand", the assumption is that you do, regardless of what the EULA might say. EULAs that are contrary to standing law are not valid. The fact that one can buy iPhones on the secondary market lends credence to notion that consumers own their devices. And given that Atari and Nintendo both tried, and failed, to make similar arguments against 3rd party software manufacturers, I think it's pretty clear which way the courts would go, if it were to ever be tested. We don't live in a society where corporations get to make up whatever rules they want, as long as they can convince someone to sign on the dotted line.
- michaelmrose 8y agoThe thing is that fundamentally you can in software undermine any degree of real ownership. Say I sell you a car outright. I decide to push an update that bricks the car and pops up a window on the in dash entertainment with an offer to re enable it for a monthly fee or an offer to buy it back for pennies on the dollar. I think we can agree that I basically just stole your car and offered to rent it to you. My ability to control the heart of your device means we can either - spend the next century litigating in what fashion and circumstances I am and am not allowed to fuck you and to what degree while hoping that the side with the deepest pockets doesn't win most rounds - pretend that the dysfunctional hand of the free market is capable of solving a complex societal problem this time - admit that the privileges and rights that we already acknowledge and value implicitly must include the right to access and modify the software included or they can literally be taken away wholly or in part for the increasing percentage of things that include a chip. I think this is true implicitly but am entirely open on the idea of spelling this out explicitly in terms of additional laws and lawsuits. Are you really on the side of the weasels?
- Spivak 8y agoI'm in no way saying that companies should be allowed to do evil things like that, only that the justification for preventing them would be consumer protection, not device ownership. Which I guess in your world is option 1. I actually think the option 1 world would actually be better than deriving rights from device ownership because then it would be super easy to get around by renting devices or by using SaaS services; consumer protection litigation protects you against various types of fucking in all cases. I don't really want to live in a world where companies are allowed to be maximally evil with their software but it's okay because you are technically allowed to replace it with your own. All this would do is allow a tiny tiny fraction of the population to enjoy their devices while everyone else would be fucked. I'm on the side of "I would personally love if companies were required to allow/support device modification but the justification for such a thing is weak and wouldn't actually protect or solve problems for consumers."
- michaelmrose 8y agoCan't we just own our hardware AND have consumer protections?
- threeseed 8y agoApple allows you just as much control as every other product. If you were to break all of the security controls you could do whatever you want including adding a new App Store just like Cydia did. The question is whether Apple should make it easy for you to do this. And there is no legal basis for that.
- sjy 8y agoSure there is. Section 2 of the Sherman Act makes it illegal to "monopolize, or attempt to monopolize, or combine or conspire with any other person or persons, to monopolize any part of the trade or commerce among the several States, or with foreign nations." You may think that Apple's conduct does not fall under that provision, and it remains to be seen whether the federal courts will agree, but if the legal argument were totally baseless then Apple wouldn't have gone to the Supreme Court to shut it down at a preliminary stage.
- michaelmrose 8y agoA standard pc keeps unauthorized users from modifying the system to protect you. It does not protect your oem from competition. Pretending that this isn't extraordinary is a very questionable tactic that Apple has handled in an innovative fashion.
- threeseed 8y agoApple can legitimately claim that the App Store protect users as well. And it's not extraordinary at all. These days any device with apps/games has their own store e.g. Nintendo, PS, XBox, Fitbit, Thermomix etc.
- michaelmrose 8y agoPhones are transitioning from devices to make phone calls to computers. Even the original iphone was more like a computer than a telephone.
- Spivak 8y ago