3 ms·
It's worth expanding on this. Because I think it gets lost in the rhetoric, whether deliberately or by accident. A profit-maximizing firm sets prices that maxi
by nerdponx 8y ago
It's worth expanding on this. Because I think it gets lost in the rhetoric, whether deliberately or by accident.
A profit-maximizing firm sets prices that maximize its expected profit. This seems tautological, but it's important and I think it's implications aren't appreciated.
If your prices are already beating the competition, and you already have a solid reputation for low prices, there is no incentive to continue lowering prices, even as you cut costs. This is why monopolies are considered "bad", because they eliminate incentives for firms to care at all about the welfare of consumers.
In undergrad economics classes, you might learn that prices are set equal to marginal cost (including opportunity cost). But that is only true under specific and relatively strong equilibrium conditions, which I don't believe apply to Amazon.
- elamje 8y agoI agree with the general idea. In your experience, when has Amazon acted negatively towards the welfare of the consumer? The point I was talking about has to do with the internal labor publicity at Amazon which rarely affects the consumer.
- andrewmutz 8y agoThe reason that this tends to lower prices for consumers is that these innovations rarely stay confined to the companies that invent them. If this lowers costs for amazon to fulfill orders, then these techniques tend to get adopted by their competitors. And once adopted by competitors, when everyone's margins have increased, these companies do compete on price. This process doesn't happen immediately but it does happen.
- nitrogen 8y agoWho are Amazon's most likely competitors?
- cavisne 8y agoMight not be true as more problems are solved through machine learning. Amazon has or could generate the largest and most diverse dataset to train the object recognition problems needed to automate a warehouse. They also have the end to end pipeline to evaluate accuracy (damaged or incorrect orders, manual intervention needed in the warehouse). Can a competitor actually catch up without this data?
- hobofan 8y agoSure. The usual strategy would be a joint venture between the second, third, etc. biggest competitors to share the development (and relevant data) for such a technology.
- pathseeker 8y agoRight, but amazon isn't known for low prices nor is it a monopoly. This will allow them to lower prices and become known for the lowest prices while still preserving their margin (if that's the market they want to target).
- nerdponx 8y agoThey aren't known for low prices? They are known for having the same prices as everyone else, with free or cheaper shipping, meaning that effectively the price is lower. And no, I'm not implying that they are a monopoly.
- rootusrootus 8y agoThey have that reputation, but be watchful. Lots of things are more expensive at Amazon, now. What they're selling me is convenience more than anything else. I can often find lower prices elsewhere but it's more work.
- nerdponx 8y agoI'd argue that convenience is part of the price. I actually suspect that one big competitor to Amazon will not be another online store, but local stores providing free or cheap local delivery, and by extension services like Postmates.
- stale2002 8y ago> there is no incentive to continue lowering prices, Yes there is. Lower prices means that consumers will buy more. Unless you are going to argue that the elasticity of demand is perfectly inelastic. Such cases are rare.
- celtain 8y ago>If your prices are already beating the competition, and you already have a solid reputation for low prices, there is no incentive to continue lowering prices, even as you cut costs. If they could reach many more customers by lowering prices, even a monopoly could potentially find it profitable to continue lowering prices as they cut costs. A monopoly could also continue to cut costs to head off the threat of antitrust litigation.
- cavisne 8y agoThats the nice thing about Amazon, because of the "flywheel" (customers will always want lower prices and wider range) they've built a reputation of operating like a utility, and customers love them for it. I dont see why they would ever sacrifice this, when they can easily keep growing by taking this same mindset into new industries (groceries, cloud computing, pharmacies).