4 ms·
> You can only buy the new Jordan's from X stores, only available on PS4, exclusively at Target, etc. When this matters is when you have a dominant market posi
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> You can only buy the new Jordan's from X stores, only available on PS4, exclusively at Target, etc.
When this matters is when you have a dominant market position. Target doesn't have to sell Nike because you can reasonably buy them at Walmart. Nike doesn't have to sell to Target because Target can reasonably buy from Reebok, which is a reasonable substitute.
The issue here is that there is no reasonable substitute for Apple's App Store, because they have made it that way on purpose. You can't sell your iOS app through Walmart or Google Play or Amazon. You can't download it from the developer's website. And you can't run Android apps on iOS devices. So Apple has a dominant position in iOS app distribution, and with that comes the antitrust restrictions that don't apply to competitive markets.
- esmi 8y ago> So Apple has a dominant position in iOS app distribution Is iOS app distribution a thing that can be dominated though, legally? In your example I get how stores and shoes are both things that can be dominated but what category of thing does iOS app distribution fall into? Is it still in the same category if one deletes iOS and just calls it in "app store"? Would Apple still dominate apps? It's all confusing to me. I'm asking sincerely because I honestly don't know.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoThis is getting into market definition, which is kind of complicated and subjective, but one of the key factors is substitution. So for example, is "Clorox bleach" its own market, separate from just "bleach"? Well, no. Clorox bleach is chemically identical to any other bleach. You could switch one for the other and not even be able to tell the difference. On the other hand, is "broadband internet service in Pittsburgh" a different market than just "broadband internet service"? It kind of is. There may be a dozen different ISPs in varying cities across the country, but the prerequisite to using one that doesn't offer service in your city is to sell your house and move somewhere else. That doesn't make it a particularly viable substitute. So then is "iOS app store" a different market than just "app store"? Well, what do you have to do to substitute one for the other? Is it reasonable to have to exchange your $600 phone, or buy a second $600 phone, in order to buy a $1 app from a different store?
- threeseed 8y agoThis is inaccurate though. You would still have to buy a new $600 phone to use that $1 app irrespective of whether Apple had multiple stores or not. iOS is a platform and apps can only work on that platform.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> You would still have to buy a new $600 phone to use that $1 app irrespective of whether Apple had multiple stores or not. You need a phone to use an app in the same way that you need a piece of real estate to get internet service. That doesn't mean Cox in Omaha is a competitor to Comcast in Pittsburgh, because people aren't reasonably going to make a choice with hundreds of times greater implications just in order to do that. > iOS is a platform and apps can only work on that platform. You're only providing reasons that it is a separate market from apps on other platforms.
- threeseed 8y agoApple isn't dominant in iOS app distribution. App Store is considered part of the device. No different to Nintendo, PS4 stores etc.