6 ms·
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memetics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memetics > Memetics is the study of information and culture based on an analogy with Darwi
by mistermann 8y ago
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memetics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memetics
> Memetics is the study of information and culture based on an analogy with Darwinian evolution. Proponents describe memetics as an approach to evolutionary models of cultural information transfer. Critics regard memetics as a pseudoscience. Memetics describes how an idea can propagate successfully, but doesn't necessarily imply a concept is factual.
> The term meme was coined in Richard Dawkins' 1976 book The Selfish Gene, but Dawkins later distanced himself from the resulting field of study.[2] Analogous to a gene, the meme was conceived as a "unit of culture" (an idea, belief, pattern of behaviour, etc.) which is "hosted" in the minds of one or more individuals, and which can reproduce itself in the sense of jumping from the mind of one person to the mind of another. Thus what would otherwise be regarded as one individual influencing another to adopt a belief is seen as an idea-replicator reproducing itself in a new host. As with genetics, particularly under a Dawkinsian interpretation, a meme's success may be due to its contribution to the effectiveness of its host.
I believe memetics is one of the most impactful but underappreciated ideas out there today, and plausibly explains the bizarre polarization of opinions on a wide variety of hot button current topics. Everyone perceives that their opinion/knowledge is based on facts, but very few are even slightly aware that their knowledge is actually based on a hodge podge of memes, each with varying levels of truthiness.
- ndiscussion 8y agoShh, don't wake us... This is one of the most obvious things in modern life if you look. But no one seems to be looking. I'm not sure what life would look like if they were. Probably very different and with a very violent transition.
- mistermann 8y ago> But no one seems to be looking. There are a few people on HN and elsewhere, but I concede that our numbers are extremely small. > I'm not sure what life would look like if they were. Probably very different and with a very violent transition. I'm curious why you think a transition to a more enlightened (a significant decrease in both delusional meme-based beliefs, as well as ignorant over-confidence in the beliefs people do still hold) society would be violent? I tend to think the transition would be rather orderly, with people tending to hang their heads in shame for their former stupidity. Violent lashing out is what we have now.
- ndiscussion 8y agoI don't mean violence from the individual, but from the buckling of systems currently supported by society. If everyone became enlighted simultaneously, we would probably help each other out, but it would cause a huge disruption in the global economy. Part of that economy is food, and it takes a while to grow a new crop... basically breaking supply chains can cause mass starvations, that's all.
- mistermann 8y agoAh I see....yes, from that perspective you are absolutely correct, I reckon mass enlightenment in a short period of time would wreak absolute havoc on the world and result in serious public unrest, likely including significant violence. Even if democracy could accommodate a transition, I have no idea how the impacts on the economic system (decreased spending on trillions of dollars in worldwide military budgets for example) would be safely managed.
- quanticle 8y agoOne site that does appear to be looking is SlateStarCodex. "Meditations on Moloch" [1] and "How the West Was Won" [2] both grapple with the notion that ideas are supreme and people are just uncomprehending vessels for concepts that are larger than any particular individual. [1] https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/ [2] https://slatestarcodex.com/2016/07/25/how-the-west-was-won/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2016/07/25/how-the-west-was-won/
- mistermann 8y agoSSC is fantastic, lots of the posts there touch on this concept in one way or another. I also recommend https://marginalrevolution.com/ https://marginalrevolution.com/
- xamuel 8y agoIf anything is a meme, then memetics itself is. It's no more "impactful" than the observation that people chant team slogans, recite famous quotes, or use mnemonic devices. Name something memetics has impacted. Viral marketing? Nope, that would've happened with or without Dawkins. Etc.
- gloriousduke 8y agoWhen I was looking at a Game of Thrones subreddit after the episode last night, I realized I was getting more emotionally from the memes (which aren’t exactly the sort of memes Dawkins was thinking of) than long-winded analysis of what was good/bad about the episode. Those reddit memes are a way to encapsulate quite a bit of thought and feeling with only a few words and an image or two. Aside: those memes have been building up on each other for years, so quite a few images, words and online interactions are involved in their existence from a historical perspective. Not to say there is anything profound about this memeified manner of communication, or that it is all that much different from other types of human language and the appreciation of art or a photograph, but I still found it interesting (futuristic?) that I was thinking that way.
- xamuel 8y agoYes, image macros can be a great way of getting a point across. But it's not like the people making them are professors of the Department of Memetic Research. The grandparent comment about Memetics being so "impactful" is somewhat like English professors taking credit for the fact that we're speaking English.
- mistermann 8y ago> If anything is a meme, then memetics itself is. Of course it is. Pointing out that something is a meme isn't really an insult, it's just the nature of reality. Indeed, chanting of team slogans, etc are all forms of memetic, cult-like behavior. > Name something memetics has impacted. Viral marketing? Nope, that would've happened with or without Dawkins. Etc. Memetics isn't an "invention", it's simply a label given to a general observation (itself a meme) of ideas like people do not think in facts, or fully realize the difference between reality and their interpretation of reality. Whether the discovery and documentation of these human behaviors has "impacted" anything is no proof one way or another if it is a correct theory. I happen to believe it could impact the world in a major way, if large numbers or people were intimately aware of it, but that's far easier said than done. Accepting these ideas in principle isn't terribly difficult (although plenty of people seem to find the ideas offensive), but even having intellectually accepted the principle, changing one's real-time behavior (not jumping to conclusions or mischaracterizing/imagining the beliefs of others during conversations, humbly admitting when someone points out your facts aren't actually facts, etc etc etc) is something else entirely. This can be observed on HN, Reddit, and everywhere on a daily basis.