4 ms·
Well they’re reusable, which is even better than recyclable. They also use less materials to make and are stronger for the same weight, so they also reduce, whi
by chrisseaton 8y ago
Well they’re reusable, which is even better than recyclable. They also use less materials to make and are stronger for the same weight, so they also reduce, which is better still.
Just don’t throw them into the ocean. But that much should have been obvious.
- libraryatnight 8y agoI don't know what kind of plastic bag it was, but the grocery bags we get where I live start to develop holes rather quickly so they're not actually reusable. They also aren't allowed in my city's recycle bins because they apparently just get stuck in the sorting machines and cause all kinds of issues. When I tried saving them for various uses and noticed they develop holes quickly, I thought maybe that's good - maybe these bags were made to decompose quickly or something, but that's not the case. And now that we know microplastics are inside lots of organisms (including ourselves) I can't help but just feel like plastic is just a nasty SOB. We've ended up getting a bunch of those cloth re-usable grocery bags and using those. I also use containers rather than zip lock bags. But I doubt I make much of a difference because when I take my morning walks on trash/recycle pickup days I frequently see bins filled to the brim with plastic water bottles where it seems like people just buy multiple cases of water bottles and drink from them like they're cups or soda cans and toss them.
- skookumchuck 8y agoI reuse the paper grocery bags. They can usually be used 10 times or more before they disintegrate, then I use them again as trash bags. I wonder why I've never heard anyone mention this. The grocery store has no problem at all with me bringing back the paper bags and stuffing my purchases in them. They've never said a word about it. I never see anyone else do it.
- jdsully 8y agoThe grocery store loves you. Bags are a major expense for them - unless you’re in an area where they get to charge. The only potential issue is extra scrutiny from loss prevention.
- frenchy 8y ago> unless you’re in an area where they get to charge. Why don't they do this everywhere? Is it because customers would throw a fit?
- Kluny 8y agoIn my city, it took a long time to get a plastic bag ban passed because of strong opposition from plastic manufacturer lobbyists who pretended that they were taking the side of "local businesses".
- skookumchuck 8y agoAround here, plastic bags are banned and paper bags have a per-bag tax. The store doesn't charge for the bags, they just pass on the tax. They didn't charge before the tax/ban, either.
- yeahitslikethat 8y agoI reuse them as garbage bags in small trash cans under the sink, in the bathroom, office, etc. You can reuse small boxes and big coffee cans as the trash cans.
- bjelkeman-again 8y agoPaper bags are also reusable, but more importantly they are biodegradable. “Just don’t throw them in the ocean.” has proven not to work. People throw everything that is packaging, all the time, despite decades long campaigns. Every generation has to diligently be educated, and despite this, it isn’t enough. The amount of plastic I have to pick up in my relatively wealthy neighbourhood is surprising.
- dalore 8y agoPaper comes from tree farms. More need for paper, more tree farms will be built. So even without use the farm themselves produce more benefit then plastic factories.
- maxerickson 8y agoLots of fiber that ends up in paper comes from actively managed forests, which are not particularly farm like. And in any case, there is only so much productive land available. Planting a large areas of trees on productive land is likely to displace some other agricultural activity.
- codingdave 8y agoOr use cloth bags. Stronger than both. Re-usable for longer than either. And some stores give you discounts for using your own bag.
- chrisseaton 8y agoDon’t you have to use a cloth bag like a thousand times before it’s recouped the environmental impact of making it compared to that many plastic bags? I’m not sure that’s always going to add up to being a win for the environment.
- codingdave 8y ago131 was the number thrown around in other comments. And I replied there as well, but go ahead and add it up - if the bag holds twice as much, and you use 2 bags a week, we're talking about less than a year before you are ahead of the game.
- chrisseaton 8y agoThe Danish government said they thought it was 20000 times. I guess we don’t really know. > one study from the Danish government found you'd have to use an organic cloth bag 20,000 times for it to be a better environmental choice than plastic
- billti 8y ago> ...better environmental choice than plastic I think "better" is very subjective here. If we're talking the energy and water to make it, sure. But that probably pales into comparison compared to the produce you'll be putting in those bags anyway. With all we know about plastic in the environment now, and how ineffective recycling as a strategy is, I think anything that will harmlessly biodegrade in a reasonable amount of time is a better choice than plastic.
- ar0 8y ago
- headShrinker 8y agoBut plastics aren’t carbon neutral and most aren’t manufactured to be reused. They’re made from buried dino bone. On the other hand, paper comes from trees which pulls carbon from the air so if and when that carbon reenters the air, the cycle is complete. Paper is in fact carbon neutral, minus any of the machinery used to manufacture or move the product. Pulling hydrocarbons from underground by its very nature is carbon additive. Don’t throw them in the ocean, don’t throw them in anybody’s backyard, is the problem we now are running into China doesn’t want our trash anymore. Recycling plastics is harder than ever before. Also recycled plastics lose their elasticity which is part of their strength so only 10% of used material can be re-manufactured into new product.
- chrisseaton 8y ago> They’re made from buried dino bone. No, they're not. https://www.thoughtco.com/does-oil-come-from-dinosaurs-1092003 https://www.thoughtco.com/does-oil-come-from-dinosaurs-10920...
- headShrinker 8y agoMeant as a casual flippant joke but your right, people should ignore that colloquialism
- dpark 8y ago> Paper is in fact carbon neutral, minus any of the machinery used to manufacture or move the product. That's a big caveat. Logging equipment doesn't run on paper fuel. It runs on fossil fuel.
- forgotmypw 8y agoNo matter how reusable they are, a decay time of thousands of years vs weeks overpowers the other benefits, IMO.