6 ms·
I see what you’re implying, but tweak one little thing and the answer seems vastly different: Instead of an Apple device, say you’re using a Google-manufacture
by derefr 8y ago
I see what you’re implying, but tweak one little thing and the answer seems vastly different:
Instead of an Apple device, say you’re using a Google-manufactured Android device (something-or-other), and have installed a third-party App Store on it. But that third-party App Store turns around and uses Google Pay as its payment processor.
All the same qualifications still apply: you essentially used a “Google POS device” (your phone), were routed through Google payment processing, and the results were deployed to a Google device (your phone again.)
But from the perspective of the seller, you were just using an arbitrary Android device to run their App Store on; and Google, to them, is just the payment-processor they chose to use (probably because it’s conveniently integrated on Android devices) but they could have just-as-well used PayPal or Stripe.
Is this third-party App Store—in this particular case—legally “Google?” Even though, in other cases, where people are using other non-Google Android devices to access the store, or maybe selecting a different payment-processor option at checkout, they definitely aren’t legally Google? I would say “obviously no.” Those apps were legally sold by the third-party App Store. Google was just a payment processor there. (Payment processors still also have legal responsibilities regarding the transaction, but they’re different than those of the seller.)
And if that’s true, then what’s the difference between a third-party App Store that you installed as its own app, and a “third-party App Store” that is a section of the Apple App Store app, e.g. a Microsoft section or Adobe section? Isn’t that the same as, say, buying from a physical Microsoft store in an Apple-owned shopping mall?
And if that’s true, then where’s the line between that and “each app you purchase is purchased from its own little stall in this digital mall, which is owned and operated by the software author”? Is there one?
I feel like this is something that’s unclear enough that you could spent eight years arguing the various precedents behind deciding either way.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- holy_city 8y ago>And if that’s true, then where’s the line between that and “each app you purchase is purchased from its own little stall in this digital mall, which is owned and operated by the software author”? Is there one? To use your analogy, the line is if someone can set up their own shop outside the mall. As a consumer, if I have no way to avoid purchasing from a store inside a single mall then I'm effectively purchasing from the mall itself. At least in my opinion. I'm not a lawyer.
- Spivak 8y agoHow do you resolve this with the fact that exclusives exist and are tolerated in just about every industry. You can only buy the new Jordan's from X stores, only available on PS4, exclusively at Target, etc. And places that sell things are well within their right to choose their vendors unless you want to demand that the BMV dealership be leglly required to sell Ford trucks if Ford desired. Put exclusivity and vendor selection together and you have a digital app store. Apple doesn't even pretend to be open -- they're a product with licensed 3rd party integrations. On what grounds should they be compelled to be anything else?
- holy_city 8y agoExclusivity deals are pretty complicated under the Sherman/Clayton acts. It's hotly contested - hardly "tolerated in just about every industry." Here are some links: https://www.businessjustice.com/is-exclusive-dealing-illegal-under-the-antitrust-laws.html https://www.businessjustice.com/is-exclusive-dealing-illegal... https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/competition-guidance/guide-antitrust-laws/dealings-supply-chain/exclusive-dealing-or https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/competition-guidance/guide-a... https://www.theantitrustattorney.com/exclusive-dealing-agreement-violate-antitrust-laws/ https://www.theantitrustattorney.com/exclusive-dealing-agree... That's why this is going to the Supreme Court - we all recognize that the App Store uses exclusive dealing, but it's non-obvious whether or not it's lawful. >And places that sell things are well within their right to choose their vendors unless you want to demand that the BMV dealership be leglly required to sell Ford trucks if Ford desired. Not sure what that has to do with anything. Apple's point was that they aren't selling anything - therefore appstore customers wouldn't have standing to bring an antitrust against them.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> You can only buy the new Jordan's from X stores, only available on PS4, exclusively at Target, etc. When this matters is when you have a dominant market position. Target doesn't have to sell Nike because you can reasonably buy them at Walmart. Nike doesn't have to sell to Target because Target can reasonably buy from Reebok, which is a reasonable substitute. The issue here is that there is no reasonable substitute for Apple's App Store, because they have made it that way on purpose. You can't sell your iOS app through Walmart or Google Play or Amazon. You can't download it from the developer's website. And you can't run Android apps on iOS devices. So Apple has a dominant position in iOS app distribution, and with that comes the antitrust restrictions that don't apply to competitive markets.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pier25 8y agoThe difference is that the hypothetical third party Android App Store could use any payment service it wanted, or even the user could use any App Store it preferred. With iOS not only you can't buy from a third party, you can't even install an app that hasn't been signed by Apple.
- Fellshard 8y agoI would argue the point of consumer choice is at device selection. If they choose the ecosystem with the heavy markup, when they had alternatives, then they are responsible for incurring their own additional costs. The information is public regarding app costs between devices and marketplaces. This seems to me a bad ruling based on that.
- bduerst 8y agoBlaming the consumer in this case doesn't fly because the consumer owns the device once they purchase it, and it is anticompetitive for Apple to lock out competing services on the consumer's device. The "Just don't buy it" argument also doesn't work for The Right to Repair movement. Either way, end users have the right to sue Apple here, not just the developers.
- Fellshard 8y agoThat requires making the case that the consumer believes they are buying a general computing device that they can use for any purpose and customize freely, which is simply not the case. Furthermore, repair applies to the hardware of the device, not the software ecosystem. You have to make a separate, very different argument for software as it is more malleable and less restricted than hardware components are.
- pier25 8y ago> believes they are buying a general computing device that they can use for any purpose and customize freely, which is simply not the case So you are arguing that an iPhone is a very sophisticated calculator and not a general purpose computer?
- blendergeek 8y ago> tweak one little thing > [you] have installed a third-party App Store on it. I believe that is more than "one little thing". Here is why: Plantiffs say that Apple's decision to be the sole source of apps for the iPhone is monopolisitc. In your scenario, the purchaser is buying apps from a third party, not affiliated with Google. So, no, a third party cannot be possibly "legally Google". Critically in your scenario, "you were just using an arbitrary Android device" and "Google, to them, is just the payment-processor they chose to use" and most critically "they could have just-as-well used PayPal or Stripe." So, I believe the facts of your case are very very far from the facts of the Apple case. Hypothetical Google Case: - Third Party App Store - Multiple competing payment solution Actual Apple Case: - Only one app store by order of manufacturer/OEM/OS Vendor - Only one payment processor (who is the app store) In the scenario with Google, google is no more involved in the purchase than mastercard is in your purchase at Walmart. In the scenario with Apple, the app developer is no more involved with your purchase than the book author is on Amazon (when you buy directly from Amazon). You purchase FROM APPLE.
- iamaelephant 8y agoYes, if you change literally every single detail then it changes the outcome somewhat.