4 ms·
It held that Apple could be sued by end users. Apple's argument was that only app developers had standing.
by bitwize 8y ago
It held that Apple could be sued by end users. Apple's argument was that only app developers had standing.
- dmix 8y agoApple's argument was that 3rd parties set the prices on their platform not them (app developers), so they shouldn't be held liable for the monopolistic effects this creates.
- DannyBee 8y agoThat is mostly irrelevant to this part of the case, which was about standing. Your parent comment (which is getting downvoted) is correct. Under previous precedent (Illinois Brick), only app developers would have standing to sue, and that is what apple argued should happen here.
- macleginn 8y agoHow can this be irrelevant to this part of the case if this is precisely why, as per Apple, end users don't have standing? The court rejects this argument and points out that who sets the prices is actually a technicality, which is less important than who buys from whom.
- DannyBee 8y agoThe parent comment is not talking about standing in a meaningful way. It talks about whether Apple should be "liable for the monopolistic effects" "liable for the monopolistic effects" != standing. Standing is literally about "who has the right to sue at all". Not whether they are liable or not. That comes later.
- zamalek 8y agoDespite what the Apple lawyers claimed, wouldn't the actual interpretation be: Apple could sue app developers? The developers are the ones "producing the concrete bricks" and Apple is the one "directly purchasing the concrete bricks." By arguing this way for this case, and setting precedent, Apple would have been able to manufacture a loop hole by subsequently using the more accurate interpretation. It's a very healthy precedent for app stores, regardless.
- hermitdev 8y agoI don't think this true. Look at your bank statements after a purchase from the App Store. You're not billed by the developer of the app, youre billed directly by Apple, so under Illinois Brick, and users do already have standing (obligatory not a lawyer).
- pfortuny 8y agoOh, wow, thanks for pointing this out, not at all clear from the summary of the parent.
- Radle 8y ago"The point in question is which of these two customers has standing to sue on the basis of the specific harm in question. Under US law the answer cannot be both." This in fact not what SCOTUS wrote, SCOTUS clearly said that Apple may be sued by developers and consumers alike, the mere fact that apple has a monopolistic (They hold all the consumer supply in this market) and a monopsonistic(They satisfy all the demand from app devs on this market) position does not mean that the damages injured to both parties are in fact the same damages. Under current US law multiple parties may not sue for the same damage. But at this point of time it is not decided whether the damages sustained by consumers in this lawsuit would be the same damages that app developers could sue for. It is entirely possible that Apple has swindled BOTH.
- simonh 8y agoYep absolutely, it would just have to be in different ways.
- yAak 8y agoThank you for taking the time to clarify this in layman's terms!
- eridius 8y agoI don't understand this argument though. Surely if both app customers and app developers sued Apple they'd be suing over the exact same damages? Either customers have their prices artificially increased, at which point app developers don't have damages as they're getting the money from customers, or else app developers are keeping prices low and taking the damage themselves, at which point customers aren't harmed.
- robbrown451 8y agoIt's still the same damages. Apple is taking money from a transaction between users and developers. It effectively comes equally from both sides of the transaction. It's just like a sales tax, who does it come from, the consumer or the retailer? It really doesn't matter, the effect is the same. The only problem is if it is accounted for twice. If it adds $10 to a transaction, you can't say both the consumer and developer are each harmed by $10. Better to say each are harmed by $5.