3 ms·
> There is a lot of law, at the federal and state levels, And that law is of very abstract, and ephemeral kind — the very criteria of fault in how USA approach
by baybal2 8y ago
> There is a lot of law, at the federal and state levels,
And that law is of very abstract, and ephemeral kind — the very criteria of fault in how USA approaches official crimes.
And as I stated above, most of that law is state level patchwork and case law rather than federal level statutory rules.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> that law is of very abstract, and ephemeral kind — the very criteria of fault in how USA approaches official crimes No, it's highly specific, drawing from cases going back to the founding of the Republic. > most of that law is state level patchwork and case law rather than federal level statutory rules Statute isn't stronger than case law. They're both law in a common-law system [1]. (Insider trading, for example, isn't defined in federal statute, but it's still commonly penalized.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_law
- baybal2 8y ago> No, it's highly specific, drawing from cases going back to the founding of the Republic. No, it isn't. Even if you do not consider the moderately modern exercise of official crimes laws, the few that were used are few. As what I know of their historicity, most of early work on that lines were about official crimes being an offshoot of treason/sabotage/sedition/subversion and such. And if you start discussing their moderately modern exercise, then, well, as I stated above, the court record of abuse of office cases is of charges not reaching the court to begin with or being dropped. > Statute isn't stronger than case law. Statute is a clear writing in text saying "things A, B, and C are a crime." When it comes to that, case law is weaker because it is much more open to interpretation with it being a collection of opinions, interpretations, philosophising, from time to time bordering on "legal theology." It is much weaker against official crimes in reality, when DAs can wiggle their way out of need to fill charges using numerous excuses provided by law's openness to interpretation P.S. That Louisiana law that you pulled, well, is a Louisiana law, not federal.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> the court record of abuse of office cases is of charges not reaching the court to begin with or being dropped For corruption, charges tend to come up. For more ambiguous forms of abuse, the investigations tend to do the political damage required to push people out of office. At the end of the day, you want a high bar for removing elected people from office. (You want a higher bar still for jailing them.) > Statute is a clear writing in text So are court opinions. Clear writings, in text, that describe the ruling's logic in detail. Statutes can be re-interpreted by courts just as easily as precedents--it's a total myth that one form of the law is weaker than the other. If anything, case law is more concrete than statute--tangibly speaking, what courts decide is more important than what you think the text of a statute means.