3 ms·
USA has very little in terms of law on personal liabilities of officials and their scope. The dismal legal history for USA CFR 25 11.448 - abuse of office is a
by baybal2 8y ago
USA has very little in terms of law on personal liabilities of officials and their scope. The dismal legal history for USA CFR 25 11.448 - abuse of office is a proof of that.
USA is one of few countries where there is close to nothing amounting to codified criminal abuse of office laws, the few criminal abuse of office laws are state level in USA. The wider official crimes class of offences, is also poorly represented, if not to say not being recognised as such.
Even if you compare USA to worst offenders on that front, from how it was in USSR, to China and other joke polities. They did jail more office abusers than US. Sounds silly, but look at the digits.
While this was never indicative of political commitment, and USSR was horridly corrupt through its whole history, there was at least a minimal acknowledgement that completely useless/incompetent people must be kicked out from official positions, or after demonstrable public screw up.
Here is a list of things amounting to official crimes in self respecting polities:
- Criminal incompetence
- Criminal dereliction of duty
- Insubordination
- Providing criminal agency
- Criminal conflict of interest
- Exceeding official authority
- Conduct of crime under official authority (have no idea for a better translation)
- Criminal deprivation of rights
- Failing official audit
- Criminal violations of cadre/appointment/recruitment policies/procedures
- Loss of official records/communications/accounting
- Income/assets beyond known means while serving in office (a charge as such, literately)
Any real code will have few times more of the above, and of stuff nowhere remotely considered an official crime in USA.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> USA is one of few countries where there is close to nothing amounting to codified criminal abuse of office laws There is a lot of law, at the federal and state levels, concerning abuse of power [1]. This takes the form of both statutes, which tend to use the term of art "malfeasance in office," e.g. [2], and court precedent (both of which are the law). > there was at least a minimal acknowledgement [in the USSR] that completely useless/incompetent people must be kicked out from official positions Office abusers tend to lose their office through elections and term limits. Where this safety valve doesn't exist, a more pointed approach is needed. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abuse_of_power https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abuse_of_power [2] https://law.justia.com/codes/louisiana/2011/rs/title14/rs14-134/ https://law.justia.com/codes/louisiana/2011/rs/title14/rs14-...
- baybal2 8y ago> There is a lot of law, at the federal and state levels, And that law is of very abstract, and ephemeral kind — the very criteria of fault in how USA approaches official crimes. And as I stated above, most of that law is state level patchwork and case law rather than federal level statutory rules.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> that law is of very abstract, and ephemeral kind — the very criteria of fault in how USA approaches official crimes No, it's highly specific, drawing from cases going back to the founding of the Republic. > most of that law is state level patchwork and case law rather than federal level statutory rules Statute isn't stronger than case law. They're both law in a common-law system [1]. (Insider trading, for example, isn't defined in federal statute, but it's still commonly penalized.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_law
- baybal2 8y ago> No, it's highly specific, drawing from cases going back to the founding of the Republic. No, it isn't. Even if you do not consider the moderately modern exercise of official crimes laws, the few that were used are few. As what I know of their historicity, most of early work on that lines were about official crimes being an offshoot of treason/sabotage/sedition/subversion and such. And if you start discussing their moderately modern exercise, then, well, as I stated above, the court record of abuse of office cases is of charges not reaching the court to begin with or being dropped. > Statute isn't stronger than case law. Statute is a clear writing in text saying "things A, B, and C are a crime." When it comes to that, case law is weaker because it is much more open to interpretation with it being a collection of opinions, interpretations, philosophising, from time to time bordering on "legal theology." It is much weaker against official crimes in reality, when DAs can wiggle their way out of need to fill charges using numerous excuses provided by law's openness to interpretation P.S. That Louisiana law that you pulled, well, is a Louisiana law, not federal.
- cafard 8y ago"that completely useless/incompetent people must be kicked out from official positions, or after demonstrable public screw up" Or anyway that somebody had to carry the can for unfortunate events: saboteur engineers, murderous doctors, what have you.
- Shivetya 8y agoa lot of incompetence at the state level is protected behind Sovereign Immunity should it have negative affects on others and rarely does it ever reach criminal prosecution. law enforcement falls behind the false state of qualified immunity, which can apply to every person in the confines of law enforcement, and that derived from a bad court ruling that perpetuates till today. worse, people do not understand the full import of many laws and instead focus on how they negatively affect a disliked group. this allows politicians at all levels to protect themselves as well as punish those they don't like all with public support.
- torstenvl 8y agoYou make three major errors. The first is that you conflate "criminal abuse of office laws" with the "acknowledgement that completely useless/incompetent people must be kicked out from official positions." The U.S. government is not required to convict someone of a crime in order to terminate their employment. Federal civilian labor law is an entire field of practice that is... quite verdant. The second major error is that you conflate the presence of such criminal laws with anti-corruption measures. In reality, the existence of laws that allow jailing someone for making mistakes at work ("incompetence," "failing official audit," etc.) is a tool of corruption. Simply appoint the right auditor and you can eliminate anyone who disagrees with you. Making poor job performance a crime, for someone with no mens rea, is inherently totalitarian and abusive. Lastly, it is simply not a factually correct statement to say that the "USA has very little in terms of law on personal liabilities of officials and their scope." (a) First, I'll address the support you cited. Your reference to 25 C.F.R. § 11.448 is inapposite: it doesn't support your position because it isn't a statute, and it is utterly inapplicable anyway because it only applies on certain Native American reservations. A Bureau of Indian Affairs regulation was not a good choice for you here. See https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/25/11.448 https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/25/11.448 and https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/25/11.118 https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/25/11.118 (b) I'll address the presence of the law you claim does not exist. (i) Brief overview. Title 5 of the U.S. Code (5 U.S.C. § 101 et seq.) is the statutory law that governs federal employees (except uniformed members, who are governed by title 10, title 14, or title 32, depending on component and status). Additional crimes are in title 18; additional constraints are found in specific titles depending on subject matter (e.g., the VA is governed by title 38). (ii) Specific examples (procedurally): Chapters 43 and 75 provide specific guidance on holding federal civilian employees accountable for malfeasance of any sort. Any lingering questions you have about the U.S. system should probably begin there. (iii) Specific examples (substantively): Since criminal statutes seem to hold special significance for you, let me direct your attention toward 18 U.S.C. § 201 (bribery), 18 U.S.C. § 203, 209 (supplementation of salary), 18 U.S.C. § 205 (representational conflicts of interest), 18 U.S.C. § 208 (personal conflicts of interest), and so on. Additionally, take a look at 10 U.S.C. § 892 (military failure to obey an order and/or dereliction of duty).
- baybal2 8y ago
- baybal2 8y agoEdit above, "The dismal legal history for USA CFR 25 11.448 - abuse of office is a proof of that." Abuse of office happened not be the part of Ch.11 of US Criminal code (Title 18, not 25) as was told by a comment below