3 ms·
I've used it multiple times, never got a reply or saw a change. I believe it's mostly like the thumbs-down for comments on YouTube: the user feels like they did
by luckylion 8y ago
I've used it multiple times, never got a reply or saw a change. I believe it's mostly like the thumbs-down for comments on YouTube: the user feels like they did something but it has no actual meaning.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- josefresco 8y agoMy theory? You can't automate the analysis of these reports (if they could, why didn't they catch it in the first place) so it basically goes into a "black hole" never to be addressed. I only base this wacky, baseless theory on Google's overall obsession with automation, which of course keeps staff low and profits high.
- luckylion 8y agoYeah, it certainly seems that way. It feels like you'll have a better chance "reporting" to Google by going viral on Twitter, HN etc, than by actually reporting it to Google.
- jacurtis 8y agoIronically, giving a thumbs down on a YouTube video actually helps its' organic rating within the site. As far as I am aware, they basically add both upvotes and downvotes together to show total votes and rank it on engagement based on the total number. I know this from my own videos. Some of my best ranking organic videos are videos that have the most downvotes.
- luckylion 8y agoI was talking about the thumbs down for comments, not videos. I believe you're right that they rank videos for engagement, which can be both positive or negative.
- brianpgordon 8y agoI think of it like sending a Windows app crash report to Microsoft. There's almost no possibility that anyone looks at any given problem, but if a million other people submit the exact same crash then maybe it'll show up at the top of some list and get some attention.