3 ms·
Something here is obviously being misreported, or Manning is crazy. Why not go to the jury, repeat previous statements, answer any question she's comfortable w
by roenxi 8y ago
Something here is obviously being misreported, or Manning is crazy.
Why not go to the jury, repeat previous statements, answer any question she's comfortable with and go with the tried-and-tested "I don't recall" for everything else? Or plead self incrimination if there is a risk?
This must have occurred to everyone involved. There isn't any reason to go to risk jail rather than answer a few questions.
- jsgo 8y agoWhat could she be asked about that she didn't previously serve time for? By that, can she really argue self incrimination if there is no risk of going back to jail for the same crimes per double jeopardy?
- levosmetalo 8y agoMaybe because she her goal is not come up with the least damage to herself, but to do what she finds more moral and right. Heroes don't play dumb, heroes do the right thing, make a statement, send the message ... and she is a hero, not someone trying to cover her ass. On the other hand, whatever she do, she's screwed, her future in such legal and power system is not bright anyways. So why not trying to be "die as a hero" then, it's not likely she would "survive" without "selling out" anyways?
- roenxi 8y agoThere isn't anything heroic about not communicating. Heroism is refusing to communicate dishonestly.
- cyphar 8y agoThe grand jury is an attempt to get something out of her which will sway a jury to decide that Assange is not a journalist and is guilty of conspiracy to commit computer fraud. She's decided to not play that game. To not serve as an accomplice in the US Government's case against Assange. I don't know why you think there's nothing heroic about remaining silent under intense government intimidation. You can come up with a counterexample very trivially -- in the civil rights movement, if you had witnessed a black person going into a "whites-only" bathroom then it would've been far more courageous to refuse to act as a witness than it would be to tell the truth.
- pnongrata 8y agoAgreed. I think one of the messages she is trying to convey is that the legal system is 'bogus'. So it's coherent refusing to play ball with it.
- g_sch 8y agoIIRC, if you are offered immunity you are no longer protected by the right against self-incrimination. So sidestepping questions in this way - when you could plausibly know the answer - carries some legal risks. There is also a long history of resistance to grand juries among anarchist activists, as a policy of refusing to give evidence to the government and law enforcement organizations: http://grandjuryresistance.org/ http://grandjuryresistance.org/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seattle_grand_jury_resisters https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seattle_grand_jury_resisters https://earthfirstjournal.org/prisoners/grand-jury-resistance/ https://earthfirstjournal.org/prisoners/grand-jury-resistanc...
- jacquesm 8y ago> Why not go to the jury, repeat previous statements, answer any question she's comfortable with and go with the tried-and-tested "I don't recall" for everything else? Because of being a principled person and doing the right thing? If anything Manning so far has shown to be pretty consistent in that respect.