2 ms·
This analogy is faulty. Assange is not a fellow soldier; he is a journalist operating outside USA. Therefore he has a completely different set of responsibiliti
by jessaustin 8y ago
This analogy is faulty. Assange is not a fellow soldier; he is a journalist operating outside USA. Therefore he has a completely different set of responsibilities, while a "war crime partner" would not.
Also the grand jury is only partly about Assange, whom they already know they won't get extradited from UK. It's also about engineering a perjury trap to punish Manning for a few more decades. She has no reason to trust the "justice" system and she might prefer contempt to the likely alternative.
- username444 8y agoThis tribal mentality of "US"(A) vs. them is outdated. We live in a global world where while laws haven't caught up, you can use your head and judge whether something is right or wrong. It's clear when someone - anyone - regardless of nationality is being abused for political reasons. Would you want to spend the rest of your life in either of their situations? For something you did once? For something that benefitted millions of people? I'm not saying they're clear of any responsibility and shouldn't have been punished, but this is beyond anything reasonable.
- sokoloff 8y ago> We live in a global world where while laws haven't caught up, you can use your head and judge whether something is right or wrong. The problem with that is that not everyone comes up with the same answer. Maybe most do in a majority of cases, but many times the answers diverge. Which is why we have to codify the expectations so even if you believe that action XYZ is OK, you are on notice that society has agreed and published that it's not (or vice versa).