8 ms·
Your periodic reminder that - despite the propaganda campaign run by nuclear advocates to make it seem like being anti-nuclear is to be anti-science - nuclear p
by nl 8y ago
Your periodic reminder that - despite the propaganda campaign run by nuclear advocates to make it seem like being anti-nuclear is to be anti-science - nuclear power remains massively expensive and even less safe than people think.
Here's the most comprehensive peer-reviewed survey around:
We summarize the results of a recent statistical analysis of 216 nuclear energy accidents and incidents (events). The dataset is twice as large as the previous best available. We employ cost in US dollars as a severity measure to facilitate the comparison of different types and sizes of events, a method more complete and consistent that the industry-standard approach. Despite significant reforms following past disasters, we estimate that, with 388 reactors in operation, there is a 50% chance that a Fukushima event (or more costly) occurs every 60–150 years. We also find that the average cost of events per year is around the cost of the construction of a new plant. This dire outlook necessitates post-Fukushima reforms that will truly minimize extreme nuclear power risks. Nuclear power accidents are decreasing in frequency, but increasing in severity.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2214629615301067?via%3Dihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S221462961...
- Consultant32452 8y agoHow many Fukushimas will we (society) accept every 150 years in order to stop climate change? That's really the only question that matters.
- c1sc0 8y agoBoth Fukushima & Chernobyl would have been essentially non-issues if built further away from population centers. I know this is Sim City logic: but my answer to that would be: quite a lot!
- toyg 8y agoWhere do you suggest people staffing the site should live? Chernobyl was basically a factory town around the plant.
- anoncake 8y agoThe Chernobyl Exclusion Zone covers 2,600km². It's irregularly shaped so it's unlikely you can predict which area will actually be irradiated, so a nuclear power plant in fact endangers an even larger area. Good luck finding a place in Europe, let alone Japan, that is far enough from population centers. Also consider that NPPs need cooling water so they are often located near rivers. As are population centers.
- ovi256 8y agoAn infinity of them, as there are very few deaths attributable to Fukushima, whereas the coal generation plants spew pollution and radionuclides into the atmosphere which result in definitely attributable deaths.
- rocqua 8y agoAttribution is a hard thing. Moreover, displacing a population and making land unlivable are bad things in and off themselves, even if people don't die.
- Tepix 8y agoI hope noone believes the official number of deaths from nuclear power plant accidents.
- dagw 8y agoSo multiply them 5. The argument vs coal still holds.
- Krasnol 8y agoHow about multiplying it by thousands? https://www.researchgate.net/publication/7151231_Estimates_of_the_cancer_burden_in_Europe_from_radioactive_fallout_from_the_Chernobyl_accident https://www.researchgate.net/publication/7151231_Estimates_o... https://www.greenpeace.org/archive-international/Global/international/planet-2/report/2006/4/chernobylhealthreport.pdf https://www.greenpeace.org/archive-international/Global/inte...
- ovi256 8y agoFirst of all, we were talking about Fukushima, do you have any data about that ? Anyway, about the first link: Wow, 40000 cancers attribuable in Europe by 2065 to Chernobyl, the worst nuclear accident in history. That sounds bad, until you finish reading the abstract, where the authors evaluate that impact as "several hundred million cancer cases are expected from other causes ... unlikely that the cancer burden from the largest radiological accident to date could be detected" Try to compare with the number attributable to coal pollution now ? Second link: Greenpeace, overtly being against nuclear power, will bring the biggest estimates of impact right ? Anyway, what they find is 200k additional deaths in Russia and Ukraine between 1990 and 2004 (first para page 9). But around 34M deaths were recorded in those territories in that time. By Greenpeace's own admission, 0.59% of those are attributable to Chernobyl. Again, try to compare to coal pollution.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoThis attitude is what's keeping these old and less safe reactor designs running in the first place.
- jabl 8y agoAll things considered, particularly climate change, probably better to keep those old designs running rather than replacing them with fossil or bio fuels. Once you have a 100% fossil/bio-free grid, you can replace those pesky nuclear plants with hamster wheel power for all I care.
- gridlockd 8y agoThe problem is that people who are anti-nuclear are often also anti-coal and anti-fossil-fuel and anti-everything-that-actually-sustains-current-human-level-of-development. For those people, it has to be "clean renewables", with the speculation being that technology will fix all the issues with it. That ignores that maybe technology can also fix the issues with nuclear - and more readily so.
- jayd16 8y agoThis is really not compelling. If you can't provide any more compelling evidence for nuclear vs clean energy improvements, why not gamble on the currently safer/cleaner bet?
- gridlockd 8y agoMy impression is that nuclear works right now and that the risk is overblown, relative to all the other risks we incur. Renewables are not working right now (see Germany) and they aren't necessarily cleaner, considering that all this infrastructure needs to be produced with ordinary industrial processes. Of course it's not an either-or, renewables can make more sense in some places and not so much in others.
- jayd16 8y ago>and that the risk is overblown I like nuclear but c'mon. Its clear that its not at an acceptable level of safety. Large scale disasters like Fukushima can't be hand waived away. >Renewables are not working right now (see Germany) What am I supposed to see from Germany? They're the largest electricity exporter in Europe. > considering that all this infrastructure needs to be produced with ordinary industrial processes. Is this not true of nuclear power?
- kyberias 8y agoFukushima was caused by an earthquake that directly caused much more damage than the reactor blowing up.
- hairytrog 8y agoKind of agree. There's been 4 catasrpohpic reactor meltdowns and there are ~400 reactors. That's a 1% failure rate. That's really bad. That's the status quo, which does not mandate continued low safety and lack of economic advantage. That's why there is R&D. Today what you say is true - great. Tomorrow, who knows. High energy density and human ingenuity could make genIV a reality.
- kyberias 8y agoWhat were the meltdowns?
- Gibbon1 8y agoFukushima, Three Mile Island, and Chernobyl. Are three.
- dagw 8y agoyea, not sure how to get to 4. Either you stop at 3 or you expand your scope to include contained meltdowns and meltdowns at small scale experimental and military facilities, in which case you end up around 7-20 depending on how serious a meltdown has to be to be included.
- newnewpdro 8y agoThree reactors melted down @ Fukushima Daiichi. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_Daiichi_nuclear_disaster#Units_1,_2,_and_3 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_Daiichi_nuclear_disa...
- hairytrog 8y agocorrect
- Gibbon1 8y agoThree mile Island's core also melted by didn't breach containment. That fact hasn't been widely publicized. And there is a tendency to skip over that TMI is on the Susquehanna River which drains into Chesapeake Bay. TMI came within hours of being a monumental disaster.