4 ms·
If I had to guess, you're a skeptic of the existence of IQ, or at least you're expressing a viewpoint in line with that. I don't know how to break it to you, bu
by chongli 8y ago
If I had to guess, you're a skeptic of the existence of IQ, or at least you're expressing a viewpoint in line with that. I don't know how to break it to you, but the mountain of evidence is not on your side.
Set aside Terence Tao and consider another mathematician, John Von Neumann. He had mastered differential and integral calculus, could converse in ancient Greek (among several other languages), and read through the entire 46-volume Allgemeine Geschichte in Einzeldarstellungen (essentially the history of the world, according to Wilhelm Oncken) at the age of 8, all without ever setting foot in a classroom. You can't seriously suggest that he benefitted from better teaching when he was entirely self-taught.
Contrast this with students who get all the way through high school and still cannot read or write above an elementary school level, who cannot perform basic arithmetic without a calculator, all of this despite thousands of hours of effort.
- jacobolus 8y agoVon Neumann had the full-time 1:1 attention of a (presumably brilliant) nanny and significant 1:1 time from several additional expert private tutors starting from an early age, as well as a ton of parental support. That is way more useful than sitting in any classroom. Then he was the kind of kid who liked to walk around town doing arithmetic calculations in his head, and was passionately curious about everything and spent tons of time reading throughout his childhood. By the time he got to school he was several years more prepared than most of the other students. The dude was obviously very clever, but it’s not like you can learn to speak several languages and understand advanced mathematics from scratch just by staring at the wall with no input or feedback. My 2-year-old has a bigger vocabulary and better grammar than any kids his age at the local playground. That’s because we read challenging books together 2+ hours per day, not because he is some kind of superhuman genius. He also runs faster and with more stamina – because he gets a ton more practice than most running and playing outside. On the other hand, he doesn’t fluently speak 4 languages like the kids whose parents speak 4 languages to them daily, he isn’t so good yet at climbing or throwing or drawing since he isn’t very excited about those skills/activities yet and doesn’t practice them regularly. It’s not a priority for me, but I would not be at all surprised if he ends up learning basic calculus before age 10.
- chongli 8y agoYou're getting the story backwards. Von Neumann didn't start working with private tutors until after he had manifested his prodigious mathematical talent, in high school. He was a genius who could multiply and divide pairs of 8 digit numbers in his head, as a six-year-old. The advanced mathematics he taught himself from textbooks. Sure, his parents provided him with the books, but he did the work on his own. advanced mathematics from scratch just by staring at the wall That's an absurd strawman.
- jacobolus 8y agoFrom what I remember he was working with private language tutors starting as a toddler. I might not have that right though. I should read a decent biography sometime.
- chongli 8y agoJust another tidbit: Von Neumann had no education in chemistry until adulthood, yet he was able to complete his degree in chemical engineering while simultaneously obtaining his PhD in mathematics, all in the span of 3 years.