3 ms·
Now try backing up your conversations and group memberships - I've rarely seen so convoluted and user hostile process which practically ensures people will lose
by izacus 8y ago
Now try backing up your conversations and group memberships - I've rarely seen so convoluted and user hostile process which practically ensures people will lose their chat histories and just switch to FB Messenger in disgust.
I do admit the rest of the experience has improved, although the ban from binding more a single device to an account is still preventing me from using it more.
- metildaa 8y agoCheck out my other comment about pyre.chat and signal-weechat, perhaps one of them will work for your use case? Signal does need serious help on the backup/restore process, iOS users are left in the cold and Android backups often fail when one attempts to restore them. I've followed up on issues on Signal Android about backups being borked (even getting Moxie to fix a bug at one point) but backups are obviously not a priority for the Signal Foundation. Very frustrating, and it has caused my friends and acquaintances to ragequit Signal in some cases.
- bilal4hmed 8y agowhat are other secure apps that are competition for Signal and do some of the other things right ?
- whitepoplar 8y agoWhatsApp uses the Signal Protocol and Wire uses a derivative of it (not the actual Signal Protocol). Both collect metadata that Signal doesn't (and I believe the last time I checked, WhatsApp stored unencrypted chat history to iCloud).
- robocap37 8y agoyou are correct about chats being unencrypted in icloud as well as google drive. So looks like signal is the least of all evils at the moment
- tptacek 8y agoWire uses a protocol derived from and related to Signal Protocol, but does not implement Signal Protocol.
- whitepoplar 8y agoThanks for the correction; fixed. I had always thought that Wire implemented the protocol explicitly, but I guess not.
- cyphar 8y agoMatrix is designed such that all of your chat history is preserved (as long as at least one of the servers involved in the chat wants to keep the logs). And the new ephemeral key backup system allows you to really simply get set up on a new device and have all of your old chat history available (if you want, you have to opt-in to it).
- tptacek 8y agoMatrix is not a reasonable Signal alternative. If you want something in the vicinity of the security model of Signal, but with more UX polish (and less privacy), Wire is your best bet.
- cyphar 8y agoIn which aspect is it not a reasonable Signal alternative? I know that you have expressed a dislike of Matrix before, but I'm not sure if your point here is that it isn't a Signal alternative or that it isn't reasonable (in a crypto sense).