3 ms·
Maciej - I think my viewpoint on the surveillance industry is pretty similar. But reading your description of the current state of affairs still put a shiver up
by mindslight 8y ago
Maciej - I think my viewpoint on the surveillance industry is pretty similar. But reading your description of the current state of affairs still put a shiver up my spine. I can't even pinpoint a single passage that did it. Rather the sheer disconnect between the technological world we envisioned and the world they built is overwhelming, and you really got that across.
I think throwing the GDPR under the bus based on how the surveillance industry is doing its best to malinterpret it is a bit off. A popup with a list of task-orthogonal surveillance companies demanding consent is obviously an anti-pattern. The prudent course feels like to wait and see how the GDPR actually turns out in practice, and then hopefully adopt it as-is.
What I worry about in the meantime is a half-baked "Americanized" implementation that guts its strongest provisions ("Right To Download" -> "correct" feels like already trying to fortify a backstop! Why can't I simply just erase?), and blesses ongoing abuses. A disingenuous standard of purported consent is pervasive in our entire society, and I don't see why this topic will turn out any different. I can forsee EU regulators concluding that surveillance-based-advertising is not a necessary part of simply viewing a news article, whereas I can see a US regulator blessing that practice.
Which maybe implies that "copy GDPR" is actually a decent answer right now, even not knowing how it will turn out. For one, it tells US companies that they need to take the GDPR seriously rather than throwing "block EU" hissy fits. If it's really as unworkable as the surveillance industry public relations make it sound, I'm sure they'll have no problems modifying it.
- idlewords 8y agoI'm sorry that you read my statement as so hostile to the GDPR. The consensus at the hearing I think was unanimous—that so much of the GDPR is open to regulatory interpretation that it is hard to evaluate yet. My fellow witness said there's a value to not going first, and I wholly agree with him. I believe we all testified it has made people safer. That said, there is time pressure on Congress because of the 2020 California law. The tech companies and data brokers are scared of 50 state laws on this and are pushing for the mildest form of Federal regulation they can get, to pre-empt state laws, and that is the context of the fight. I think the GDPR is inadequate but much better than nothing, and I tried to convey that in my testimony.
- mindslight 8y agoI didn't take it as outright "hostile", but rather more of a basis with which to pivot into the idea of doing something different. Which feels like playing to lawmakers' interest / American exceptionalism of doing something "better", but counterproductive given how the US lawmaking process works. I'm also not personally a huge fan of the GDPR as is, because I agree we have no idea how it will actually play out. But I don't think the American philosophy will be productive at coming up with a different approach. So if it's to be one national regime, why not simply match the EU for now? If we can't do that, then honestly each state having a different approach sounds better for individuals (assuming it it doesn't devolve into companies demanding one's physical address for compliance). It's more likely that one state will properly codify the idea that users should have full control over data about themselves. Ultimately I don't think we'll end up with sensible-looking legislation unless legislators actually get down and dirty with the technical specifics. For example, the brokenness of the cookie law actually necessitating cookies could have been avoided by mandating a fixed cookie/header format to express the preference rather than allowing every site to come up with its own bespoke implementation.
- idlewords 8y agoThe problem with saying "let's just match the EU" is that key parts of the GDPR are still undecided. What is a "legitimate business interest" for data collection? What are the limits to algorithmic decisionmaking? No one knows. A regime with 50 state privacy laws would result in every website you visit having a consent click-through where you agree to abide by Alabama privacy laws (or whoever wins that race to the bottom).
- mindslight 8y agoBut how can it not come down to judgment calls? We're essentially trying to define the contour of a new right. If we stick with the axiomatic approach, then it feels like we can only end up essentially right back where we are now - data collected by companies is theirs to do with as they like. FWIW are you sure it would be a race to the bottom (companies going to the least-restrictive state) ? In the context of salestax/cookie-nexus, I would have hopes that it would be a race to the top (users benefiting from being in a more-restrictive state). Which is why I'd think the worry would be every random service demanding to verify your address to keep you from claiming to be in the more restrictive states.