3 ms·
I think the endorsements should acknowledge that one can't necessarily trust the rest of the smartphone software and hardware.
by neilv 8y ago
I think the endorsements should acknowledge that one can't necessarily trust the rest of the smartphone software and hardware.
- matt4077 8y agoI don’t know if this level of cynicism is helpful. If taken to its logical conclusion, one would just give up on electronic communication. That comes with some costs, either economically, or in being exposed to other safety risks associated with offline communication, or being less effective in whatever one wants to achieve with that communication. Or, people will conclude that everything is compromised anyway, and therefore not take the reasonable steps because “why bother?” I also don’t think the idea that all hardware is compromised should just be accepted as fact. There is more that speaks against that thesis than in its favor, including the high market value of iOS exploits and the length Apple and the FBI went to in their fight over that shooter’s iPhone. Apple especially has taken some steps that seem to deserve some credit. After all, if we refuse to see the differences in their approach to others’, they (and everyone else) will just learn from it not to even try making privacy part of the value proposition.
- neilv 8y agoJournalists and dissidents are being encouraged to use this software, on platforms we know to be insecure.
- dontbenebby 8y ago>Journalists and dissidents are being encouraged to use this software, on platforms we know to be insecure. What specific platforms, and what are their insecurities?
- dontbenebby 8y ago> I think the endorsements should acknowledge that one can't necessarily trust the rest of the smartphone software and hardware. Welp, guess I should just send my messages in the clear then rather than make them work for them
- neilv 8y agoRecommending a solution for a critical need without communicating the limitations doesn't seem like good engineering practice.
- dontbenebby 8y ago> Recommending a solution for a critical need without communicating the limitations doesn't seem like good engineering practice. Good security advice is about harm reduction. Security advice is not "bad" because it does not achieve perfect security. Using Signal instead of an app the government can access through subpoenas (Facebook Messenger), that is closed source (iMessage) or transmits in the clear (traditional SMS) is good advice because it reduces harm and reduces risk.
- neilv 8y agoWe can't know all threat models and options of everyone who is the audience of such broadcast endorsements, such that we can engage in noble lies and confidently call it "harm reduction". (Simple scenario: journalist was told by experts that such-and-such is secure, without qualification, so journalist uses it in some ways that they would not, had they been given a more accurate characterization.)
- dontbenebby 8y agoHow is saying "I endorse using Signal" a lie? Seems like that's a statement of opinion.
- neilv 8y agoYou can see my first comment in this thread, which you took exception to. This is a very important topic, and I'm not debating recreationally. There is a long and ongoing history of security advocates overstating security, to people who really need it, and that's the sort of thing that can get people killed, positive movements ended, etc. Anyone advocating right now should be aware of that, and not keep making the same mistakes.