3 ms·
You are projecting your personal framing of a particular problem space onto all other people and then further framing it as some kind of objective and irrefutab
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
You are projecting your personal framing of a particular problem space onto all other people and then further framing it as some kind of objective and irrefutable truth.
I spent a lot of time in therapy, so I don't suffer a lot of existential guilt. I've generally walked the walk on things I believe in, so I don't have a lot of guilt of the type you are describing.
I'm not unaware of the fact that anyone can potentially find themselves tossed in jail over basically bullshit reasons. This happens at times to tourists who are doing nothing wrong according to the law of their country, but it's a serious offense in the country they are visiting.
My last boyfriend spent three years in prison in his youth for his political activism. He also was trying to talk me into illegal activities that would have benefitted him and not particularly endangered him. He tried to justify this with reasoning similar to yours.
So I've had plenty of opportunity to think about such things and my mental framework is likely not anything I can adequately explain in a single comment on HN.
But perhaps an anecdote will have a modicum of value.
I had food stamps for part of the time that I was homeless. Food stamps cannot be used for non food items and it is illegal to convert them to cash by, for example, offering to buy groceries for someone in exchange for cash for a portion of the value.
There is one loophole that I know of: food stamps cover the CRV, a charge on cans and bottles in California. You can then take the cans and bottles back for a cash refund after consuming the contents.
A lot of homeless people break the law regularly as a matter of course merely to survive or merely by existing. I no doubt was breaking the law every single night by sleeping someplace I wasn't supposed to be.
But I didn't use that as an excuse to justify doing any damn thing I wanted and to hell with the law. I did my best to find legal ways to get my needs met to the best of my ability.
While homeless, I was repeatedly offered money for sex in a state where prostitution is illegal. I have zero moral qualms about the idea, but was celibate for medical reasons, so wasn't tempted to take the money. I also had it hinted to me that I could potentially get scads of money from some guy I knew if I would launder some of his money. I ended our so called friendship.
Among other things, I run several blogs to put out useful info for homeless Americans. I do this in part to try to point them to practical legal solutions that have some hope of actually working.
I also do my best to put out good information on what we can do to actually improve things in a way that will help address the issue of homelessness. I'm aware that it is a genuinely hard problem. I have done a lot of research and I try to educate people while keeping the information accessible in a way that conceptually simplifies a complex issue without distorting it or watering it down.
I believe the solution to the issue you are wrapped around the axel about is twofold:
1. Educate people about what they can do to get their needs met that is legal.
2. Increase the availability of viable, legal solutions.
I do my best to walk the walk on that conceptualization of the problem space. I'm aware I'm only one person and there is only so much I can do, so either the road rises up to meet me or I'm doomed anyway.
I'm plenty frustrated at the fact that the road mostly does not appear to be rising up to meet me when it comes to certain things. But that's not on me. That's mostly on other people and their shit.
My websites don't get a lot of traffic, nor do they make much money. Other people mostly are not promoting nor supporting my work.
In fact, I get actively stonewalled. For example, I was thrown off of Metafilter, nominally for "promoting my websites." It's basically a cesspit of classist asshats, so my real crime is probably something more like "having the ridiculous expectation of being treated like a human being."
The world has hung plenty of it's baggage on me already, thank you. I have no plans to agree to accept more of it. That includes yours.
If you worked on your framing, you might find that we agree on a lot of things. Of course, you aren't obligated to do that. I am equally not obligated to agree with how you choose to frame it.
- soulofmischief 8y agoAll of that talk about people making assumptions about you over the internet without knowing you, and you begin this conversation with: > You are projecting your personal framing of a particular problem space onto all other people and then further framing it as some kind of objective and irrefutable truth. You're already projecting, already assuming, already attempting to paint me negatively before even beginning the discussion. This leads me to believe you must partially be projecting when you tell others they don't know you. Because here you are doing the same exact thing! > I spent a lot of time in therapy, so I don't suffer a lot of existential guilt. I've generally walked the walk on things I believe in, so I don't have a lot of guilt of the type you are describing. And with the second sentence, we've already made this a conversation about you. What follows, surely, will be a large personal anecdote, which the act of dissecting would cause you to claim that I am personally attacking you or silencing you. And remember: You approached me first. How is engaging in conversation this way either constructive or relevant? > My last boyfriend spent three years in prison in his youth for his political activism. He also was trying to talk me into illegal activities that would have benefitted him and not particularly endangered him. He tried to justify this with reasoning similar to yours. You very unsubtly just projected your boyfriend onto me. I'm not your ex-boyfriend, honey. I am not trying to talk you into committing crimes for my benefit. All of the issues I listed revolved around human rights. If you think those issues aren't important, that's your own issue that you need to work out, but don't compare them to whatever ideology your ex-boyfriend supposedly espoused. That is just not relevant. > ut perhaps an anecdote will have a modicum of value. Perhaps not. This is typically the case. > A lot of homeless people break the law regularly as a matter of course merely to survive or merely by existing. I no doubt was breaking the law every single night by sleeping someplace I wasn't supposed to be. Yes. This is an extension of my last post. The government has created criminality out of necessity. > But I didn't use that as an excuse to justify doing any damn thing I wanted and to hell with the law. You're strawmanning my original discussion now. I never made such a ridiculous assertion. I only listed a set of legal concepts which revolve around human rights. You are now deliberately coloring this discussion, and since we're no longer talking about my original post, I will stop reading your post any further. You need to kick this dopamine feedback loop where you get off on being victimized. You're derailing discussions and attacking people like me under the veil of being attacked yourself. > If you worked on your framing, you might find that we agree on a lot of things. Yeah, if I just thought the way you did and framed everything the way you did, we most certainly would agree! I thank the heavens this is not the case and that I do not frame online discussions in the same manner as yourself.