13 ms·
John Tierney’s writing was roundly, soundly debunked 20 years ago. It’s amazing to me that it continues to do damage. https://www.heartland.org/_template-asset
by dahart 8y ago
John Tierney’s writing was roundly, soundly debunked 20 years ago. It’s amazing to me that it continues to do damage.
https://www.heartland.org/_template-assets/documents/publications/4030.pdf https://www.heartland.org/_template-assets/documents/publica...
https://www.technologyreview.com/s/400100/recycling-is-not-garbage/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/400100/recycling-is-not-g...
> Recycling arose out of 1980’s landfill anxiety
That’s the first anti-recycling myth addressed above. It sure seems like this argument is being recycled.
> we have plenty of space,
Anti-recycling myth #3...
> What a waste of tax dollars
Garbage disposal is also funded by taxes. Whatever, fewer dollars are spent on both garbage and recycling combined than are lost in the margins of military spending. If you really cared about taxes at all, you’d know recycling is irrelevant.
- landon32 8y agoThe first link you posted an article from over 25 years ago from an organization that denies human caused climate change and prioritizes science that makes their donors happy. I would take it with a grain of salt.
- dahart 8y ago> an article from over 25 years ago It’s a direct response to an even older article the parent comment posted that preceded it. BTW, May 2019 - June 1996 is just less than 23 years. > from an organization that denies humans caused climate change The Environmental Defense Fund denies human factors? I think you’re mistaken. Can you please provide a source for that claim? Or are you talking about Heartland... did you confuse the hosting web site with the authors?
- lupire 8y agoEDF was founded to ban DDT, widely but controversially regarded as one of the worst mistakes of environmentalism.
- inflatableDodo 8y agoI think you might be overemphasising the view of a rather small minority there.
- dahart 8y ago> EDF was founded to bad DDT Right, thanks, yes EDF was founded on the very idea of human factors. I guess @landon32’s comment mistook the URL I used for the source of the information. I can’t find the full article on the EDF site, just a shortened version. Or maybe that comment was intentionally trying to cast doubt by association? Is the history of DDT relevant to the recycling debate, or are you hoping to cast doubt by association? > widely but controversially regarded as one of the worst mistakes of environmentalism. “the United States ban on DDT is a major factor in the comeback of the bald eagle (the national bird of the United States) and the peregrine falcon from near-extinction in the contiguous United States.” https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/DDT https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/DDT I like bald eagles. And I don’t want DDT used on my food. Do you?? I’d never heard the idea that banning DDT is a mistake. I’m trying to find some reputable sources for the claim that this is widely believed. The Wikipedia article doesn’t exactly back up that claim, so do you want to provide some? “A few people and groups have argued that limitations on DDT use for public health purposes have caused unnecessary morbidity and mortality from vector-borne diseases” https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/DDT#Criticism_of_restrictions_on_DDT_use https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/DDT#Criticism_of_restriction...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- specialist 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Tierney_(journalist)#Views https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Tierney_(journalist)#View... "Joseph J. Romm has written that Tierney is one of the "influential but misinformed" skeptics who have helped prevent the U.S. from taking action on climate change. ..." -- Back in the day of dial-up BBSes, our offline mail readers had "twit filters". Precursor to today's ad blockers. Gods I miss that functionality. I keep day dreaming about what today's twit filter might look like. Maybe a RSS reader.
- arkades 8y agoI found these rebuttals well argued, well supported, and convincing. Thank you for digging them up.
- zaroth 8y ago> What a waste of tax dollars The better point is we can spend the dollars more effectively to improve the environment. The military / military spending has nothing to do with it.
- dahart 8y agoRecycling already is a more effective expenditure than landfill. If there are even better ways, please contribute them to the discussion! > military spending has nothing to do with it. That’s right. Military spending is simply what one should be concerned about if they are worried about taxes. Military spending is greater than 50% of all tax expenditure in the US. Waste management is such a small fraction, it’s in the noise, far below military, and other things like roads and education.
- zaroth 8y ago> Recycling already is a more effective expenditure than landfill. There are some materials where there is a net economic benefit to recycling, such as aluminum and to a lesser extent steel and glass. There are also materials where it’s a net cost (in excess of landfill dumping fees) to recycle the material, such as many plastics. If we are paying in aggregate millions of dollars to recycle this material, it makes sense to ask could those dollars be put to better use. Also worth noting I don’t pay for garbage and refuse through my local taxes, I have a private service which I pay to pickup my trash. Many towns are moving to this model so that residents who make less trash can pay less. Military spending is 50% of “discretionary” spending, but about 1/6th of total spending. “Discretionary” means spending appropriated each year, versus spending which is based on existing laws and not the annual budget. I’m sure there’s many ways that money could be better spent as well, but it doesn’t change the fact that we should invest efficiently in environmental protection.
- dahart 8y agoFirst, thanks for the reply. What I like about the discussion, even when I disagree, is that I think you and everyone here are truly pro-conservation as a goal and ideal, both economically and environmentally. We all want the same thing, less waste, there are just minor differences of opinion about how to get there. What I don’t like about the article posted and about Tierney’s quite misguided writing is the negative headlines that immediately give the reader the impression that inaction is better than action. There are many cherry-picked statistics being used to paint a narrative that is more or less the opposite of truth, at least in Tierney’s work. I encourage you to read it and the rebuttals I posted and make up your own mind. > There are some materials where there is a net economic benefit to recycling Personally speaking, money is not what I care about. Recycling’s primary goals are to stop using non-renewables and stop toxic pollution and damage to the environment, not to be cheaper than being lazy. I don’t care if it costs more to value the environment, I want clean air and water, forever. I realize it’s going to take strong economic arguments to get us all moving, and I’m in no way in favor of wasting money, but in terms of priorities and the way we evaluate what’s worth doing, I believe waiting for clear and undeniable and unarguable economic benefit is probably a mistake. I furthermore think that cost-benefit analysis of environmental factors is a deeply flawed idea. By reducing things to dollars, we’re losing our actual values. This study examined previous environmental cost-benefit analyses, and concluded they were wrong by orders of magnitude: https://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1326&context=facpub https://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?a... I think in a hundred or two hundred years if we run out of petroleum, if we need expensive air and water filters in order to survive, our great great grandchildren might look back and realize how pathetic and petty the idea was that we decided we needed to make valuing the earth cheaper than screwing it up before we were willing to budge.
- justnotworthit 8y agoRe: Space. From the PDF: >Anti-recycling myth #3: Landfill space is cheap and abundant. > Fact: Landfill space is a commodity, priced according to supply and demand. The majority of the growth of recycling in the United States has occurred in populated regions where landfills are expensive relative to the U.S. average. I stared at this for a while trying to get at the heart of the issue. The response isn't "no, there isn't space." More like, market forces show that it isn't cheaper than recycling. Perhaps the argument use to be "why bother recycling at all if creating new is cheaper"? I think it's currently a de facto non-issue: Things that are worth recycling are being recycled, and things that aren't are going to be dumped/burned.