6 ms·
The reason many places don't do this is not so much to avoid feeling like an a-hole but to avoid accidental liability. There are so many things you can't say o
by ams6110 16y ago
The reason many places don't do this is not so much to avoid feeling like an a-hole but to avoid accidental liability.
There are so many things you can't say or ask in an interview, that a lot of companies that are big enough to have an HR person or department will require a very generic rejection letter just to be sure they don't provide grounds for a lawsuit.
- verysimple 16y agoIndeed, no good deed goes unpunished these days.
- loumf 16y agoUnfortunately, the accidental liability problem needs to be taken seriously -- mostly because of risk/reward. I try to write as nice and appreciative letter as possible. 1. I don't reject candidates -- I choose a different candidate. 2. The more they went through the process, the longer (and better) the letter. Rejected application, short thank you for applying. If you came for two interviews, but then we went with someone else -- I write a longer letter with references to the meetings. 3. Good candidates that we didn't hire (because another was better) are invited into my personal network. I recommend them to others, I invite them to dev events, etc. I give non-specific-to-our-interview job hunting advice. We'll have openings at some point. 4. I do the same for candidates that are just not a fit (they do X, we need Y). I might never hire them, but I have a personal goal to know every good developer within commute distance of my company (we live in a low population area).
- Dylanlacey 16y agoI think 3 is a really great idea. Do you find that, in doing so, you get additional benefits yourself? I imagine you've already got places to look for new hires ect.
- loumf 16y agoAbsolutely. All of the benefits you'd get from knowing smart people. The biggest benefit has been recommending them to others.
- mscarborough 16y agoYour approach sounds great! If candidates know this is how you conduct the interview process, it seems very positive and always keeps the door open.
- jhchen 16y agoIs there a way I can just waive my ability to sue? I would love to know my weaknesses in the eyes of others.
- tomerico 16y agoNot likely. Consider an extreme example where they admit they didn't hire you because you are black. They broke the law and cannot be protected. In other words, your signature does not provide a lot of legal security
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- mikeryan 16y agoBecause the default tends to be to say nothing, frequently if you just ask directly for feedback may get it. Its a bit of a back door to the policy. When I worked for "MegaCorp" we didn't give any feedback voluntarily but if a candidate asked me directly I would let them know. I frequently hired junior engineers* and felt almost a responsibility to give them some input, particularly if their issue was technical. If they were just an ass, I'd likely stick to the company line and not say anything. * I found most senior engineers are pretty well aware of their deficiencies and almost never would ask for feedback.
- anamax 16y ago> Is there a way I can just waive my ability to sue? I would love to know my weaknesses in the eyes of others. If you could (and it was binding), HR departments would try to require such waivers.
- mcritz 16y agoAvoiding a lawsuit is as easy as not citing illegal reasons for not hiring someone. E.g. “You’re a woman,” “you’re Indian,” “we’re uncertain how your disability will effect our workplace,” or “you’re too old.” (Or their codeword equivalents.) I think the author is just being civil and I commend him for it.
- smallblacksun 16y agoA good lawyer can twist almost anything into an illegal reason.
- tptacek 16y agoNo. All you have to do is interview someone in a protected hiring class, and then say something in the rejection that contradicts or is in any way inconsistent with anything you have said or the candidate can claim you have said. Litigious candidates don't have to play to win the lawsuit, either; they can play to settle.
- mpk 16y agoSure, those reasons are pretty obvious. If you want to familiarize yourself with the main reasons, check out the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission's Q&A/FAQ page at http://www.eeoc.gov/facts/qanda.html http://www.eeoc.gov/facts/qanda.html If you haven't read it, I really recommend spending a few minutes reading it. It doesn't just apply to the hiring process and there are cases for drug use, religious accommodations, acting on genetic information (really), etc. I can certainly understand why people would prefer to send a generic rejection letter rather than list reasons, any of which may or may not trigger some clause in one of the relevant laws.
- metachris 16y agoThat's a reason why it is better to tell the candidate on the phone instead of in writing.
- brown9-2 16y agoThe bargain being made here though is reduced liability in exchange for missing out on a chance to make a really positive impression with someone who has had a pretty serious and beyond-the-surface experience with your company. I think this is the primary point the blog author is trying to make.
- MrFoof 16y agoThis is indeed true, and I'll never fault anyone for it. Though rarely have I encountered a rejection in which I didn't feel the same way -- actually, if I have a sense that something is amiss I prod around for it rather deliberately to see what sort of answers I can get out of folks. Sometimes you get the obvious red flags you were looking for, complete with obvious body language and visible frustration. Recently I quit my job and put myself out there again. One company employs headhunters and has a very well-known developer in their employ. So at the time I was pretty chuffed to line up an interview, figuring I had no risk of "slamming into the ceiling" at all. I already had two offers in front of me, but I figured it was worth pursuing. The best way I could describe the interview is if you were walking about as a child and saw an action movie hero that your admired -- and watched him punch out a six year old that happened to be in his way. Before he interviewed me the group manager asked what blogs I read, and I rifled them off with my thoughts on them. One I had mentioned that I didn't read, but that I was aware that he was attempting to make a name for himself by making more complex topics accessible to Joe average. Before the manager left he sternly warned me that if I were to mention that name in front of this individual, the interview would end immediately. The fellow himself was abrupt, intimidating, and rather smug. I've interviewed hundreds of people, so I can sympathize to an extent regarding the monotony of asking the same questions over and over, but I was able to gauge from other team members that he simply wasn't having a bad day, but that's how he is to folks outside of his circle. The recruiter had me come back in person to say that I was considered brilliant technically, but they would pass. She couldn't figure out why, so I mentioned that he gave pretty clear feedback on twitter, and it's not the first time he's done it. I pulled out my phone to prove it. The recruiter was a superbly nice person, the type that worries about and tries to take care of everyone. She was shocked to the verge of tears -- an opportunity she sells as manna from heaven, and those were the kinds of comments he'd pass on to thousands of people as opposed to delivering directly to the individual. I didn't consider his criticism harsh, as it was valid to pass on someone who wasn't a very assertive and confident Type A personality when your organization has invested decades in building up that specific culture. Not to mention it's difficult to seem eager when considering the prospect of working with an outright bully. She was upset enough that she had to leave the room, and the account manager and I spent the next hour dissecting the organization's culture. I think that's the only time I can ever really consider a rejection to not be kosher. Fortunately, the universe has a way of balancing these things out. His group is now one of my clients. I can't wait to see the look on his face when I pop into the room.