5 ms·
If you don't feel like a criminal in today's society, you are complicit.
by soulofmischief 8y ago
If you don't feel like a criminal in today's society, you are complicit.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoMy mother actually escaped East Germany in her teens. I have plenty of criticism of what's wrong with the US. For example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19888281 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19888281 But I don't actually agree with your assertion, nor with other comments suggesting that the US is currently about as bad as East Germany was. After she escaped, my mother helped multiple relatives get out. Family stories indicate that part of the process was sending enough cash to help them cover bribes to get their papers. My dad was an American soldier. The exchange rate was 4 West German marks to the dollar and 4 East German marks to the West German marks, or 16 East Marks to the dollar. My father's relative wealth and pragmatic attitude facilitated a lot of this. You didn't have any means to wire it or whatever. You sent cash. Sometimes it got to the intended recipient. Sometimes it didn't. It took tremendous faith, willingness to trust and callouses to keep sending help in the face of that and not just accuse desperate people of lying, etc. My dad was a remarkable man.
- cmurf 8y agoI agree it is not as bad as the DDR was, but it is way more decadent and that may end up being every bit as effective as a police state. No one wants to tip over this apple cart under some vague notion of ethics or actual equality - my goodness no, we want to keep on being entertained and to buy crap we don't need and have stuff. We have more attachment to stuff than we have to any sense of rights let alone normative behavior for leaders. It's a classist system of neo-feudalism and any attempt to moderate it is communism/socialism. Who needs a police state when most people believe the propaganda willingly and repeat it?
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI gave up my car more than a decade ago. I spent nearly six years homeless. I have lived in an SRO for about 18 months or so. Since getting divorced, I have mostly not owned a TV. I think I have been to one movie at a theater in the many years since my ex moved out. I'm aware it is a classist, sexist, racist system in many ways. I also seem to be the only woman to have ever spent time on the leaderboard of Hacker News. I hit the board under my original handle of Mz about a month or so after finally getting off the street, so a lot of the upvotes that got me to the leaderboard were gotten during the years I was homeless. I bitch regularly about the classism and sexism both in the world and on HN. But I'm not really the right person to aim your remark at. Because if you imagine you are "talking about me," then you have absolutely no idea whatsoever who the hell I am.
- coldtea 8y ago>Because if you imagine you are "talking about me," then you have absolutely no idea whatsoever who the hell I am. Making a point in a discussion is not about the personal circumstances of the one we're talking to. Doubly so if they're an outlier, and triply so if we don't know their circumstances to begin with, because the discussion happens in an online forum.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoA. I made that inference based on the framing of the remark, not based on straight up stupidity. B. Plenty of people here know plenty about my circumstances. I know because they routinely use that against me. So it is not unreasonable on my part to assume some people here do have some idea who I am and what I'm about. I was, in fact, very recently told I'm full of shit if I assume they don't: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19776469 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19776469
- coldtea 8y agoWell, I for one, never even knew the backstory. I wouldn't assume most do. Could be a few that have grievances against you or something. I've noticed that some people, on online forums, get an obsession with another they had a dispute with (and felt wronged or whatever), and follow them from post to post, gather intelligence, and act like stalkers. Then again, some people are cuckoo with no personal lives and compensate in all kinds of bizarro ways online. Best to ignore those kind of people...
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI'm not assuming most do. I would thank you to stop trying to police my participation here. You have something of a history of treating me like an idiot. If you want to engage some point I've made in a good faith manner: awesome. If you want to continue your pattern of talking at me like I have no fucking clue how public discourse on HN works, please stop doing that. I view it as a form of harassment. If you are not consciously aware of doing that, well, consider yourself notified that I have noticed a pattern of behavior here and it's something I don't like and don't want done to me. And if you are suggesting I simply "ignore" jacquesm, I assure you I've tried. He's impossible to ignore. He's extremely influential here.
- jlavine 8y ago> If you don't feel like a criminal in today's society, you are complicit. Which society exactly are you referring to? What crime are you claiming that every single member of this society is complicit in? How does feeling like a criminal itself absolve someone of complicity in this crime? You seem to be saying we should take on guilt for something precisely in order to free ourselves of this guilt. This seems like a paradoxical admonition. Could you please clarify?
- soulofmischief 8y ago“Show me the man and I’ll show you the crime” - Lavrentiy Beria Essentially, in modern society, if you do not feel like a criminal, it's because you are walking on eggshells around your government. Just about every modern government has laws on the books which are just plain ethically, morally, or constitutionally unjustified. The DMCA, the PATRIOT act, the listing of cryptography under non-exportable munitions, the War on Drugs, the US foreign drone strike program, whistleblower laws, same-sex marriage laws or even death penalties, (soon to be) Article 13, social credit systems, mass surveillance, threat of ostracization/deplatformization if you fall outside of or in the middle of the now-split Overton window, the militarization of police in some developing countries coupled with a growing propaganda-driven movement to disarm citizens in order to increase the power gap, neoliberalist consumerist lifestyles propped up by military coups, dictatorships, and pollution sinks in developing countries. I could keep going. But what it boils down to, is that if you don't find yourself at odds with the way things are being run in most parts of the developed world (not just the US) then you're either living under a rock, or complicit. If you're in the UK, it also means you like your sex without salt. And, as ignorance is not an excuse in a society where you have plenty access to such information, you are still complicit. I think a bit of guilt over the way our lifestyles impact the health of the earth and the lives of other people is certainly in order. I think some guilt over allowing our brand new rebel government to turn into the world's largest bully and largest perpetrator/denier of climate change, some guilt over not participating in activities which put you directly at odds against your government for the sake of knowledge or ethics, is entirely in order. Guilt gets things done.
- DoreenMichele 8y ago