3 ms·
Gotta love deregulation. Remind me, when's the last time we had a major fatality incident in the US domestic passenger airline business? And how does that com
by CamperBob2 8y ago
Gotta love deregulation.
Remind me, when's the last time we had a major fatality incident in the US domestic passenger airline business?
And how does that compare with the prevailing state of affairs before "deregulation?"
Difficulty: answer with numbers, please, rather than insults, downvotes, or political attacks.
- sokoloff 8y agoColgan Air 2407 was in 2009. Comair 5191 was 2006. Both, like most airplane crashes, were substantially pilot error. (Both of these were primarily pilot error.) Weather forecasting has gotten much better in the years since deregulation. We’ve also been operating a mostly-jet fleet, which has larger inherent performance margins than the turboprops (and, worse, pistons) before them. And we have decades of experience about how pilots kill airplanes to inform operations and regulations. It’s not clear that airfare deregulation either hurt nor helped airline safety in the US. US-flag air carrier ops are extraordinarily safe and I believe the FAA makes a positive contribution to that outcome.
- blattimwind 8y ago> Remind me, when's the last time we had a major fatality incident in the US domestic passenger airline business? Doesn't really matter much. Incidents in aviation that can happen on continent X could usually have happened on any continent.
- CamperBob2 8y agoA good counterexample: in the Lion Air case, at least one planeload of passengers came within a hair's-breadth of disaster prior to the fatal crash. The pilots figured out what to do in time, in part because a third pilot was available to RTFM while the other two flew the airplane. However, that crew not only didn't take any action to remove the aircraft from service, they apparently didn't even bother to leave a Post-It note on the dashboard. The regulations we have in place here in the US -- to say nothing of our airlines' own policies -- would have kept that aircraft grounded until the problem was diagnosed and addressed.
- salawat 8y agoHe didn't RTFM actually. They performed Crew Resource Management, and he was able to focus his attention on controls the other two pilots didn't have time to manage. Hence noticing the trim wheels running amok.
- CamperBob2 8y agoGood point, I was just echoing some of the earliest news accounts there. Those stories came out before it became apparent that the flight manuals didn't actually have much useful information on the subject.