3 ms·
Boeing declined to detail the specific functionality of the two switches It seems like that's really the crux of the problem. They made changes that they didn
by CamperBob2 8y ago
Boeing declined to detail the specific functionality of the two switches
It seems like that's really the crux of the problem. They made changes that they didn't feel it was necessary to tell their customers about. Just another step along the "I know you bought this product from us, but it's still our product at the end of the day" timeline that we're stuck on.
Further, I'll bet that it transpires that no one entity inside Boeing is really to blame for this mess. The engineers in charge of the AOA indicator subsystem didn't know that someone else in the company was going to drive a safety-critical component from it. And that engineering group may not have realized that the AOA data they were getting came from only one of the two sensors. My guess is that Boeing not only hid this information from their customers, they hid it from themselves.
The problem will have to be addressed at the top, but I don't agree with those who say that blaming, firing, or jailing the CEO is going to be helpful. The culture that allowed this to happen will have grown organically over time.
- bumby 8y agoI think their safety system analysis made the connection MCAS is potentially hazardous as previously reported by the Seattle Times
- jeremyjh 8y agoWhen a culture becomes this defective, the top people need to end their careers in disgrace. This provides the necessary context, clearance and incentives for others to pick up the pieces and make substantial reforms.
- CamperBob2 8y agoActually what it provides is the necessary context for fear-based decisionmaking, misallocation of resources, metastatic bureaucracy, R&D stagnation, and ultimately departure of talent. There is a reason why the aviation industry focuses on fixing the problem rather than the blame. A witch hunt makes everybody feel better in the short term but provides no guarantee of actual forward progress.
- jeremyjh 8y agoThe problem here is corporate greed and willfully blind governance. It’s not a technical issue.