3 ms·
>>> ... we can never make any more until we get to the outer planets. We can. It isn't easy/cheap and may never be totally practical, but it can be done for l
by sandworm101 8y ago
>>> ... we can never make any more until we get to the outer planets.
We can. It isn't easy/cheap and may never be totally practical, but it can be done for less than the costs of getting it from the outer planets.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fusor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fusor
There are also replacements for helium. They aren't exact replacements and do come with their own issues (liquid hydrogen = fire). With effort, they can be used. Hydrogen under vacuum pressure can be made to boil at temperatures close enough to helium for most applications.
Helium can also be recycled, which today rarely happens. It is not generally collected as a gas and re-liquefied. Maybe if its availability goes down, driving its cost up, people might make efforts to recapture the helium they boil.
- orev 8y agoMost of the time when people make comments like that, they don’t actually mean “impossible” — they mean within the realm of reality. No one is going to be fusing helium in quantities high enough to run MRI machines. It would greatly add to the discussion if we didn’t have to address these red herrings.
- sandworm101 8y agoNot how we use it now, but the total amount of helium needed to run an MRI machine (with recapture) isn't all that much. Devices like acoustic cold fingers can use a very very small amount of helium to create a steady heat pump. Currently, such devices are not integrated into MRI machines because tubs of liquid helium are cheaper, but there is no reason why we couldn't build a closed-cycle MRI machine that didn't use any net helium. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermoacoustic_heat_engine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermoacoustic_heat_engine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pulse_tube_refrigerator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pulse_tube_refrigerator
- yostrovs 8y agoThere are MRI machines that use nearly zero helium: https://www.medgadget.com/2018/09/philips-helium-free-mri-system-combines-productivity-with-high-quality-imaging.html https://www.medgadget.com/2018/09/philips-helium-free-mri-sy...
- HarryHirsch 8y agoLarge NMR facilities have started recycling their helium: Yale, Harvard, Madison, UGA.
- orev 8y agoAgain, not the point of the discussion. MRI was a simple example of how we use helium today. I could have easily said party balloons. It would help any conversation you have in general to avoid nitpicking on insignificant items and keep the discussion on the main point (which, if I have to spell it out, is the quantity of helium required to do various things) I do understand that when helium is depleted we will probably find other ways to accomplish things, but it’s still silly to be venting a gas that we KNOW has a finite amount over the lifetime of the Earth or using it for party balloons.
- daodedickinson 8y agoIt wasn't a red herring - the post he replied to reads: "we can never make any more until we get to the outer planets."
- c3534l 8y agoOf course not, not when helium is relatively cheap and plentiful. But when we're nearly out of helium, you'd better bet we'll figure it out.
- Retric 8y agoFarnsworth fusors are primarily interesting nightlights not a source of Helium. Otherwise they would quickly kill everyone in the room when you turn them on. Even if the entire world was 100% running on fusion power we would still be short orders of magnitude from our current demand. MRI machines can switch to designs that don’t use helium, parties are simply going to have to go without long term.
- colechristensen 8y agoI did the calculations once and the heat generated by helium production equal to use was approximately equal to the total solar radiation on the planet. Cheap and practical don't make the cut, the physics of fusing hydrogen make it impossible.