6 ms·
This article attacks a straw man. Being falsifiable is necessary but it is not sufficient to be considered a scientific hypothesis. Such a hypothesis also, an
by lisper 8y ago
This article attacks a straw man. Being falsifiable is necessary but it is not sufficient to be considered a scientific hypothesis. Such a hypothesis also, and more importantly, has to provide a better explanation of some phenomenon than the current best theory. Experimental evidence is only brought to bear to decide among plausible alternative theories after the vast majority of candidate theories have been eliminated for not providing good explanations.
It's easy to see that this must be true because we can only ever have a finite amount of data, and that will always be consistent with an infinite number of falsifiable theories (c.f. Russell's teapot). So data cannot possibly help us choose from among those.
- logicchop 8y agoPopper heavily criticizes the value of explanation. He gives examples of really great "explanations" that have almost zero empirical value (things like psychoanalysis). Hard to see how it could be a "straw man."
- akvadrako 8y agoI don’t think that’s true. One of the most prominent figures to continue developing popper’s philosophy is David Deutsch, and he emphasizes good explanations. Being a good explanation means, among other things, it has a wide range of applicability and is hard to adjust if predictions don’t work out. Psychoanalysis wasn’t a good answer.
- logicchop 8y agoIt's easy to go read Popper. Look for his discussions of Adler.
- vixen99 8y agoBut as we know, these examples are not 'great', they're lousy explanations because they are not testable. Good explanations are another matter altogether as Deutsch points out in his criticism of the instrumentalist view of quantum theory.
- Animats 8y ago"Science is prediction, not explanation." - Fred Hoyle.
- mannykannot 8y agoWhich is rather ironic, considering how long he continued to oppose the big-bang theory even after its successful prediction of background radiation (and the explanation of isotope ratios is as good as a prediction, given that the processes are no longer happening.) I'm wondering if he made that statement specifically to avoid these issues?
- lorriman 8y agoI heard Fred Hoyle when he came to lecture at my school in the 80s (a prestigious, rich boys school). It was one of the few places willing to give him the time as his views were vaguely in line with Christian creationism though he was an atheist, ironically. It was doubly ironic in that the school was Catholic and Catholic Christianity is not biblically literalist. In fact the inventor of the Big Bang theory eventually became a Catholic priest. hahaha!
- lisper 8y ago> Popper heavily criticizes the value of explanation You have misunderstood Popper. Psychoanalysis is an example he cites of a bad explanation (because it's not falsifiable). He doesn't criticize explanation in general. That would be throwing out the baby with the bathwater.
- mannykannot 8y agoFurthermore, if I have understood Popper's criticism of psychoanalysis, he thought it was treating these bad or unsupported 'explanations' / just-so stories as if they provided, or could substitute for, real evidence.
- lisper 8y agohttps://plato.stanford.edu/entries/popper/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/popper/ "[Popper] discovered the psychoanalytic theories of Freud and Adler (he served briefly as a voluntary social worker with deprived children in one of the latter’s clinics in the 1920s), and listened entranced to a lecture which Einstein gave in Vienna on relativity theory. The dominance of the critical spirit in Einstein, and its total absence in Marx, Freud and Adler, struck Popper as being of fundamental importance: the pioneers of psychoanalysis, he came to think, couched their theories in terms which made them amenable only to confirmation, while Einstein’s theory, crucially, had testable implications which, if false, would have falsified the theory itself."
- claudiawerner 8y ago>he dominance of the critical spirit in Einstein, and its total absence in Marx, Freud and Adler What's ironic about this is not only that Marx and Freud inspired the entire school of critical theory today, but that Marx, Freud and Nietzche are the "big three" when it comes to the culture of suspicion and criticism. I'm not sure how Popper could claim the lack of the critical spirit in Marx when Marx's major thesis was a critique of political economy and capitalism which had not been attempted an nearly such a deep and rigorous level until Marx. Successive Marxists after Marx have been very critical of Marxism too. It makes me wonder whether Popper ever read Marx at all when he thinks like this. And for all the talk of the lack of critical spirit, it's odd that scientists dogmatically cling to the theory of falsifictaionism, even in Popper's sufficient and necessary criterion.
- dang 8y agoThe author addresses this: "It’s the crude version that most people, especially scientists, have in mind when they talk about falsificationism. I will be satisfied if all I have achieved with this post is to convince you that, at least in this crude version, falsificationism is false." It isn't a straw man if he's right that the crude version is what most people believe.
- lisper 8y ago> The author addresses this: No, he doesn't. The word "explanation" doesn't even appear in the article.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- leereeves 8y agoEven the author calls it "naive falsificationism". That's the strawman. The author is right that it's a crude version of falsificationism, but I doubt that most people believe it. I suspect most people believe the version that the author calls reasonable: first confirm the experiment and its conclusions before questioning a proven theory.
- dang 8y agoIn that case you and the author have an empirical disagreement about how many people believe which version. Given how often "naive falsificationism" shows up in internet comments, I wouldn't bet against the author. But isn't it moot anyhow? He states up front that not everyone believes this, but those who do are the ones he's writing for. That's not a straw man argument.
- leereeves 8y ago"Naive falsificationism" shows up in Internet comments from the kind of people who think vaccines cause autism or global warming is a hoax, and cling to a single isolated result as "proof". Even on the Internet they aren't a majority. If the author merely wants to argue against that kind of thinking, that's fine, but given the extensive discussion of Karl Popper and physicists, I don't think that's the author's intent.
- astazangasta 8y agoYou should come to my workplace and tell this to actual scientists, who seem to have no trouble hypothesizing things they are unable to falsify, who pick up methods because "other people are doing this", not because of some underlying epistemological criterion, and whose epistemologically broken hypotheses have no trouble getting published in top-flight journals. I also object to you saying "better explanation" without defining what that is. What makes something "better"? It's more intellectually satisfying? It feels "right"? It has a lower p-value? The ultimate subjectivity of this criterion, which is really at the root of all scientific endeavor, is why philosophy of science remains so difficult to pin down. In the end what makes up scientific knowledge is that a bunch of people we call "scientists" approve of it, and pass it on in their writing and speech. Philosophers of science are welcome to come up with theories about how science operates, but I suggest they might benefit from some anthropological approaches, because scientists are sure not reading and applying their philosophy books.
- BurningFrog 8y agoThe actual scientific establishment at any given time and place is never going to be a 100% pure implementation of scientific ideals. Some might not be doing science at all, even though it says so on the building and their business cards.
- crazydoggers 8y agoThis. And that’s always what these criticisms miss. Science’s strength is that any one individual or even groups of individuals can be bias. That bias might persist (theories of static universe, vitalism, etc etc) for a long time within the scientific community. But science is the only method that eventually will rut out the biases. It’s self correcting, but you need to look at it from the long view.
- anongraddebt 8y agoThat's generally right. However, a non-trivial number of well-educated, scientifically minded persons do not take a long enough view. A possible explanation: it is difficult for humans to care about research timelines that may or may not be longer than the average human life. Maybe it's some sociological theory X, and you think, "well, yeah, X has some kinks, but they should be worked out within the next decade or so." In reality, you should essentially have no attachment to said theory. And in reality, far too many people have attachments to one or more theories that have yet to be proved out fully, and could be proved out fully in a decade/century/etc. or worse... never proved out at all. In the case of currently 'proved out' (whatever we take that to mean) theories, a non-trivial number of persons have excessive attachment to one or more of them, since, taking a long view, said theories could be overturned or reinterpreted, etc.
- drpixie 8y agoTrue - it's a rather undergraduate article for a PhD candidate! Nothing new or interesting, just rehashing old complaints about Popper. I find his other stuff concerning ... he shows a clear history of setting up straw men and picking them apart ... generally implying that "liberals" of one flavour or another are poor mistaken fools. Just because Lemoine can pick apart a straw man, or a single statement, doesn't mean that there is no racism, nor that we should ignore climate change, nor that blatant dishonesty by politicians is a good or acceptable thing. Perhaps he's aiming for a career as a Republican stooge?
- lisper 8y agoThat's a growth industry nowadays. :-(
- SantalBlush 8y agoI've seen similar critiques of philosophy of science, and it's usually clear that the critique is just a subterfuge for validating the person's own alternative opinions.