3 ms·
This is somewhat nonsensical, though. We don't have evidence that we are preventing a decline in temperatures. We have evidence that we are seeing a rise in t
by taeric 8y ago
This is somewhat nonsensical, though. We don't have evidence that we are preventing a decline in temperatures. We have evidence that we are seeing a rise in temperatures. Those are two very different things.
So, it is not that the question is unpopular. It just doesn't make sense. You are begging the question that things could be worse under alternatives. The plight is to improve the one we are in.
- _red 8y ago>We have evidence that we are seeing a rise in temperatures For the majority of the earths history, the poles have had no ice on them. Their current existence is a holdover from our last ice-age. Wouldn't it be rational to conclude that earth's temperatures are meandering back to its natural state?
- throw0101a 8y ago> Wouldn't it be rational to conclude that earth's temperatures are meandering back to its natural state? Perhaps, but it is a strange coïncidence then that they've been going up since the Industrial Revolution, which also happens to be when humans started releasing a whole bunch of carbon (a greenhouse gas) into the atmosphere. It took a while for us to develop the science of climatology and then start noticing natural climatic cycles as well as then noticing anthropomorphic climate change (ACC): * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_change#Terminology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_change#Terminology Natural cyclic oscillations are known and have been taken into account: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pacific_decadal_oscillation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pacific_decadal_oscillation * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlantic_multidecadal_oscillation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlantic_multidecadal_oscillat... The possibility of being wrong is there, but here's the thing: if we're wrong about ACC being real, then the worse that will happen is that we move towards more efficient and renewal infrastructure (which isn't a bad thing in itself). If we're right about ACC being real, and do something about it, then we (may) save human civilization. There's not much long-term downside to assuming ACC is real and doing something about it.
- _red 8y ago>then the worse that will happen But that's not the "worse that will happen". Go tell a starving 3rd world family that their $300 per month salary will now only buy $200 because you decided its a "risk worth taking".
- Gibbon1 8y agoYour of course proposing the orthodox neo-liberal do nothing solution. The worst that will happen in that case is your 3rd world family starves to death.
- throw0101a 8y agoThe carbon use of a family making $300/month is minimal and I would hazard to guess any carbon pricing/capping scheme would effect them minimally. * https://www.mcc-berlin.net/en/news/information/information-detail/article/climate-policy-reduces-inequality-in-lower-income-countries.html https://www.mcc-berlin.net/en/news/information/information-d... * http://www.anthropocenemagazine.org/2018/07/how-a-carbon-tax-could-fight-poverty-and-climate-change-at-the-same-time/ http://www.anthropocenemagazine.org/2018/07/how-a-carbon-tax...
- mempko 8y agoCanada just passed a carbon tax where they take the proceeds and then distribute them to everyone. The lowest income earners are actually getting MORE back from the rebates than what they spend on the tax. So yes, it's possible to not only tax carbon, but do it in such a way that it will help lower-income people.
- taeric 8y agoFor the majority of the universe's existence, the Earth didn't. Not exactly a helpful data analysis. So, no. It isn't rational. It is, at best, distractions. And, honestly, folks that peddle these sorts of arguments don't exactly have a history of good faith debates.