2 ms·
>It's patently wrong to suggest that unequivocal positions are inherently toxic. I'm reading your comment and kinda wondering what it has to do with my comment
by BeetleB 8y ago
>It's patently wrong to suggest that unequivocal positions are inherently toxic.
I'm reading your comment and kinda wondering what it has to do with my comment that you're replying to. I never suggested such a thing.
>There are innumerable situations wherein there is legitimate experience and authority for people to make fairly clear and unambiguous decisions.
I'm not disputing that. The context of my comment is the discussion around it. My question is: If that is the case, does there need to be any discussion around it at all? Just make the decision. It kind of gets to the point of the article. If it's unambiguous and you're sure about the decision, you can present it that way and close any room for disagreement. If you actually want people to express disagreement, then it means you are willing to consider your analysis of ambiguity would be wrong.
My counter would be:
There are innumerable situations where people's belief that the situation allows for clear and unambiguous decisions is wrong.
I'm not saying your scenarios don't exist. I'm arguing about Type I vs Type II errors.