3 ms·
I suspect "strong opinions, loosely held" used to be very common in hacker culture (although personally I've never actually heard the phrase used before this ot
by mistermann 8y ago
I suspect "strong opinions, loosely held" used to be very common in hacker culture (although personally I've never actually heard the phrase used before this other than Jeff Atwood: https://blog.codinghorror.com/strong-opinions-weakly-held/ https://blog.codinghorror.com/strong-opinions-weakly-held/), but as time marched on and the makeup of people working in technology (and people on the internet in general) changed, the younger generations increasingly only saw the "strong opinions" part, and now that's mostly all we have left.
My perception is that open-mindedness and nuance in discussions have been steadily decreasing, replaced with hyper-confidence and binary thinking, and the rate of that decrease is accelerating. I wonder if anyone other than me has noticed this change in the nature of forum discussions (here and elsewhere?
> Even if someone does have the courage to push back, in practice the original speaker isn’t likely to be holding their opinion as loosely as they think.
"isn't likely" is a massive understatement in my personal experience, not only when the topic of discussion is technology, but even more so when the topic is politics.
> So, what about the situation where someone else goes first and makes an absolute statement? There is a simple ninja move! Just say “It sounds like you are 100% sure of that, is that right?” If the answer is yes, you can ask them to explain why they are certain and see if they have any data to back it up....
This does seem like quite the ninja move, I like it.
> ...If not, you’ll have prompted them to assess their actual level of conviction, sharpen their thinking, and open up the conversation. It is a simple, kind way of helping them develop a style of thinking and communication that will improve your organization.
I am very curious if this ninja move will indeed be received/interpreted in the real world as a "simple, kind way of helping them develop a style of thinking and communication that will improve your organization." I predict (80% certainty) that kind of reception will be quite rare (<50%).
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoA while back I was reading a memoir by someone who consulted for DEC in the 70s and 80s, and he was astounded that engineering meetings were sometimes full of people shouting at each other. Apparently this was considered a normal way to find consensus. So - things may not have changed as much as you say. (See also Usenet in the 90s.) What has changed is YouTube culture, which seems to have a scary number of people SHOUTING and EMOTING in VERY EXTROVERT WAYS DIRECT TO CAMERA with plenty of FAST CUTS and ASIDES, even when making videos about technical content. Sometimes it's entertaining, but just as often it's tiresome and distracting. I wouldn't object if it was toned down.
- mistermann 8y ago> and he was astounded that engineering meetings were sometimes full of people shouting at each other. I'd bet (there's no way of really knowing obviously) that back then, that worked perfectly fine because those people for the most part actually held their opinions loosely. Oh, they wouldn't give them up without a fight, but what was Correct trumped personal opinion. I don't think there's very much left of this in modern culture, even among those who think they behave this way, at least on certain topics. Distinguishing between reality and one's perception of reality does not come naturally.