5 ms·
Delta anti-union poster: Spend on video games over union dues
- chrisseaton 8y ago> Crosses One Line Too Far in Union Busting With posters giving their point of view? I was expecting to read about them calling in strike breakers with baseball bats, given that headline. Surely posting literature that isn’t untruthful, offensive, abusive etc is always ok and should be protected even if you don’t agree with the argument?
- otikik 8y agoAn example of the poster can be found here: https://twitter.com/EoinHiggins_/status/1126477710434414592/photo/1 https://twitter.com/EoinHiggins_/status/1126477710434414592/... A lot of people are finding it offensive.
- dpark 8y agoLame? Sure. Offensive? No. "Offensive" shouldn't be a synonym for "something I don't like".
- ajkjk 8y ago'Repulsive' is perhaps the better choice here.
- dpark 8y agoThat is a much more appropriate word.
- rhizome 8y agoMaybe consider "offensive" under its "aggressive" definition. It's a plainly worded discouragement from participating in unionization.
- sverige 8y agoI don't see any aggression. What is "aggressive" about pointing out that for the cost of paying a union boss to negotiate for you, you could buy a video game system instead? Maybe more to the point, what's wrong with a company discouraging employees from participating in a union? It's against the company's interests. They have a right to try to persuade their employees with posters, just as the union has a right to promote their position with their own propaganda.
- luckydata 8y agoOh wow, who would ever infer that there might be consequences for doing something the company you work for hates so much they bothered making flyers against? Nobody in their right mind would think that's the first of many, many hints for people that can't catch the drift.
- gowld 8y agoFrankly it's none of their business, just as the company shouldn't lobby their employees on who to vote for. > It's against the company's interests. The fact that it's a baseline assumption that a company's interests is opposed to the interests of the employees who create the company's value is exactly why employees and their unions need political protection.
- sverige 8y agoIt's definitely the company's business, since unions add another layer of management to their business processes. And these days it's generally assumed that a union is opposed to the company's interests because unions by definition are there to extract money from both the company and its employees.
- hannasanarion 8y agoUnions are nonprofit, they don't exist to "extract money" from anybody. They exist to act on the behalf of all their members in negotiations, to increase wages and to provide employment-related services like labor lawyers in case of a wrongful firing. In the airline industry, Union workers make on average $12k more than non-union workers, which more than makes up for the $700 dues.
- iancmceachern 8y agoI would say its insulting to their intelligence at the very least. If I had an extra sum of money the last thing on my mind would be games. Its insulting and demeaning to assume such. Why not assume that extra money would be going to medical bills, housing, etc.
- leftyted 8y ago> If I had an extra sum of money the last thing on my mind would be games Bully for you.
- praneshp 8y ago> that extra money would be going to medical bills, housing, e Because they assume that you are smart, and the $700 is after those bills.
- cannonedhamster 8y agoIf you're working for an airline you're probably not rolling in dough. They don't typically all make what people in software make, so it's not a given that all those bills are paid in the first place.
- rdiddly 8y agohttps://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/offensive https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/offensive "causing displeasure or resentment"
- dmix 8y agoIt's the internet, people find everything offensive these days.
- AsyncAwait 8y agoAnd people find complaining about how people find everything so offensive these days somehow edgy, your point? Perhaps their meant it as 'in poor taste' or the like.
- dmix 8y agoThis is long past edgy, it'd be unoriginal if a comedian said it. It's pretty much a standard part of our culture now thanks to social media. Much like the concept of slacktivism which is closely related (when the bar drops so low for being an 'activist' for something, then everything has activists).
- AsyncAwait 8y agoEdgy was perhaps the wrong word, but 'keeping it real', while being blind to their own echo chamber being guilty of the same, (taking offense, looking for safe spaces, accusations of bigotry...).
- manigandham 8y agoWhat someone finds offensive is entirely subjective.
- otikik 8y agoMy comment was an answer to > Surely posting literature that isn’t untruthful, -->offensive<--, abusive etc
- rdiddly 8y agoWell, more thoroughly stated, it's one line too far, for him to continue to fly Delta. Maybe a bit dramatic as headlines go, especially since he can react only to things he actually hears about. (They may have crossed his "line" long ago, but it didn't make it onto Twitter etc.) I'm not up to speed on what's "protected" anymore; people seem to care more about being protected from speech nowadays rather than protecting the speech itself. So I'm setting all that aside. But the poster that seems to have started the shitstorm (https://twitter.com/EoinHiggins_/status/1126477710434414592 https://twitter.com/EoinHiggins_/status/1126477710434414592) is indeed untruthful. They're concealing their true and real argument/position/reason for why they don't want a union (namely that they'll have to transfer wealth to workers) and using a disingenuous one (namely that they want you to have a game system). Incidentally, one of the reasons it fails is because, as one of the many replies to that tweet said, it's trying to bribe you with your own money.
- chrisseaton 8y agoI think the poster’s argument is the the Delta union does not deliver $700 of value to its members, so spend the money on something you value more instead. I don’t know if that’s true as I don’t know their numbers but it seems to me to be a perfectly reasonable, adult, honest opinion to present to people.
- rdiddly 8y agoSpeaking of honest, now nobody knows WTF I'm talking about because you swapped-in a different article link.
- chrisseaton 8y ago> you swapped-in a different article link I did? I don’t run HN and I didn’t post the original link and have no power to have changed someone else’s submission! I didn’t do it and I’m not dishonest.
- rdiddly 8y ago
- draw_down 8y agoIt's a scummy move, but hardly surprising. I don't know if I'd consider it crossing a line, so much as revealing the contempt management have for workers
- rayiner 8y agoWherever you stand in the union issue, you have to take exception with the dishonest reporting about Delta’s profitability. Airlines are enjoying profits recently because of low fuel prices over the last five years. But nobody mentions that Delta went through bankruptcy in 2007. Airlines aren’t a long-term profitable business that can support inflexible union arrangements. A spike in fuel prices can quickly put them in the red.
- vageli 8y ago> Wherever you stand in the union issue, you have to take exception with the dishonest reporting about Delta’s profitability. Airlines are enjoying profits recently because of low fuel prices over the last five years. But nobody mentions that Delta went through bankruptcy in 2007. Airlines aren’t a long-term profitable business that can support inflexible union arrangements. A spike in fuel prices can quickly put them in the red. Airlines don't hedge against increases in fuel price by engaging in futures markets? That sounds borderline irresponsible of management.
- dboreham 8y agoThey probably do hedge but hedging also costs money and at some point becomes uneconomical due to lack of time machines and so on.
- TomVDB 8y agoI'm pretty sure airlines do hedge against increases. But that only delays things if prices go up permanently.
- function_seven 8y agoThat's another way to quickly go into the red. You purchase futures contracts to hold your fuel prices steady, then the market turns and fuel gets really cheap. Your competitors can now start a fare war and you're locked into expensive fuel while they enjoy cheap fuel. When you make a bet on the future price of a commodity, that bet may work well for you (see Southwest during the late 2000s [1]). But it just as easily can hurt you if the prices move the other way. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2007/11/28/business/worldbusiness/28iht-hedge.4.8517580.html https://www.nytimes.com/2007/11/28/business/worldbusiness/28...
- segmondy 8y agoGive me a break, some people are pro union, companies are not. pro union folks campaign to get folks to join, companies campaign to stop that. Delta didn't say anything along the line of if you join you will loose your job or some subtle threat. They said spending $700 on video game sounds more fun than union dues. I personally think it's funny. If anyone is going to be swayed by that, then that person probably shouldn't join a union or can just as easily be swayed by a union with something silly and more catchy than Delta's campaign.
- axiom92 8y agoMakes a lot of sense. I don't understand why you're being downvoted.
- thesagan 8y agoPeople shouldn't be swayed by that, and in my opinion, Delta shouldn't put it out there, either. Delta is in a much stronger position than most of its employees. The fact Delta makes an appeal on that level is disappointing to me. There's a common sentiment that fools should be taken as such. I don't subscribe to it, for the most part. I think that's brutish business.
- ryandrake 8y agoNot that it excuses Delta's terrible behavior but other companies also put out anti-union propaganda [1] [2] [3] and it's also terrible behavior. 1: https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/06/how-walmart-convinces-its-employees-not-to-unionize/395051/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/06/how-wal... 2: https://www.forbes.com/sites/janetwburns/2018/09/27/amazons-anti-union-training-strategy-revealed-in-leaked-video/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/janetwburns/2018/09/27/amazons-... 3: https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/target-anti-union-video-cheesy-but-effective https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/target-anti...
- gowld 8y agoSelling out a citizen's responsibility to engage in government in exchange for a bit of cash has a sordid history. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_machine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_machine
- newsoul2019 8y agoA really good idea is take the $700, buy a Chromebook, learn JavaScript, and stop working for Delta! As a flier though, I am a fan of Delta.
- everdev 8y agoHonestly, I'd rather fly with an airline where the mechanics aren't unionized. I don't want someone to have a poor team attitude and not care about what they're doing because they know they can't get fired for less than 3 infractions or whatever else the union negotiates. I want underperforming mechanics out ASAP and the best ones rewarded.
- otikik 8y agoWell I want people who are thinking about the problem they have in front of them, not about whether they can afford taking Sally to the doctor to have that weird lump on her shoulder checked.
- sparky_z 8y ago> I want underperforming mechanics out ASAP and the best ones rewarded. That would be nice. I think it's more likely that it would be the mechanics that don't make waves and keep costs down who would be rewarded. Woe betide the mechanic who insists on delaying a flight and costing the airline large amounts of money to investigate a possible issue that might result in a 0.01% chance of a crash, rather than delaying it to a more convenient time.
- everdev 8y agoSure, that would be nice. Maybe I'm just not familiar with unions, but what are some examples of high performing / high quality companies with a unionized workforce? My only experience is friends who have worked in unions and their stories make it sound like there's little to no chance for advancement besides waiting in line, so at best people skate by and do the bare minimum and at worst actively try to subvert management decisions.
- cannonedhamster 8y agoPlumbers, electricians, lots of other sole proprietor workforces in the trades have unions that institute strong training and protection for their union work. Is it perfect, nope. I can't stand police unions in my state because they prevent perfectly reasonable road crews from functioning with only flag crews instead of with flag crews and a usually sleeping officer just to pad their wages. There's some crappy things about unions but it's the only effective way to protect individuals from companies. They don't however protect companies from outsourcing, usually to lower paid non union workers of lower quality.
- bargl 8y agoI'm pretty pro union myself. However, I think it makes sense for people to NEED the union. If they don't need it they shouldn't join it. Defaulting into something is how you get stagnation. You should think about whether or not $700 would be better than the union. If you get rid of the Union and then your pay goes to shit, then Unionize again and demand higher pay. We should make Unions as fluid as possible so that not only companies but unions feel the pressure of their membership numbers. EDIT: Yes, I know this ignores the startup cost of forming a union and the pressure by companies to form unions. But I think that points out a flaw in our current legal system not a deficit in my (overly) optimistic idea of how easy it should be to form and end a union. My goal is competition in unions, not to start and stop them every time they lose favor. Starting and stopping them may not be realistic ever, but it'd be nice if we had options.
- gowld 8y agoYou're ignoring the huge transaction costs (and employer criminal behavior) involved in starting up a union. You are right that unions need accountability to their members, but dissolving the union is not the way. We don't dismantle the national government every time the government solves a problem.
- bargl 8y agoVery good point, I'm not saying I want to dismantle all unions and create them again. But I would like more competition with unions, currently there isn't much of that. Well I might have said that in my comment but it wasn't my intent and reading your comment made that more clear to me.
- engineeringwoke 8y agoI'm not sure what happened but this website versus two years ago is filled with shills. Posting on twitter that your employees should buy an Xbox instead of join the union is fucked up
- chrisseaton 8y ago
- mevile 8y agoDelta is the only big American airline, that I know of, that doesn't own any Boeing 737 Max aircraft. I don't know when these planes will go into the air again but I assume they will. Based on the reporting of the problem with Boeing and these planes I don't feel like I want to fly in that plane and I don't want to play ticket games to try and avoid a particular type of plane. I know lots of people have good reasons for being angry at Delta, but for me just the fact that they don't have this particular plane and thus I'd never have to worry about ending up on one of them makes me likely to continue using Delta. Is this irrational of me?
- toolz 8y agoIrrational? Not at all. Delta can be reasonably well priced and you're avoiding a known risk that hopefully is fixed. If you're paying substantially more for Delta to avoid that plane while also not having the income to support that luxury it might then be irrational.
- dang 8y agoUrl changed from http://ebb.org/bkuhn/blog/2019/05/10/delta-union-busting.html http://ebb.org/bkuhn/blog/2019/05/10/delta-union-busting.htm..., which points to this.
- caymanjim 8y agoThe naivete of people in situations like this drives me nuts. This person discovered that a company they frequent has done something that offends their sensibilities. Now they going to Do Something About It! And we should all join them! This aggression cannot stand! This is arbitrary offense-taking. I'm not taking a stand on whether or not Delta has done something egregious. I don't care about the underlying issue. What I can't stand is people who become aware of something like this and act like they've uncovered a crime against humanity that we're all ignoring. I guarantee that the author wrote that blog post while wearing clothes manufactured in a sweatshop, on an electronic device manufactured in many sweatshops, with a stomach full of food picked by disadvantaged illegal immigrants, after driving home from work in a vehicle powered by oil from an unsavory country. They're proud of the million miles they've flown, with a carbon footprint that's big enough to sink a continent. To be fair, the author acknowledges much of this in the post, which makes it all the more inane. This one company crossed some arbitrary ethical line in the sand, and the author wants everyone else to jump on board. The world is a messy place full of suffering and wrongness. By all means, pick the occasional battle and take a stand once in a while, if that's your thing. I'll find something better to get bent out of shape about.
- anigbrowl 8y agoDid you skip over the bit where he mentioned his experience as a CEO whose workforce unionized during his tenure?
- caymanjim 8y agoAnd now the link to the article I was commenting on has been swapped out and replaced with a Washington Post article. I don't know who did that, but it completely removes the context.
- norgie 8y agoVery true, we should never criticize anything bad because we can't criticize everything bad. We do live in a society after all.
- bkuhn 8y ago
- rdiddly 8y agoFlagged for changing the link from http://ebb.org/bkuhn/blog/2019/05/10/delta-union-busting.html http://ebb.org/bkuhn/blog/2019/05/10/delta-union-busting.htm... to https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2019/05/10/delta-told-workers-save-up-football-beer-video-games-instead-union-it-didnt-go-well https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2019/05/10/delta-tol... circa 5pm Fri 5/10/19. PSA to all confused readers reading comments posted before that time. Moderators, if this isn't against policy, it ought to be.
- purplezooey 8y agoSomeday unions will be back. Until then, keep listening to what your Sinclair station tells you.