3 ms·
There are lots of comments to this effect in the NYTimes article, but large swaths of the population already have their salary data public: many (most?) public
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
There are lots of comments to this effect in the NYTimes article, but large swaths of the population already have their salary data public: many (most?) public sector workers' salary is public knowledge, oftentimes searchable on a website, military pay grades are public, highly paid executives report most of their compensation in SEC docs, etc.
Thus, I don't really buy the myriad of reasons presented here for why this is such a bad idea.
- ip26 8y agoPerhaps the strongest argument against is basically that if you're the only one telling, you are at a disadvantage. It's a prisoner's dilemma. By comparison, in the public sector & military, everyone's is public, and on top of that there is no salary negotiation.
- azhenley 8y agoIt isn’t true that all public sector salaries are nonnegotiable. State university salaries are public and negotiable.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> By comparison, in the public sector & military, everyone's is public, and on top of that there is no salary negotiation. There is some salary negotiation in the public sector, especially at the executive level; now, even those positions that are negotiable may often (but not always) have narrower constraints than a private employer would have in practice, but not all positions in public service have strict salary bands with objective rules for placement within the bands.
- astura 8y ago... there is salary negotiation in the public sector ... And even if every pay grade was fixed, a salary negotiation can take the form of "I deserve to be moved to a higher pay grade because XYZ." People don't get promoted on a fixed schedule.