4 ms·
"As long as they don't break into other people's computers, launching DDoS should not be treated as a crime by default; " Yeah, they should. Those attacks are
by wccrawford 16y ago
"As long as they don't break into other people's computers, launching DDoS should not be treated as a crime by default; "
Yeah, they should. Those attacks are the same as vandalism. They destroy some things that are hard to quantify, such as trust and image, as well as cost the companies money to attempt to mitigate the issue.
- andrewgodwin 16y agoNot only that, a DDoS can cost quite a bit in extra bandwidth costs (I've had a couple of small ones chew through a suprising amount). It's a bit more of a substantial repercussion in addition to hitting "brand", and often affects smaller companies proportionally more.
- Retric 16y agoThere is probably a reasonable separation between automated DDoS attacks and manual ones. If I convince 50 million people to click on CNN once at 3:17PM on a Tuesday then that's a reasonable form of protest IMO. If I rent a botnet for 24 hours and try and exploit some hole in your infrastructure then that's vandalism. From a monetary standpoint they might cause the same amount of harm, but from a social standpoint a manual attack is a much harder target.
- TheAmazingIdiot 16y agoI say that the rulings and ideas here are... Backward. I've seen a few times a website owner who asked that slashdot submissions be linked to a static page because of php content. Instead, slashdot posts directly to a php link, causing cpu, memory to go through the roof along with flooding the net channel empying quota. And he was powerless to stop it, because he couldn't even ssh into the machine. We techies all know about the slashdot effect. How's it so much different, aside a tool called LOIC vs firefox and f5? Guess it does go down to intent?
- Nick_C 16y ago> Guess it does go down to intent? Yes. If I put my hand on your shoulder, it could be friendly companionship or it could be assault. The physical action is the same; context is everything. One thing about engineers I'm sure we all notice is we tend to think in terms of logical analysis: true or false, black or white. Real life is full of grey.
- onedognight 16y ago> Those attacks are the same as vandalism. An analogy for you: What if all your (Anonymous) friends went to Wal-Mart and stood in line to buy something. Then when they got to the front they would fumble around in their pockets and say, "oh darn, I forgot my wallet", then they'd got out and come back in and do it again? Would that be vandalism? Would it cost Wal-Mart money? Would Wal-Mart have to spend time dealing with the problem? Would it be illegal? Should it be? What if these anonymous strangers stood just stood outside and held up signs? Wouldn't the company hire someone to deal with them? Wouldn't that cost them money?
- patio11 16y agoThat is, indeed, illegal. In Japan, the crime is Disruption of Business (rough translation). In the US, as soon as the clerk wises up and tells you to leave, you're trespassing. It is also probably public nuisance and disturbance of the peace, and an enterprising DA could probably indict you for larceny. But there's two or more of them doing it, with the intention of harassment. Ho ho ho, bad idea. Now we're up to conspiracy to commit racketeering. Tech people seem to think that the law is a finite state machine, which has no memory and so cannot parse a crime out of a series of legal actions. Tech people are foolish about a lot of things.
- wladimir 16y agoStop generalizing. All people are foolish in a lot of things. One can't know everything.
- pigbucket 16y ago>All people are foolish in a lot of things. >Stop generalizing. I'm not saying anything. I'm just quoting.
- tptacek 16y agoConcert pianists are foolish about hamster care. They will chew right the hell through a cardboard toilet paper tube! what are you thinking, stupid pianist! Audio engineers are foolish about contract law. It's called an implied-in-fact contract! IMPLIED IN FACT! It doesn't need to be spelled out in ink! Why do you always make this mistake, audio engineers? Sanitation workers are foolish about bespoke tailoring. Functioning sleeve buttons don't work on off-the-rack clothes! You can't position the buttonholes until you've altered the jacket! Stop putting functioning sleeve buttons on those jacket and get back to collecting trash! See, there, I can name three. What is your point? He didn't say tech people are simply foolish; he said they're foolish about a lot of things, and he's right, and you literally agreed with him the very sentence after you told him to stop. Tech people sure are thin skinned. Way, way more thin skinned than audio engineers and san workers.
- radu_floricica 16y agoI don't think you should qualify them based on either intention or consequences. Sit-ins and other civilized protest tools have both disruptive intentions and consequences. I also think they are much closer to vandalism, but this is because of the technology of the act. If me and a couple of friends decide to hang around the entrance of a public institution and politely tell everybody who passes our opinion, that's civic protest. If we use any kind of tool to block the entrance door, no matter how briefly or cleanly, it's a crime. Same with DOSes. There is a threshold which once passed makes the whole thing a crime. 100.000 people visiting a site? Civic protest. 100.000 clicking F5? Most likely civic protest. 1000 people using specialized tools which are designed to go over DoS filters? I dare say it's much easier to make the case that this is a crime.
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoAgreed. Look at the issue from somebody not versed in what has happened: because company X chose not to do business with somebody hackers love, hackers are shutting down company X on the internet. That doesn't sound much like a sit-in. A sit-in doesn't involve botnets and thousands of people randomly dispersed around the globe. Be nice if it were more like a sit-in, though. But there's just no room between "doing nothing" and "disrupting my business and my cash flow" -- at least none we seem to have found by now. The author makes a great point that while there is all this nuance and distinction among people inside the story, for the vast majority of the apathetic this story, like all other ones, is going to be drawn like a comic-book, with good guys and bad guys. Time to wake up and figure out which box you're getting stuck into.