3 ms·
> Dear ImGui > Cons > nothing jumps out to me Why the fuck am I reading this article? I could easily write "nothing jumps out to me" or list a bunch of first
by klodolph 8y ago
> Dear ImGui
> Cons
> nothing jumps out to me
Why the fuck am I reading this article? I could easily write "nothing jumps out to me" or list a bunch of first-impressions of GUI libraries. But I can tell you off-hand a list of cons for Dear ImGui, and if you're interested there are plenty of Qt -vs- ImGui comparisons out there based on people who have actually switched and done a writeup. (Various people fall on both sides of this debate.)
https://deplinenoise.wordpress.com/2017/03/05/why-qt-and-not-imgui/ https://deplinenoise.wordpress.com/2017/03/05/why-qt-and-not...
https://gist.github.com/bkaradzic/853fd21a15542e0ec96f7268150f1b62 https://gist.github.com/bkaradzic/853fd21a15542e0ec96f726815...
There are definitely use cases out there where Dear ImGui is a clear winner over Qt, and vice versa, and if you're going to compare GUI frameworks I would expect to want to know more about them.
I have a big ole' bag of Google Docs that contain comparisons like this, but I sure as hell ain't gonna share them because they're full of subjective declarations and I stop evaluating an option as soon as I've figured out it doesn't meet my needs.
- felixguendling 8y agoI consent with you that many pros and cons are rather subjective and pros/cons depend on the specific use case. On the other hand, I like having a list of all these libraries with their supported platforms, license and a screenshot. This alone gives a pretty good overview of what's there. Not all pros/cons are subjective (e.g. having a GUI wysiwyg editor is definitely a pro for some use cases). Anyway, thanks for sharing your view and thanks for sharing this comprehensive overview.
- klodolph 8y agoYes it is useful to have a list of everything, but I feel like I can get a list like this in about a half hour with Google. What I can't get in a half hour is a summary of the problems people have had with particular framework, or the reasons why they chose to start using or stop using a particular framework. The picture from the beginning is very exciting and optimistic. To pick on ImGui again, it's easy to get started--but I know there are some issues with larger projects, some things that are hard to do in immediate mode, etc.
- seba_dos1 8y agoEven the list of platforms is kinda pointless here, as Dear ImGui doesn't really support any platform itself. You're expected to write a glue yourself, with some examples for popular libraries/frameworks/engines being provided for your convenience (and those examples alone already go further than just four platforms listed in the article). On the other hand, Qt is a whole framework itself which already handles all this stuff for you, which makes a lot of stuff easier, but then you're of course limited to what's supported by Qt.
- seba_dos1 8y agoAgreed. I use Dear ImGui, I like it, but it's certainly not a general purpose tool which you can replace Qt with (or vice versa). It's a completely different project made for different use cases, and "nothing jumps out to me" in the list of cons sounds a lot like "I just started using it and I love it".