3 ms·
Hmm, I've never heard anyone else object to mid-function returns. Usually guard clauses are considered a good thing. What's your objection to them?
by skybrian 8y ago
Hmm, I've never heard anyone else object to mid-function returns. Usually guard clauses are considered a good thing. What's your objection to them?
- jayd16 8y agoLike GOTO it makes the execution harder to reason about as you could easily miss it. It doesn't bother me personally but I can sort of see an argument for it.
- icholy 8y agoAvoiding early returns usually makes code harder to read. It's outdated advice which was meant for writing assembly.
- apta 8y agoIt's not outdated, it depends on context. Several modern languages, including Rust, Swift, Scala, Kotlin, and F# are built around having expressions as constructs (if, match, try, etc. are all expressions). Once you have that powerful feature it makes sense to write code in a certain way to make use of that, and it ends up being clearer a lot of the time.
- jeswin 8y agoI'm increasingly used to everything (including entire function bodies) being expressions. It's very much a personal preference though.