4 ms·
This article reinforces my suspicion that the British, even the ones who supported the Remain vote in the referendum, simply have no idea what the EU is about.
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
This article reinforces my suspicion that the British, even the ones who
supported the Remain vote in the referendum, simply have no idea what the EU
is about. For the author, for example, it is a matter of "identity". For the
Remain campaign, the argument was that Brexit would be bad for business and
industry.
The British can just not comprehend the need for a united Europe in the modern
world, where European countries are beset on all sides by many times more
powerful rivals (Russia, China and now even the US is turning against us). To
think that the little nation-states of Europe can survive and prosper on their
own like they did back in the days of Napoleon and Queen Victoria ignores
reality for the warm fuzzy feeling of epic fantasy.
The EU's goal is to promote peace an the well-being of its people (Treaty of
the European Union, article 3, par. 1). The British either ignore this, or, if
they know it, they don't believe it. Therefore, the public conversation about
the EU revolves either around irrelevancies, like bendy bananas and fast-track
airport lanes, or around issues that most people cannot really connnect with,
like the benefits to industry (as if there is anyone left in the UK who
believes that what is good for industry is good for everyone).
No wonder the Leave side carried the referendum vote. Their message was simple
and to the point: "us versus them" (all of them - the EU, those krauts and
frogs and those PIGS countires, Poles, Romanians... everyone). You cannot
argue against nationalistic slogans and battle buses with "Brexit is bad for
business". Nor with "I want my kids to be able to travel to the EU cheaply and
without a visa". A powerful message is needed and it needs to make it clear to
everyone what awaits us if we divide up and withdraw each in our little
borders.
But, nobody has done that for the British- so, it's all identity, bendy
bananas and travel privileges.
- tim333 8y ago>To think that the little nation-states of Europe can survive and prosper on their own... fantasy... I'm a remainer but I think little nation states that are non EU like Switzerland or Singapore survive and prosper quite well. I admit I don't know that much about the EU - I think of it mostly as an admin for free trade and travel between the countries mostly. Which I quite like. One of the troubles with the 2016 leave/remain referendum was remain is clear enough but no one really knew what leave would consist of. When you clarify it none of the options are very popular for instance the polls on remain/May's deal are about 60:40 to remain. Even remain/no deal polls about 56-44 towards remain so to leave politicians will have to force it through against the wishes of the majority of the people and of their parliament. Which is kind of a mess.
- rayiner 8y ago> I admit I don't know that much about the EU - I think of it mostly as an admin for free trade and travel between the countries mostly. Which I quite like. That has not been true since the Lisbon treaty. Now, it’s an EU-wide government supreme over the EU national governments. In key respects, the EU is even more powerful compared to the EU national governments than the US federal government is compared to the US state governments. For example, the federal government cannot pass laws then force the state governments to enforce them. The EU can. If the EU stayed on its pre-Brexit track, all the stuff that renders US politics intractable would be coming to the EU faster than anyone would think. You’re already seeing it—for example, with Sweden and Finland having to strengthen gun control to accommodate the sensibilities of the rest of Europe.
- mnky9800n 8y agoThe us federal government via Congress can certainly pass laws that supersede state laws. That's the purpose of the 9th amendment and the commerce Clause in the us Constitution.
- rayiner 8y agoUnder the Supremacy Clause, the federal government can pass laws that preempt state laws. What it cannot do is coerce states into enforcing federal laws. (That's the whole premise behind sanctuary cities--states cannot be compelled to enforce federal immigration laws.) The EU can do both--it can pass laws that override national laws, and it can enforce member states to enforce EU laws, or to pass national laws to comply with EU directives.
- jeff_tyrrill 8y ago> The us federal government via Congress can certainly pass laws that supersede state laws But it cannot force the states, specifically, to enforce them. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tenth_Amendment_to_the_United_States_Constitution#Commandeering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tenth_Amendment_to_the_United_...
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
- mindcrash 8y ago> This article reinforces my suspicion that the British, even the ones who supported the Remain vote in the referendum, simply have no idea what the EU is about. Erhm, no. Some might consider those who supported Brexit "idiots" but most of them have a pretty good idea what the EU is about. (Which, by the way, is Elitarian empire building -- like for instance the United States) > The British can just not comprehend the need for a united Europe in the modern world, where European countries are beset on all sides by many times more powerful rivals > (Russia, China and now even the US is turning against us). "Big bad US" and "big bad Russia" is what Brussels and the media wants you to think. People living in constant fear are much easier to control. Putin needs the rest of the world a lot more than the rest of the world needs Putin. Without the sale of oil and gas Russia is pretty much done. Also the EU can be glad that the US is still more or less an ally because our armies are FUBAR. If China, whom by the way is indeed one of the biggest threats of the West right now but seriously overlooked by Brussels, would go offensive we have pretty much nothing to defend us with. This also makes the point of having a EU at all null and void, by the way. > To think that the little nation-states of Europe can survive and prosper on their own like they did back in the days of Napoleon and Queen Victoria ignores reality for the warm fuzzy feeling of epic fantasy. There were no "little nation states" in the time of Napoleon. He conquered pretty much the whole continent of Europe, tried to invade Russia (big mistake) and finally met his Waterloo at Waterloo. Seems you don't know a lot about European history to begin with... > The EU's goal is to promote peace an the well-being of its people (Treaty of the European Union, article 3, par. 1). I'm getting a vibe you never read Orwell or never really understood what he was trying to say. > Therefore, the public conversation about the EU revolves either around irrelevancies Yeah, let's never mention the irrelevant facts that the EU is lead by a public drunk, and as such even a bigger disgrace than Trump, and most of the officials signing in to get the money that comes with it and then return home (There's video evidence of this, and yes it pissed officials off to no end that they got caught on tape doing this). > Their message was simple and to the point: "us versus them" Bullshit. Their message was simply: "We want our fucking country and our own destiny back" > so, it's all identity, bendy bananas and travel privileges. And the God given right to choose your own destiny as a free people. QED.