54 ms·
Anyone getting off the plane with a carry-on should be charged with negligent homicide or similar. 55 seconds vs 45 vs 35 could be the different between 40 dead
by arcticbull 8y ago
Anyone getting off the plane with a carry-on should be charged with negligent homicide or similar. 55 seconds vs 45 vs 35 could be the different between 40 dead and 42 or 44. One life matters, your laptop does not. Only one of these things can be restored from iCloud. Leave. Your. Bags. On. The. Plane. This apologism has to stop. Other than that very little you said is disrupted by the author — they themselves point out it’d be very unlikely the fire started in the air. They are a pilot after all.
To your own point anyone who stops and grabs carry-on from the overhead bins while the cabin is filling with smoke and anyone past row 12 is passed out is criminally stupid. I don’t care if it took 55 seconds or 12, it’s not okay.
How thrilled would you be if your grandmother died because someone couldn’t leave their laptop aboard?
- neuronic 8y agoShould they? There is evidence in psychology studies about human reaction to catastrophes such as this. People often default to habitual behavior, possibly because active decision making may be "disabled" as responsible regions of the brain get overwhelmed. It reaches an extent where people are entirely incapable of unbuckling their seatbelts because a more common and therefore default mechanism for unbuckling is the one you would use in your car. And that works entirely different from the ones in planes. https://consumerist.com/2016/07/12/why-are-there-seatbelt-demos-on-airplanes/ https://consumerist.com/2016/07/12/why-are-there-seatbelt-de...
- FabHK 8y agoYeah, they should be charged. The psychological studies you cite could then be entered by the defence and taken into account by the judge.
- evilolive 8y agoI'm reading this comment and I'm thinking : you're absolutely right, they should be! Yet. I have been in plane on fire and I did grab my backpack.. I didn't really act consciously, and somehow I had rationalized the order "everyone, get out now!" as some kind of random evacuation exercises. (European in my teens back then and one of my first flights)
- Xcelerate 8y ago> Yet. I have been in plane on fire Commercial? What happened?
- UnFleshedOne 8y agoBut maybe a few public court cases (even if everybody was acquitted in the end) would cause some people to remember not to grab the bags in the next accident. Maybe instead of pointless court cases, lots of publicity about correct behavior for the same effect.
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>Should they? Probably not for the reasons you mentioned. That doesn't mean it's not a damn good thing to say if you want to be popular on the internet. Hard-line opinions about Bad Things(TM) always win virtue points regardless of whether or not those opinions are well informed.
- ufmace 8y agoThis is more the truth IMO. They aren't consciously being jerks because they don't have time to have those kinds of thoughts. Which means that throwing criminal charges around months later won't help anything. The only way to change such behavior would be for people to practice serious everything's-on-fire drop-everything-and-run-NOW evacuations regularly. I'm not going to hold my breath waiting for that to happen. Okay, maybe having a short preflight safety briefing that people would actually pay attention to and that told people that would help. Or maybe just scare the crap out of everyone.
- bambax 8y agoReally? What about people paking in handicapped space? Is this because they don't have time to think clearly, or is it because they only carr about themselves? Why would people be different when exiting a plane, as when shopping?
- ryanmarsh 8y agoIt would be terribly difficult for the prosecutor to prove that "but for" the actions of the defendant another person died. Secondly, I find it hard to believe that anyone who has had to act in moments as extreme as this would have such a harsh view of others who had never been in such a situation. I spent a good portion of my adult life in extreme situations and I can tell you people do not operate with their conscious minds. They do not really "make choices", things just happen. This is why training is so important for people who might encounter extreme situations. Please be more gracious to these people.
- biql 8y agoIt's worth noting that the reason many people take their baggage with them is because airlines often can't be trusted to handle it. Bags get lost, damaged, delayed on reclaim, etc, and they charge extra. If those problems were solved, airlines could forbid taking anything with you to the cabin with other passengers and evacuation would be easier.
- bipson 8y agoBecause any of the mentioned problems matter in the case of an emergency where people's lives are in danger.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mullen 8y agoIf a airplane crashes, all of the baggage is confiscated whether you took it off the plane or not. Do you really think that something happens to bring down a plane and they just let the people who took their baggage off the plane during the emergency to just go home with their baggage? I can't believe this has to be explained to anyone.
- crooked-v 8y agoThe post you're responding to is talking about the general case of non-emergency travel situations, which would if less poorly handled by airlines, allow for fewer complications in the specific case of emergencies.
- weaksauce 8y agoThe fire started on the ground.