6 ms·
> "What do we gain by connecting a smart watch to an internet-enabled coffee maker so I can avoid getting up to press a switch in the morning? Stay in bed and s
by pdonis 8y ago
> "What do we gain by connecting a smart watch to an internet-enabled coffee maker so I can avoid getting up to press a switch in the morning? Stay in bed and scroll Twitter?"
Or read a book. Or play with your kids. Or your pets. Or talk to your spouse/significant other/friends. Or write code. Or post on your blog. Or...
The value of "time-saving" is that it lets you choose what you will spend the saved time on, instead of being forced to spend it on routine tasks that might not give you any real satisfaction even though they need to be done. But you do have to choose. Being able to do that is of value to many people. But perhaps it isn't of value to everyone; and to someone for whom that opportunity to choose is not of value, perhaps they would indeed be better off making their coffee and doing other necessary life chores by hand.
- ssivark 8y ago> you do have to choose But that is precisely the point! Suppose, (as Barry Schwartz says) constraints are what drive choices we consider meaningful. Then, the greater the convenience, the harder it becomes to make meaningful choices! Would spending time with family feel as meaningful as it does now if you were living inside the loop of "Groundhog day" and recreating the same evening over and over again? That is essentially immortality, as experienced in an unchanging world. > Or read a book. Or play with your kids... I don't know about the people you meet, but most people I meet seem to lament that it feels like they're getting less and less time for these things :-)
- pdonis 8y ago> Would spending time with family feel as meaningful as it does now if you were living inside the loop of "Groundhog day" and recreating the same evening over and over again? Who said that was the choice being offered? > That is essentially immortality, as experienced in an unchanging world. But we don't live in an unchanging world, so I don't see how any of this is relevant. > most people I meet seem to lament that it feels like they're getting less and less time for these things Is that because they're refusing to use automatic coffee makers and doing all their chores by hand? Or is it because they're using all the time freed up by automation on Facebook and Twitter instead of using it reading or playing with their kids?
- TeMPOraL 8y agoThat line of thinking sounds a lot like trying to artificially induce meaningful experiences. I don't know if it generalizes to everyone, but once I'm aware I'm tricking myself into something, I don't find it meaningful at all. Also, "spending time with family" isn't meaningful per se. The meaning is in the details the phrase doesn't convey - the things you do together, the things you talk about, the emotions you feel. > most people I meet seem to lament that it feels like they're getting less and less time for these things :-) That's because we live in a competitive environment; the work really does expand to encompass all the time labour-saving inventions liberate - simply because some people choose to go "the extra mile" and everyone else suddenly has to follow suit, or risk being left behind.
- ralphstodomingo 8y ago> Or read a book. Or play with your kids. Or your pets. Or talk to your spouse/significant other/friends. Or write code. Or post on your blog. > you do have to choose. Yes, convenience frees you up to pursue something else, but I've felt that it takes so much willpower to pick an activity you know to be of value to you (like exercise, or reading a book) over something immediately gratifying. Another thing I've been thinking about, related to this is that our value systems and/or attention span have been weakened severely by the torrent of information and immediate connectivity these days have. I remember this quote attributed to G. Michael Hopf: "Hard times create strong men. Strong men create good times. Good times create weak men. And, weak men create hard times." What if this pursuit of convenience is making us weaker, and in the long run, blind to what should be pursued with the time we free up?
- nopassrecover 8y agoYou may be interested in this if you haven’t already come across it previously: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strauss–Howe_generational_theory https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strauss–Howe_generational_th...
- ralphstodomingo 8y agoReally interesting bit, wouldn't have found it unless you sent me this. Interested, too, to hear what people think about it.
- pdonis 8y ago> it takes so much willpower to pick an activity you know to be of value to you (like exercise, or reading a book) over something immediately gratifying Yes, it does. Anything worthwhile requires effort. But most such things can also benefit greatly from practice--the more you are able to choose to do them, the easier it gets to choose to do them.
- Kalium 8y ago> Yes, convenience frees you up to pursue something else, but I've felt that it takes so much willpower to pick an activity you know to be of value to you (like exercise, or reading a book) over something immediately gratifying. Whereas before you didn't have to choose and never got an opportunity to use your willpower to pick an activity of value. What's to say that people weren't made weak and compliant by a lack of opportunity to make their own choices? > What if this pursuit of convenience is making us weaker, and in the long run, blind to what should be pursued with the time we free up? What if it isn't? What if this is little more than another moral panic, such as a decade ago how sexting was going to ruin everyone forever and was a threat to all children? It seems to me that there are few answers here, but an awful lot of moralizing about shockingly little. Re-frame much of it as the quest for self-mastery, and now generations of philosophers approve.
- vlan0 8y agoIf making coffee is as simple and quick as pressing a button, then I doubt the convince would save enough time for any of the activities you mentioned. We also should also not forget the extreme sacrifice in quality that comes “quick and easy” coffee.
- wDcBKgt66V8WDs 8y agoexactly. read 2 pages of a book. play with your pet for so little time that it gets pissed off at you. ditto the kid. code long enough that you manage to remember what you were doing yesterday and then immediately forget...
- asark 8y agoA stupid-simple $20 coffee machine with no interface but an on/off switch will produce something most daily coffee drinkers find acceptable, given grounds a notch or two above the absolute cheapest around, and it takes at most 1 minute of hands-on time if your stuff's arranged with any sense at all. My pour-overs from whole beans take like 3 min hands-on, maybe, and that's about as fiddly as it gets. Maybe add one minute with a manual grinder just for maximum fiddliness. WTF are people doing that not having to make coffee frees up any useful amount of time?
- atoav 8y agoI use a (manual) coffee grinder as part of a morning ritual. When I wake up I put on water to boil, start grinding coffee, stare out of the window, make coffee and then return to bed and read my news/blogs for as long as the coffee lasts. Then I go for a shower. The thing for me is: it feels good to start the day by doing something yourself and the time you spend in morning rituals can be valuable for the whole day. Although I automate a lot on computers, I belive in the value of manually making things happen, instead of having a environment that caters to you. Every now and then I break my ritual and don’t drink coffee, which is something I don’t want to have to schedule with my smart watch.
- bluGill 8y agoDo you cut the wood to boil your coffee, light the fire, or is that line about boiling coffee just a convenient knob you turned. When you put the water on to boil do you go to the well [that you dug yourself] and let a bucket down on a rope [that you made yourself]; or do you open the tap? Is your coffee grinder a rock, or a more convenient gadget?
- coldtea 8y agoNone of those things sounds particularly bad -- and many people do all of the above... Environmentally wise, they are much saner. And from a sedentary standpoint too.
- bluGill 8y agoPerhaps, but your morning coffee now isn't ready until lunch time...
- coldtea 8y agoIt doesn't take more than 10 minutes to cut some wood for the fireplace/stove (assuming you haven't already cut them at a more convenient time or bought them pre-cut). Water from the well is also like 2-5 minutes to get assuming the well is in your property and not a few miles away (and assuming you don't have it already connected to pipes). All in all, one can get some firewood, start the stove/fireplace, grind coffee, and have a cup within 30 minutes or so. Still more than waiting 2-3 minutes for the machine to poor it, but not really impossible. On the plus side, the whole procedure assumes that you live in the countryside, and don't have some office job to feel stressed to go early to.
- lostphilosopher 8y agoBoth your statement and the GP's ring true to me. Here's how I'd parse it - Automation does indeed free up time for by choice activities, but it also removes motivation to do things that are both hard to do and good to do. Obvious example: cars have made tons of things possible that weren't possible before, but if I didn't have a car or live in a society built around them I'd probably get a lot more exercise. The more automation we have the fewer things we're forced to do and there are drawbacks that come with that. Others have brought up that the experience of having done any hard thing may have intrinsic benefits, but fewer of us have had that experience. Not an argument against automation, just acknowledging the cons.
- coldtea 8y ago>Or read a book. Or play with your kids. Or your pets. Or talk to your spouse/significant other/friends. Or write code. Or post on your blog. Or... Or nothing of the short -- just go and produce more useless innovations (IoT crap, and so on), and then spend 3+ hours on social media, and so on. The important real time saving low hanging fruits inventions (washing machine, fridge, etc) are already done (some are pending still, but they aren't those peddled by modern companies). All those modern "innovations" are meant for you to be a good consumer -- and to be such, you need to constantly buy the next, and work in the rat race to afford them. You could read the book and play with your kids without an "internet-enabled coffee maker"... In fact even agrarian medieval societies had more holidays (almost half the year) and far more leisure time than we do -- and that's with all the farm and household chores...