3 ms·
I wonder what they're using the lead and cadmium for? Also, "toxic" may be overexaggerating; "poisonous" or even "possibly harmful" might be more accurate, but
by userbinator 8y ago
I wonder what they're using the lead and cadmium for? Also, "toxic" may be overexaggerating; "poisonous" or even "possibly harmful" might be more accurate, but even then, from what I understand you'd have to consume a lot of it for it to be a problem.
(I worked on electronics and soldered with real lead solder for many decades, starting when I was a kid, and think RoHS and the lead-ban has caused far more environmental problems.)
Edit: apparently controversial opinions are not welcome here either...? Or is it the "chemicals are scary" crowd again? :|
- rectangletangle 8y agoThey're probably using the cadmium for red paint/dye. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cadmium_pigments https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cadmium_pigments
- userbinator 8y agoWorth reading the safety section, which starts with this sentence: Cadmium sulfide is not very toxic (LD50 above 5,000 mg/kg) when used as a pigment, although acute exposure to cadmium vapors from welding is harmful. For comparison, sodium chloride (table salt) has an LD50 of 3,000mg/kg.
- aaronbwebber 8y agoUsing the LD50 for a carcinogen is inappropriate. LD50s are used as a measure of acute toxicity. The issue isn't that it's going to kill you from toxicity, it's that if you expose thousands of children to even low levels of it many more of them will get cancers than they otherwise would.
- verelo 8y agoNot familiar with the reasons why the lead ban or rohs would be an issue for the environment, can you point me in the right direction? They seem like positive moves on the surface, but I’m sure they’re not as straightforward as I’d like.
- userbinator 8y agoOne of the reasons: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whisker_(metallurgy) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whisker_(metallurgy) Lead-free solder is also less resilient to thermal stress because it's not as ductile, and that lead to plenty of PCB failures around the time manufacturers switched over --- creating even more e-waste. Fortunately, military/aerospace is still exempt from the ban. Here's an interesting NASA presentation about lead-free vs. leaded solder: https://nepp.nasa.gov/whisker/reference/tech_papers/2011-kostic-Pb-free.pdf https://nepp.nasa.gov/whisker/reference/tech_papers/2011-kos...
- hedora 8y agoThe problems from lead-free solder are mostly solved, though avoiding them is non-trivial, and does require special expertise.
- qiqitori 8y agoAh, so your argument is that the lead ban has led to PCB defects that might have increased e-waste. Let't think about e-waste for a bit. Let's say you have a PCB that you do not need anymore. This PCB is made of the following materials: - mostly epoxy - surface mount components: ceramics, plastics, glass, etc. - metals such as tin, copper, steel, aluminum, gold Generally, only the metal bits are worth recovering, everything else needs to be burned. (It's possible to burn epoxy and other plastics without producing harmful gases.) Depending on the type of board, the metals may or may not be worth recovering. If it's just tin and steel and copper, there's no harm in just shredding and burning the whole thing. (After shredding, a small amount of metal may recovered by magnets and routed to the foundries.) If the burning is done correctly (and it definitely isn't if you do this on the streets somewhere), no harmful gases are produced, and materials like ceramics, glass and metals will be left in the ash/slag. (BTW, even if your incineration facility sucks somehow and harmful gases like dioxins are produced, most of these decompose from UV exposure.) That slag will often be used to build roads, and e.g. this company says they're able to refine the slag a bit: https://www.adrecyclingmachines.com/applications/incineration-slag https://www.adrecyclingmachines.com/applications/incineratio... Now, what if there's lead or other heavy metals in that slag? You probably would want to avoid using that for road construction, and since metals form alloys, you'll also be able to recover a whole lot less reusable metal. Lead has really, really bad effects on human health (not just cancer, but generic insanity). Most people seem to think that lead causes cancer, along with thousands of other compounds. But when they're told that lead causes insanity, they usually tend to listen a bit more carefully. If "insanity" doesn't mean much to you... Well, there have been studies correlating lead exposure with violent crimes. (* I haven't read these studies, but they can be found on Google)
- astura 8y agoPaint. >from what I understand you'd have to consume a lot of it for it to be a problem. Your understanding is wrong.
- emeraldd 8y agoThe cadmium could easily be tied to pigments, though I suspect this is more likely from environmental contamination. Some quick google searches find things like: https://www.betterhealth.vic.gov.au/health/HealthyLiving/cadmium https://www.betterhealth.vic.gov.au/health/HealthyLiving/cad... https://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/csem/csem.asp?csem=6&po=5 https://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/csem/csem.asp?csem=6&po=5 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.3184/095422910X12631439471494 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.3184/095422910X126314... So likely, they aren't using the Cadmium and Lead for anything directly with these products, it just happens to be around as a contaminant from other processes.
- analog31 8y agoAs I understand it, one use is in catalysts that speed up the drying of paint... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oil_drying_agent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oil_drying_agent
- onion2k 8y agoAlso, "toxic" may be overexaggerating; "poisonous" or even "possibly harmful" might be more accurate, but even then, from what I understand you'd have to consume a lot of it for it to be a problem. Toxic is definitely the correct term. Heavy metals like lead and cadmium don't get excreted by your body; they build up in the brain and kidneys until they kill you. For this reason there is no level of exposure that's considered safe. Even a very low level of exposure will kill you eventually.
- astura 8y agoLead exposure in children causes permanent damage to the brain and nervous system.
- schappim 8y ago>> I wonder what they're using the lead and cadmium for pigments (lead), soldering (lead) and light sensors (cadmium).