3 ms·
SF's budget is actually much larger than Chicago's budget in 2019, $11B vs $8.9B. However, Chicago has significantly more debt, and is on the verge of bankrupt
by gamblor956 8y ago
SF's budget is actually much larger than Chicago's budget in 2019, $11B vs $8.9B.
However, Chicago has significantly more debt, and is on the verge of bankruptcy. SF is not.
- mmcclure 8y agoTo add to this, I'm assuming "twice as large of an economy" must be hyperbole because I'm not finding any data that comes even close to that. Chicago's GDP, for example, is only ~1.3x bigger in total. In terms of GDP per capita SF is actually ~1.5x bigger (for metro areas, because that's the data I could find). Definitely not arguing that SF doesn't have its share of management problems, but this feels like a pretty poor example.
- rayiner 8y agoI’m looking at just the city proper. 1.5x the GDP per capita, with 1/3 the population = half the GDP.
- mmcclure 8y agoThen you're not looking at the city proper and we're mixing measures here. The 1.5x I mentioned is at the metro level, while your 1/3 population is city proper. That said, I'm struggling to find any kind of useful data broken down at the city level in terms of economic output, so I certainly wouldn't die on this hill.
- rayiner 8y agoRight, I’m assuming the relative ratio is the same for the cities as for the metro areas. Both cities have a lot of their jobs and major companies in the suburbs, so that’s probably not an unreasonable assumption.
- rayiner 8y agoChicago’s problem is that it’s in a state that until quite recently taxed like a red state (3% flat income tax!). But that’s on the revenue side—it has nothing to do with how much money is reasonable to spend on city services.
- strictnein 8y agoIf taxes are the issue, nothing is stopping the one party that rules Chicago from implementing their own progressive income tax.