5 ms·
This has an assumption that the people are a fixed group - that if you add more housing, that will mean better housing for the people at the end of your 'line'.
by cortesoft 8y ago
This has an assumption that the people are a fixed group - that if you add more housing, that will mean better housing for the people at the end of your 'line'.
This doesn't take into account something mentioned in the article - that increased housing supply is going to attract MORE of the highly skilled workers that were driving up costs, and those people are going to be the ones filling up the houses, not poorer people.
This is a form of induced demand.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Induced_demand https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Induced_demand
- wbl 8y agoAnd the highly skilled workers were where before this? Oakland suffers because SF doesn't build.
- cortesoft 8y agoThey live in the surrounding areas or other parts of the country. They will move closer to the cities, with shorter commutes, as housing prices move down.
- nostrademons 8y agoSounds like a win all around.
- stale2002 8y agoThere are low income requirements in many cities though. For every X number of expensive apartments, builders must sell Y% low income housing. Even if you only care about the low income stuff, upzoning still helps, and gets you what you want.
- bluGill 8y agoInduced demand is nonsense. It really means there is unmet demand at the price point. Once everyone who wants a house at a price point gets one. Same applies to roads: if you build them big enough eventually there are enough lanes. What really you are saying is we don't want to build enough for all the unmet demand at the current price point. This is a perfectly fine thing. Roads are expensive, if we can get people to not drive someplace because the current roads are too crowded that might be a worthwhile thing. Unlimited road expansion quickly requires expensive bridges. Building more houses actually starts to fix the road problem because dense enough houses makes public transportation practical. Yes rich folks will move into San Francisco at first. However their old house isn't in middle of nowhere, it is a longer commute away from San Francisco, and that house is available.
- secabeen 8y ago> Once everyone who wants a house at a price point gets one. Same applies to roads: if you build them big enough eventually there are enough lanes. Here is a report from UC Davis that shows otherwise: http://www.dot.ca.gov/research/researchreports/reports/2015/10-12-2015-NCST_Brief_InducedTravel_CS6_v3.pdf http://www.dot.ca.gov/research/researchreports/reports/2015/...
- paulddraper 8y agoYes, other factors can change to compensate. In that case, people drove more miles with bigger roads, meaning congestion doesn't decrease very much. But big picture: more people got more of what they wanted, which to drive farther (without more congestion).
- tastygreenapple 8y agoI think the parent comment was pretty clear in their argument - you have to build enough roads to get ahead of constrained consumption. If they built an extra lane on every road between me and the pizza shop, I'd go the pizza shop more. I dont' go to the pizza shop as often as I'd like because I hate traffic, if there were less traffic, I'd be better off. But I won't drive any more than I'd like to, I think we could build more roads and build that capaity for more people.
- thebradbain 8y agoA tangent: Or we could invest more in public mass transit, which is proven to get people around dense cities more efficiently — without all of the negative externalities wider roads bring (sprawl, mainly, which even an all electric-fleet won’t stop; and, as has actually been seen again again, congestion: in many cases a proper multi-modal street grid is actually more efficient and faster for everyone, including drivers, than a single-purpose channel accessible to only cars). There’s certainly a place for cars in city planning (lower density areas), but there’s also a point where planning focuses too much on cars to the detriment of everyone else.
- mixmastamyk 8y agoOn the other hand, if you don’t build, rich workers will win and force folks out anyway. At least with more supply folks are forced out more slowly, if at all.
- pcwalton 8y agoInduced demand applies to roads because people have a choice whether to drive or not. But they don't have a choice of whether they need a house or not. For housing it's not induced demand--it's just demand.
- toast0 8y agoSome people choose not to live in the Bay Area (or SF specifically) because prices are too high. Or they choose to live with more people per unit of housing because of pricing.