5 ms·
Perfect timing. I was only just discussing battery technology with some friends, who believe batteries cannot possibly grow to capacities larger than we have to
by sliverstorm 16y ago
Perfect timing. I was only just discussing battery technology with some friends, who believe batteries cannot possibly grow to capacities larger than we have today on the basis of 'gee, they haven't grown as fast as other technology in the past 100 years'
No faith in scientists, I tell you.
- InclinedPlane 16y agoBattery technology has different constraints than other technologies (such as cpu speed or memory capacity) but there's still a ton of headroom. There's at least a factor of 50 available between today's batteries and the energy density of gasoline (for example).
- raghava 16y agoI remember reading about betavoltaics a coupla years ago. http://www.newscientist.com/blog/invention/2007/07/betavoltiac-batteries.html http://www.newscientist.com/blog/invention/2007/07/betavolti... >>a factor of 50 Yes.
- ynniv 16y agoWhen making the comparison between batteries and gasoline, it is often useful to note that converting gasoline into mechanical energy is only about 35% efficient. This gives batteries a 3x operational advantage.
- anamax 16y ago> There's at least a factor of 50 available between today's batteries and the energy density of gasoline (for example). That difference doesn't imply that batteries can be improved at all, let alone by 50x. There are lots of differences between batteries and gasoline and some of them may limit the energy density of batteries to be less than that of gasoline. Even small differences matter. For example, diesel has significantly more energy per volume than gasoline. (I forget how the various alcohols rank.)
- samatman 16y agoLower than gasoline as a general rule. Once you get to butyl alcohol the differences start being minor.
- pierrefar 16y agoYou reminded of a sort-of related quote: When an expert says something is possible, they're almost certainly right and when an expert says something is impossible, they're almost certainly wrong.
- dcx 16y agoSo if you consult an expert, anything is almost certainly possible? ;-)
- wladimir 16y agoStill, it's true. Theoretical constraints that exist now might well be removed with new scientific insights. Trying to predict whether something is possible at all is useless given our limited understanding of things. If an expert says something is possible.. it probably will be developed soon. If an expect says something is not possible, it probably will be developed (far) further in the future.
- derefr 16y agoExcept if the expert in question is a physicist; rigorously determining exactly what is impossible, and why, is basically their job.
- albertzeyer 16y agoWell, yea, under the assumption that the current theory is complete and right. There are quite a few examples in history where great physicians have been wrong. Maybe todays physicians are more careful because of that but let's see how radical the view on our universe changes in the future.
- newman314 16y agophysicist = a scientist who studies or practices physics. physician = doctor.
- 16y ago