3 ms·
I'd say, very unlikely even if Zhao and Hu were given a go. Both of them were held pretty much like a decoration to appease the West. A lot people exaggerate t
by baybal2 8y ago
I'd say, very unlikely even if Zhao and Hu were given a go. Both of them were held pretty much like a decoration to appease the West.
A lot people exaggerate their role. Even back then, very few Chinese ever heard of them.
> What if the students in Tiananmen Square had peacefully dispersed, but continued to work quietly for democratic reform throughout the 1990s?
Then they would've been quietly hunted down to the last one without making much of a bang. People entertaining themselves with such scenarios have little understanding of the way the mindset of totalitarian regime leaders work: in 1989, the CCP was scared to death. Loss of power in any form for such people invariably means either a trip to Hague, or to their own secret jails.
Peaceful political change don't happen when the power holders are ready to do anything to keep their power. In such cases, only violence works.
I truly despise people who call for "peaceful resistance" in time when people are being showered with bullets. Such people bear as much responsibility for loss of human life as one who do the killing.
- NotPaidToPost 8y ago> Then they would've been quietly hunted down to the last one without making much of a bang. That's pure conjecture, of course. One thing to keep in mind is that the events of Tiananmen (and beyond, actually, as they did not involve only Beijing and only the students) scared the government, as you mention. That's why the reaction was so harsh and the backlash so durable. The government might have taken a softer stance if the events had been less threatening.