3 ms·
> I am unhappy about STEM. That is, I’m unhappy about how it’s presented as the principal portal for careers in science and technology. Hear hear! Much as I h
by gumby 8y ago
> I am unhappy about STEM. That is, I’m unhappy about how it’s presented as the principal portal for careers in science and technology.
Hear hear! Much as I hate anti-vaxxer know-nothings, much support from the sciences is also “science fandom” rather than scientific thinking.
And from my time on a school board (where almost every discussion involves axe grinding) I learned that there was a talismanic belief in magical “STEM” that would help us create the “thinkers of tomorrow”. “Technology” was super important, but its definition was absurdly restrictive: teach the kids Word and PowerPoint so they’ll be prepared for the jobs of tomorrow. Hey, the wheel and inclined plane were triumphs of technological thinking which is what people need to develop, not Gadgrindesque “skilled” organized by an institutional ontology.
- joeyrideout 8y agoThank you for the succinct description of '“science fandom” rather than scientific thinking'. This perfectly expresses my trouble with most scientific discourse nowadays. Many people brandishing "science" as a tool to win arguments instead of thinking scientifically, and often can't explain the scientific method. That, and the constant appeal to authority (fallacy) of "scientists say..." are my biggest pet peeves. This problem isn't easily solved, unfortunately, because scientific thinking is difficult and not for everyone. If anything this amplifies the responsibilities placed on scientists to communicate their findings and caveats as clearly as possible to the public.
- whatshisface 8y ago>most scientific discourse nowadays I don't think it's right to call what you're describing "scientific discourse," it's more like "popular discourse." >scientific thinking is difficult and not for everyone There's no difference between scientific thinking and careful thinking. In fact the main strength of science is that anyone can eventually reproduce the conclusions, it's just that some people would take longer than others. If it was a priesthood of oracles who could, alone, speak to nature then you couldn't reasonably expect the non-oracles to believe any of it.
- ndiscussion 8y ago>There's no difference between scientific thinking and careful thinking. Not sure what your intent was, but I don't think the following statement is any less valid as a result >scientific thinking is difficult and not for everyone >careful thinking is difficult and not for everyone
- whatshisface 8y agoAnyone can think carefully, and everyone needs to think carefully sometimes.
- foldr 8y ago>There's no difference between scientific thinking and careful thinking. I don't think this can be right unless you have a very broad definition of "scientific". Lots of people think carefully about lots of things. Only a tiny minority of them are doing science.
- gumby 8y agoI interpreted the statement as "the process of thoughtful reflection, learning, and decision is no different in the scientific domain as any other". The problem is so few people do engage in critical thinking. I think that's a human universal though.
- MaxBarraclough 8y agoYou are correct, there's certainly more to the scientific process than thinking. Theology isn't science, but not for lack of careful thinking. Mathematics isn't science either. Science is about empirical investigation, by definition. I think whatshisface's point was that scientists don't have unique access to some special mode of inquiry. It's expertise, not a priesthood.
- joeyrideout 8y agoYes, you're right, popular discourse is better wording. Or perhaps I could put scare-quotes around "scientific" discourse. I see scientific thinking as more in line with skepticism and general disagreeableness. (Is that really true? Where's the data? What was your methodology? How did you come to that conclusion?)
- matt4077 8y agoNuclear technology fanboys are the worst in this regard. They seem to be forever trapped in some 1950’s futurism, not noticing that renewables have improved while their favorite technology has stagnated. Actual scientists improved batteries and photovoltaics by magnitudes, but these people are still litigating some argument from the 80s about risk assessment.
- maxxxxx 8y agoThat's what bothers me about the whole idea that if everybody beams a coder the world would be a better place. STEM is an important of education but there are plenty of other things that are as important. that coming from someone who has an engineering mind but I know I wouldn't the world to be run exclusively by people like me. I like the phrase “science fandom”.
- Bartweiss 8y agoI've been thinking a lot lately about the idea that we too often learn whether things are good or bad without learning why. It gets discussed most with politics and ethics, where people can revile a past movement while happily reinventing all of its beliefs. But the same goes for "science fandom", where 'science' is the good thing which knows settled facts, rather than the actual investigative process that discovered them. Or too for replication-crisis academia, where everything from peer review to significance testing are treated as ritual barriers to getting published. (Not just by publish-or-perish; people like Wansink seem to genuinely have no idea why they need good methodology.) My old school district has repeatedly cut funding for science, non-core tech classes from programming to computer art, and any sort of 'extra' content from accelerated classes to non-teacher experts. (For years, they had a floating "science demonstrator" who was one of the best and most scientifically-minded educators I've ever met. Not anymore.) Meanwhile, there's constant talk about how teaching students to be at the cutting edge of STEM is a major priority. They've rationalized that divide with things like 'science and technology studies' (meaning Powerpoints about science topics) and 'STEAM' (I'm all for arts education, but it's basically being used here as a broadened slogan to avoid talking about science). Outside of one great physics teacher, the most science-minded class I remember taking was actually a machine shop class. Giving up the STEM talisman and taking on inherently open-ended problems like "it's making a funny noise" did wonders for getting people to think inquisitively and logically.
- rosser 8y ago> “science fandom” See also Scientism [0], especially in the sense Popper meant it. The place I keep getting stuck is trying to understand how we went from skepticism meaning, "I will neither believe, nor disbelieve, without evidence" to something more like "if the thing doesn't confirm my (probably very limited) understanding of our (definitely limited) understanding of reality, the thing should be dismissed, if not mocked." I get the value of things needing to be proved — which, in context, just means "the theory still works", not the "it is known" that notion seems to have become — in order to be believed, but the one just doesn't follow from the other. My guess is tribalism. When people are mocking things, they're doing it to advertise some kind of tribal affiliation, or enforce some tribe's norms. EDIT: Phrasing. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientism