4 ms·
From companies' perspective, SMS has a critical property that U2F dongles and TOTP authenticators lack: Restoring the user's access if they lose it is someone e
by michaelt 8y ago
From companies' perspective, SMS has a critical property that U2F dongles and TOTP authenticators lack: Restoring the user's access if they lose it is someone else's problem.
With SMS login, if I lose my phone getting back into my account is an argument between me and my phone provider. And blame for any mistakes in that process lies squarely with my phone provider.
This avoids the "I lost the backup codes as it's 5 years since I printed them out" problem.
Anyone involved in designing a 2FA system knows SMS isn't secure - companies like Apple accept that insecurity, to avoid the support costs of the lost-backup-codes problem.
- kwhitefoot 8y agoWhy does everyone assume that two factor authentication by mobile means SMS? The SIM card (Subscriber Identity Module) has the features necessary to do it and this is used in Norway to provide 2FA for logging in to banks and state services like tax and health.