3 ms·
From outside the US, it's hard to avoid the impression that some non-trivial percentage of high school supervisors and support staff are fundamentally irrationa
by TheOtherHobbes 8y ago
From outside the US, it's hard to avoid the impression that some non-trivial percentage of high school supervisors and support staff are fundamentally irrational and unable to think and act like stable, responsible adults.
This is incredibly damaging for teens, because teens need to see adults modelling rational, fair, and effective boundaries, and dealing with problems in sane ways.
Powerful adults acting like capriciously ineffective self-indulgent authoritarians is almost the worst possible school environment.
- itronitron 8y agoUnfortunately all it takes is one irrational adult to cause lasting harm, and over the course of 12 years each student is likely to come across several. The common trait, based on my experience, is that the problem staff feel they have all the information, are the experts, categorize complex interactions into 'seen this before' bins, and feel they are the sole authority and report to no one. They are basically acting as judge, jury, and executioner. They are a minority within the public school system however they have the overwritten rules and regulations to back up their actions.
- cafard 8y agoI'd be interest to learn of a country that does not have this sort of problem to some degree. "teens need to see adults modelling rational, fair, and effective boundaries, and dealing with problems in sane ways". This may sound like sarcasm, but is not intended as such: this is rude preparation for the workplace and the "public square". I agree that education would be better.
- zamber 8y agoIt's not a US-only phenomenon. I've got lots of similar incompetency stories from Poland. My mom was a math teacher in primary school for 6 months after which she had to stop doing it because the kids drove her close to a mental breakdown. Her friend from high school (which sucked at math) still teaches in her hometown and is seen by a lot of kids (and now adults) as completely incompetent (as reported by cousins growing up there). I recall multiple instances of incompetency, abuse, blaming and general stupidity in my own education. Good teachers were the odd ones. Most were mediocre. The problematic ones had to really cross the line to get fired or warned.