7 ms·
So basically they reinvented the trolleybuss[1] that's been around for over 100 years and still popular in some European cities by putting a tram pantograph[2]
by ChuckNorris89 8y ago
So basically they reinvented the trolleybuss[1] that's been around for over 100 years and still popular in some European cities by putting a tram pantograph[2] on top and moving them on highways.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolleybus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolleybus
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tram https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tram
- chewz 8y agoExactly. Trolleybus had been popular in my city when I was a child. Then declared obstacles and replaced with oridinary buses. Time to bring trolleybus back instead of EVs that as any individual cars have no place in a city.
- mysterydip 8y agoIs there a such thing as a cargo trolleybus, or are they strictly for passengers? Maybe such a thing could be useful in cities?
- dredmorbius 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolleytruck https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolleytruck
- martin_a 8y agoHead over to Solingen, they still have some there. ;-)
- sergiosgc 8y ago> (...) as any individual cars have no place in a city. That's one view. The other is that cities are too dense. There is no reason, in the era of fast digital communications, to pack humans so densely that we are discussing the right to use an 8m² space in the city for personal use. It's an attack on the symptom rather than an attack on the cause.
- mgbmtl 8y agoWhat's the maximum density? I live in Montreal, which is a medium-sized city, not particularly dense, but cars don't scale as well as humans. The city has become gridlocked, noisy and dangerous, with roads full of potholes no matter how much money we throw at the problem.
- sergiosgc 8y agoI'm not a city planning expert, so I have no idea. It's a fun problem, though: From Wikipedia, Montreal seems to have a lower density than my home city (Porto), at 4k/km² vs 7k/km², but higher total urban population (3.5M vs 1.5M). Porto has very decent traffic (rush hour lasts 2h, entry/exit times peak at 30min). It's either the total population that is causing stress in Montreal, or traffic planning. Porto did a very thorough change in traffic in the 90s, to great effect. Outer rings to avoid passing traffic going into the city, an inner traffic distribution ring, channels to have traffic avoid the old city center (centuries old, poor fit for auto traffic).
- mgbmtl 8y agoI had misread your initial comment. As a north-american, I often hear people arguing in favour of more sprawl. A detached house and minimum two cars for a family. I think we agree that we can have nice 'small' but dense cities. We don't all need to be New York, but we also don't want to clutter the planet with suburbs.
- baud147258 8y ago> Outer rings to avoid passing traffic going into the city, an inner traffic distribution ring, channels to have traffic avoid the old city center It's funny how it look like a quick description on how traffic is organized around Paris, which is heavily gridlocked. Of course, that's two different metro area and I'm not a specialist on why we have traffic issues here in Paris.
- sergiosgc 8y ago
- throw0101a 8y ago> Time to bring trolleybus back instead of EVs that as any individual cars have no place in a city. If a city / transit agency does not have overhead wiring infrastructure already, I do not think they will have much interest in setting it up from scratch. It's probably a lot easier to either (i) have a few charging spots on a bus route, (ii) use hybrid buses, or (iii) have EV buses with range extenders where needed.
- ordu 8y agoTrolleybus can charge while moving. Or while staying at a charging spot. In St.-Petersburg, Russia we had trolleybus all the time, but lately they got batteries and it was a mind blowing experience to see a trolleybus going without wires. The next surprising thing of that sort would be a tram going without rails.
- anticensor 8y agoThat will not be called tram. Whole point of tramway is it trams a fixed path.
- denzil_correa 8y agoBerlin ran the first experimental Trolleybus in the world. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electromote https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electromote
- _Codemonkeyism 8y agoFrom the article "In English language use, the Kontaktwagen was later named the "trolley", giving the trolley car and trolley bus their names."
- hn23 8y agoNot exactly. A trolleybuss will not run at 90km/h.
- mantas 8y agoNor do trucks in the city. Put trolleybus on a highway and it could do 90km/h.
- jessriedel 8y agoDo you know of any existing system of trolleybuses running at highway speeds? Equating the tech here is like equating trams with long-distance trains.
- mantas 8y agoWell, it's city transport so they're installed in cities. But I don't see any technical issues to install them on highways if it proved to be cost-effective. My city got a significant trolleybus network. It's on slow streets only because that's where public transit stops are. But from technical perspective, there's nothing stopping from putting them on a highway. The biggest issue is tight intersections downtown. They go painfully slow at those. Straight line? No problem at all and they can safely floor it. And boy is there a difference between flooring a trolley and a diesel bus...
- jessriedel 8y agoWithout evidence, I'm not at all convinced by your claim that there is no technical issues to doubling the speed and handling heavy freight. There is a reason trains are different than trams.
- mantas 8y agoJust like there's some difference between trains, high speed trains and freight trains, there would be some differences between trolleys and freight-trolleys or high speed trolleys. But the fundamental design is +/- the same.
- yitchelle 8y agoDon't think it ever went away in Germany. Solingen, a German city close to where I live, have been running trolleybuses for many years now. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolleybuses_in_Solingen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolleybuses_in_Solingen
- badpun 8y agoTrolleybuses are operating in a couple Polish cities as well. IMO they’re great - clean like a tram (which are very widespread in Poland), but make less noise and vibrations (as they ride on rubber, not steel) and don’t require the tracks. Also, one tram’s failure causes entire line to shut down, which is not the case with trolleybuses. I really like them.
- qbaqbaqba 8y agoPutting batteries in trolleybuses could help mitigate this problem.
- badpun 8y agoTrolleybusses DON'T have that problem - they can easily pass another failed trolleybuss. Having said that, there are trolleybusses with batteries already (operating in Gdynia, Poland for example) - they're being used to service routes which are not 100% electrified.
- gumby 8y agoStill big in SF. The differences of this proposal are the distances and speeds, and that I assume the trucks are multimode (so can use electric on the Autobahn and then ICE elsewhere.
- SiempreViernes 8y agoYeah, the article states that these are hybrid trucks.
- jessriedel 8y agoTrolleybus cannot operate at highway speeds or handle detachable trailers.
- johannes1234321 8y agoA problem they are solving is that this requires a closed electric circuit. Trams solve that with a pantograph and steel wheels on steel rails. Trolley busses use two collectors tied to the independent overhead lines. This system uses two pantographs with a control system pulling them back when he truck leaves the lane and pushes them up when entering the lane. Doing that on highway speeds is a bit more complicated.
- jlj 8y agoSeattle has had them for half a century or longer too.