4 ms·
I've heard multiple times that you sometimes get understandable speech out of an analog radio where a digital signal wouldn't work. That doesn't make sense to m
by adrianN 8y ago
I've heard multiple times that you sometimes get understandable speech out of an analog radio where a digital signal wouldn't work. That doesn't make sense to me. If there is enough signal left for a human to understand speech, surely there is enough signal left for a computer to understand something if you have an appropriately chosen amount of ECC applied in your protocol.
- j16sdiz 8y agoAnalog radio usually use lots more bandwidth, maybe that's why.
- philpem 8y agoNot always. 25kHz "wide NFM" is still common where licences have been grandfathered in, but 12.5kHz "narrow NFM" is becoming more common. 12.5k NFM has the same signal bandwidth as a timesliced (dual timeslot -- two virtual channels per physical RF channel) DMR or APCO P25 signal.
- jcims 8y agoInstantaneous use is the same but channel management does probably make P25 more efficient for a bunch of departments to independently operate in limited spectrum.
- philpem 8y agoThe problem is twofold: "graceful degradation" and the effect of digital compression. Digital schemes like TETRA and DMR compress the audio and add error correction. The audio bitrate for DMR is somewhere around 2400 Baud. This means a lot has to be thrown away. As a result, some things confuse the codec (usually AMBE). I have Scottish and Irish friends with strong accents; AMBE makes their voices both indistinguishable and unintelligible. The second problem is what's sometimes called "the cliff-edge effect" or "graceful degradation". An FM signal degrades progressively as the signal gets weaker. If there's a temporary 'fading', you'll get a bit more hiss for a second or two. An experienced dispatcher or radio operator will often be able to "hear through" the hiss. Digital signals don't degrade gracefully. The audio quality is perfect up to a point, but after that point things fail quickly. You get corrupted, missing or glitchy audio, loss of control packets (more lost audio), loss-of-sync (no audio until the next SYNC burst, ~1-2 secs)... Incidentally, analog speech scramblers have similar issues. Rolling Spectrum Inversion scramblers send an FSK data-burst every time the seed (ephemeral key) changes. If your radio misses one of these bursts, the rx/tx audio will be screwed up for a second or two.
- anilakar 8y agoI still haven't fathomed why ETSI chose AMBE+2 for DMR. It's a codec made by an American company for compressing American English speech and it works reasonably well for that purpose. However, most speakers in my native language sound as if they were drunk or having a stroke. Even Motorola has recognized that problem and added options in their programming software that makes the DSP boost higher frequencies before feeding the signal to the vocoder. As to the graceful vs cliff-edge degradation of signals I've yet to see real comparisons where both analog and digital radios use the same frequency, radiated power and bandwidth (with co-channel interference!). With digital systems, the degradation will surely be much more noticeable, but the real question is whether the critical signal level is above or below that of the analog system.
- mschuster91 8y ago> I still haven't fathomed why ETSI chose AMBE+2 for DMR. It's a codec made by an American company for compressing American English speech and it works reasonably well for that purpose. However, most speakers in my native language sound as if they were drunk or having a stroke. A lack of ethnic diversity in vendors and standardization committees, which has also led to issues such as the "racist soap dispenser" (https://gizmodo.com/why-cant-this-soap-dispenser-identify-dark-skin-1797931773 https://gizmodo.com/why-cant-this-soap-dispenser-identify-da...). When most or all testing is exclusively done on White US-english male persons, issues such as a lack of sensitivity/quality for anything diverging from that norm only crop up when it is way too late to fix.
- lapnitnelav 8y agoIt's more than purely testing[0], it's a lack of self-awareness. I remember seeing marketing / engagement material targeting worldwide customers and using American football as the illustration. Wrong kind of football if you're aiming beyond NA. [0] Not to detract from the skin colour issues we've seen countless examples of, like the example you mentioned or the Google Photo fail https://news.sky.com/story/google-photo-app-labels-black-couple-gorillas-10353994 https://news.sky.com/story/google-photo-app-labels-black-cou...
- la_barba 8y agoThere is lots of discussion to be had here, including that analog signal degradation is linear while a digital signal simply 'vanishes' if the SNR gets below a threshold. I suppose you could alternatively keep the existing analog infrastructure and apply an ECC to the analog signal too.