4 ms·
It /is/ as crazy as it sounds. To make Drax seem "carbon neutral" you have to pretend that it's fine if the Carbon spends time in the form of CO2 the atmosphere
by tialaramex 8y ago
It /is/ as crazy as it sounds. To make Drax seem "carbon neutral" you have to pretend that it's fine if the Carbon spends time in the form of CO2 the atmosphere, causing global warming, rather than in a bunch of mature trees because hey, it's the same carbon. But that's exactly the thing we were trying to prevent, we're not worried about running out of carbon, we're worried we're heating the planet up.
- rory096 8y agoIs there reason to believe they're using old-growth trees rather than managed forests? I would guess the former are more valuable in actual wood products.
- hjek 8y agoFrom what I can read here[0], I get the impression that turning unmanaged forests into managed forests is itself a threat to biodiversity: > These Southeastern coastal forests in the US are home to bears, endangered red wolves, salamanders and a number of bird species as well as many endemic plants. According to a 2015 report by the National Resources Defense Council, the potential pellet sourcing area for existing and proposed pellet mills includes “critical habitat for 25 species that are federally listed as endangered or imperilled”. The area has been classified as a biodiversity hotspot, meaning that it contains an unusually high level of biodiversity (2000 endemic species in all) and that it is threatened. The threats here come from forest degradation and fragmentation, caused by urbanisation and ‘forest industries’ such as biomass. [0]: https://www.biofuelwatch.org.uk/2018/pellets-introduction/ https://www.biofuelwatch.org.uk/2018/pellets-introduction/
- astrodust 8y agoValuable to whom? What if they're old trees but not suitable for lumber products, but are perfectly fine shredded up into chips and thrown into furnaces? Without protection everything's a useful asset to someone.
- pkulak 8y agoThe idea is that if you cut a tree down and burn it, the tree that grows in its place will just soak the carbon right back up again. When trees die and rot, the carbon gets released too.
- briffle 8y agoApparently, you haven't been to the west coast of the US in the summer, when lightning, dryness, etc all works together to release millions of acres of CO2 per summer..
- Roboprog 8y agoTrue, despite the down vote(s) It’s a natural process, but still dirty and wasteful.