4 ms·
What exactly are you suggesting here? What's the fundamental problem that Google is managing instead of fixing, once and for all?
by TulliusCicero 8y ago
What exactly are you suggesting here? What's the fundamental problem that Google is managing instead of fixing, once and for all?
- harryf 8y agoDiscovery. From a technical point of view search doesn’t have to be centralized. Economics and the nature of markets may say different though
- TulliusCicero 8y agoMaybe I'm just dumb, but I'm not following. How could they solve discovery once and for all, instead of managing it? I don't see how decentralization would permanently solve discovery. I can see how it could be useful in other ways, but you'd still be managing an ongoing problem.
- EpicEng 8y agoI _think_ the GP's point is that Google is "managing" discovery, i.e., if Google were to up and disappear we would have a large problem on our hands. If search were decentralized then no single entity could bring it down.
- TulliusCicero 8y agoI mean, there are a bunch of other search engines out there, and I still don't see how having even more would somehow 'solve' search for good.
- Draiken 8y agoI think Google is way more than just "search". No other engine knows everything about you. Knows what you read, what you dislike, your appointments, your travels, etc. While there are alternatives for search, it's only search. Everything else is scattered. Google lives and breathes through the mesh of services they offer. Search is at the core, but everything attached to it is what makes Google so different. It is a scary prospect IMO. We already sold our souls to it whether we like it or not. We live on our tech bubble and perhaps try to make better choices but it will never happen to the majority. Most of what I said can also be said about Facebook, with the social network at the centre instead.
- TulliusCicero 8y agoOkay. This has absolutely nothing to do with my original question, though, so I'm not sure why you put it here.
- bduerst 8y agoAny decentralized information system will suffer tragedy of the commons as bad actors exploit it's usefulness (imagine the SEO garbage), or have the vacuum of power filled by a few centralized players. Before you say, "Bitcoin did it!", just look at the block size debacle or the fact that it's mostly controlled by a handful of Chinese miners.